Bibliometric and Altmetric Analysis of Retracted Articles on COVID-19

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Background: With greater use of social media platforms for promotions of research articles, retracted articles tend to receive approximately the same attention. We systematically analyzed retracted articles from retractionwatch.com to look at the Altmetric Attention Scores (AAS) garnered over a period of time in order to highlight the role of social media and other platforms in advertising retracted articles and its effect on the spread of misinformation.
Methods: Retractionwatch.com was searched for coronavirus disease 2019 related retracted papers on November 6th, 2021. Articles were excluded based on lack of digital object identifier (DOI), if they were preprint articles, absent AAS, and incomplete AAS of pre retraction, post retraction, or both scores.
Results: A total of 196 articles were found on the Retraction Watch website of which 189 were retracted papers and 7 were expression of concern (EOC). We then identified 175 articles after excluding those that did not have a DOI and 30 preprint articles were also excluded giving 145 articles. Further exclusion of articles with absent AAS and incomplete AAS resulted in a total of 22 articles.
Conclusion: Retracted articles receive significant online attention. Twitter and Mendeley were the most popular medium for publicizing retracted articles, therefore more focus should be given by journals and their Twitter accounts to discredit all their retracted articles.
Preprints should be reconsidered as a whole by journals due to the huge risk they carry in disseminating false information.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Li HO, "YouTube as a source of information on COVID-19 : a pandemic of misinformation?" 5 (5): e002604-, 2020

2 Moylan EC, "Why articles are retracted : a retrospective cross-sectional study of retraction notices at BioMed Central" 6 (6): e012047-, 2016

3 Prieto Curiel R, "Vaccination strategies against COVID-19 and the diffusion of antivaccination views" 11 (11): 6626-, 2021

4 Alsobayel H, "Use of social media for professional development by health care professionals : A crosssectional web-based survey" 2 (2): e15-, 2016

5 Tang Y, "Unwrap citation count, Altmetric Attention Score and Mendeley readership status of highly cited articles in the top-tier LIS journals" 69 (69): 653-664, 2020

6 BMJ, "Top cited articles"

7 Kambhampati SB, "Top 50 cited articles on Covid-19 after the first year of the pandemic : a bibliometric analysis" 15 (15): 102140-, 2021

8 Househ M, "The use of social media in healthcare : organizational, clinical, and patient perspectives" 183 : 244-248, 2013

9 PLOS, "The role of retractions in correcting the scientific literature - Speaking of Medicine and Health"

10 Johnson NF, "The online competition between pro-and anti-vaccination views" 582 (582): 230-233, 2020

11 The New York Times, "The most influential spreader of coronavirus misinformation online"

12 Fraser N, "The evolving role of preprints in the dissemination of COVID-19 research and their impact on the science communication landscape" 19 (19): e3000959-, 2021

13 Zimba O, "Social media platforms : a primer for researchers" 59 (59): 68-72, 2021

14 Dunn AG, "Social media interventions for precision public health : promises and risks" 1 (1): 47-, 2018

15 Goel A, "Social media in the times of COVID-19" 26 (26): 220-223, 2020

16 Gaur PS, "Social media for scholarly communication in Central Asia" 1 (1): 152-157, 2020

17 Zimba O, "Social media for research, education and practice in rheumatology" 40 (40): 183-190, 2020

18 Ventola CL, "Social media and health care professionals : benefits, risks, and best practices" 39 (39): 491-520, 2014

19 Retraction Watch, "Retracted coronavirus (COVID-19) papers"

20 Soltani P, "Retracted COVID-19 articles : a side-effect of the hot race to publication" 125 (125): 819-822, 2020

21 David CC, "Reliance on Facebook for news and its influence on political engagement" 14 (14): e0212263-, 2019

22 Haldule S, "Post-publication promotion in rheumatology : a survey focusing on social media" 40 (40): 1865-1872, 2020

23 Ahmed S, "Perception about social media use by rheumatology journals : survey among the attendees of IRACON 2019" 15 (15): 171-174, 2020

24 Gasparyan AY, "Monitoring information flow on coronavirus disease 2019(COVID-19)" 31 (31): 243-246, 2020

25 Ganatra Keya ; Gasparyan Armen Yuri ; Gupta Latika, "Modern Health Journalism and the Impact of Social Media" 대한의학회 36 (36): 1-5, 2021

26 Keller B, "Mind the gap : social media engagement by public health researchers" 16 (16): e8-, 2014

27 Serghiou S, "Media and social media attention to retracted articles according to Altmetric" 16 (16): e0248625-, 2021

28 Khan Hiba ; Gasparyan Armen Yuri ; Gupta Latika, "Lessons Learned from Publicizing and Retracting an Erroneous Hypothesis on the Mumps, Measles, Rubella (MMR) Vaccination with Unethical Implications" 대한의학회 36 (36): 1-5, 2021

29 Kavadichanda C, "Journal metrics : different from author metrics" 15 (15): 149-154, 2020

30 Gupta Latika ; Gasparyan Armen Yuri ; Misra Durga Prasanna ; Agarwal Vikas ; Zimba Olena ; Yessirkepov Marlen, "Information and Misinformation on COVID-19: a Cross-Sectional Survey Study" 대한의학회 35 (35): 1-11, 2020

31 Nature Index, "Google Scholar reveals its most influential papers for 2021"

32 King A, "Fast news or fake news? The advantages and the pitfalls of rapid publication through pre-print servers during a pandemic" 21 (21): e50817-, 2020

33 "Eric Topol on Twitter: “Debunking another myth, the mRNA vaccines didn’t just suddenly appear in 2020for covid-19. Many had been tested years previously for other viruses; status as of 4 years ago in this Table, and shown to be safe …”"

34 Candal-Pedreira C, "Does retraction after misconduct have an impact on citations? A pre-post study" 5 (5): e003719-, 2020

35 LSE, "Despite concerns, COVID-19 shows how social media has become an essential tool in the democratisation of knowledge"

36 Kouzy R, "Coronavirus goes viral: quantifying the COVID-19 misinformation epidemic on Twitter" 12 (12): e7255-, 2020

37 Ecker UK, "Can you believe it? An investigation into the impact of retraction source credibility on the continued influence effect" 49 (49): 631-644, 2021

38 Banerjee D, "COVID-19 as an “Infodemic” in public health: critical role of the social media" 9 : 610623-, 2021

39 Brüssow H, "COVID-19 : vaccination problems" 23 (23): 2878-2890, 2021

40 Informa UK Limited, an Informa Group Company, "Author services: how to measure research impact"

41 Altmetric, "Altmetric Attention Score in context"

42 Udawatta M, "Age-related differences in social media use in the neurosurgical community : a multi-institutional study" 180 : 97-100, 2019

43 Teixeira da Silva JA, "Adjusting the use of preprints to accommodate the ‘quality’ factor in response to COVID-19" 16 (16): 477-481, 2021

44 Journalist’s Resource, "Academic journals, journalists perpetuate misinformation in handling research retractions"

45 Anderson C, "Academic journal retractions and the COVID-19 pandemic" 12 : 21501327211015592-, 2021

46 Lentzen MP, "A retrospective analysis of social media posts pertaining to COVID-19 vaccination side effects" 40 (40): 43-51, 2022