Statutory Rape in Korea: Do Teens have the Legal Capacity to give Consent to Sex?

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Protection and regulation of youth sex is a sensitive and complex issue in Korea. The Korean Penal Code criminalizes any person who, with no force or threat, obtained consensual intercourse with a minor under thirteen years old. Consensual intercourse with a juvenile aged thirteen or older is not an offense unless consent was acquired through fraudulent means or by means of force. Therefore, a perpetrator, who obtained intercourse without fraud or exercise of power with a minor aged thirteen or older, is not being punished. A multitude of cases has embarrassed Korean society and has fueled debate over the age of consent.
This article discusses the age of consent under the Korean statutory rape law. After giving an overview in Part I of this paper, Part II is providing a primer of statutory rape under Korean Criminal Law articulating legislative intent, related principles, and the critiques of the statutory rape law. Part III discusses the issue of juveniles’ capacity to consent to sexual intercourse focusing on whether they should be recognized as legally capable of making decisions based on sexual autonomy. Part III contends that the age of consent must be raised to protect juveniles from sexual abuse. Part IV proposes possible solutions for a balance between juveniles’ sexual autonomy and the government’s protection.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 김한균, "형법상 의제강간죄의 연령기준과 아동·청소년의 성보호" 한국형사법학회 25 (25): 105-132, 2013

2 정은경, "의제강간죄 연령상향의 타당성에 대한 연구" 한국형사정책연구원 27 (27): 1-27, 2016

3 이덕인, "위계에 의한 아동․청소년 간음죄에서의 ‘위계’의 의미" 한국형사법학회 28 (28): 255-277, 2016

4 최은하, "위계 또는 위력에 의한 미성년자간음죄(형법 제302조)에서 ‘위계’의 해석 - 성적 강요죄(독일형법 제177조)의 관점에서 -" 한국비교형사법학회 17 (17): 177-200, 2015

5 장경순, "십대 미혼모의 임신 및 출산 경험" 한국아동간호학회 14 (14): 186-194, 2008

6 송숙형, "소아·청소년 성폭력 피해의 실태：원스톱 지원센터 대상자를 중심으로" 대한소아청소년 정신의학회 19 (19): 162-167, 2008

7 류부곤, "미성년자 등 간음죄에 있어서 ‘위력’의 의미" 한국형사법학회 25 (25): 133-156, 2013

8 조국, "강간죄 및 미성년자 등에 대한 위계간음죄 재론(再論)" 한국형사법학회 28 (28): 91-122, 2016

9 "http://library.scourt.go.kr/base/eng/SCD/eng__judg_view.jsp"

10 Jin-Tae Kim, "a law-maker, statement in the minutes of hearing, Amendment Bill of Criminal Act: Hearing on Bill Number 1901590 and 1901742 Before the Legislature and Judiciary Committee, 19th National Assembly, 311th second hearing held on Nov. 22, 2012"

11 "[Editorial]Getting tough on sex crimes"

12 Kuk Cho, "The Under-Protection of Women under Korean Criminal Law" 22 : 119-121, 2008

13 Han-Kyun Kim, "The System is tough on Sex Crimes"

14 Jeong-A Chun, "The Raise of Age of Consent in Statutory Rape for the Protection of Juveniles’ Sexuality" 2015

15 조국, "The Exclusion of Illegally Obtained Confessions, Electronic Communication and Physical Evidences in Korea" 아시아태평양법연구소 13 (13): 175-217, 2014

16 "Supreme Court, 92Do2345, July 27, 1993"

17 "Supreme Court, 2014Do9288, Nov. 13, 2014"

18 "Supreme Court, 2012Do7377, Aug. 20, 2012"

19 "Supreme Court, 2012Do14788, May 16, 2013"

20 "Supreme Court, 2010Do14487, Apr. 28, 2011"

21 "Supreme Court, 2008Do4069, July 24, 2008"

22 "Supreme Court, 2005Do6791, Jan. 13, 2006"

23 "Supreme Court, 2004Do5868, July 29, 2005"

24 "Supreme Court, 2002Do2029, July 24, 2002"

25 "Supreme Court, 2001Do5074, Dec. 24, 2001"

26 "Seongpokryeok beomjoeoeu cheobeol deungeo gwanhan beobryul [Act on Special Cases Concerning the Punishment, Etc. of Sexual Crimes] Act No. 10258, Apr. 15, 2010, art. 7, Amended by Act No. 12889, Dec. 30, 2014"

27 Mi-Gyeong Lee, "Review on the Standard of Sexual Violence Beyond Age"

28 Jong-Heu Hong, "Review on the Raise of Age of Consent in Statutory Rape"

29 Lim Jeong-yeo, "Policemen get away after having sex with teenagers"

30 No Jun-cheol, "Of the two school police officers who had sexual intercourse was one prosecuted without detention and the other not charged"

31 "N.Y. Penal Law §130.05(3)(a)(McKinney 2004)"

32 "Minsa sosong beop [Civil Procedure Act], Act No. 547, Apr. 4, 1960, amended by Act No. 12882, Dec. 30, 2014, art. 322"

33 "Minbeop [Civil Act], Act No. 471, Feb. 22, 1958, amended by Act No. 13125, Feb. 3, 2015, art. 322"

34 Kim Yon-se, "Man Cleared of assault charge on 15-year-old girl"

35 Lee Han-Soo, "Lawmaker pushes for statutory rape age increase"

36 "Hyeongbeob［Criminal Act］Act No. 293, Sep. 18, 1953, art. 297 amended by Act No. 11574, Dec. 18, 2012"

37 "Hyeongbeob [Criminal Act]"

38 "Hyeogsa sosong beop [Criminal Procedure Act], Act No. 341, Sept. 23, 1954, amended by Ac. No. 13454, Jul. 31, 2015, art. 159"

39 "Geunro gijun beop [Labor Standard Act], Act No. 5309, Mar. 13, 1997, amended by Act No. 12527, Mar. 24, 2014, art. 64"

40 Seong-Don Kim, "Criminal Law(4th ed)"

41 Kim, Seong-Don, "Criminal Law(3d ed)"

42 "Constitutional Court, 2013Hun-Ba107, Feb. 26, 2015"

43 "Constitutional Court, 2008Hun-Ba58, Nov. 26, 2009"

44 Ji-seung Kim, "Children from Poor Families More Likely to Be Targets of Sexual Crimes"

45 "Cheongsonyeon-Gibon-Beop［Framework Act on Juveniles］, Act No. 4477, Dec. 31, 1991, amended by Act No. 13180, Feb 3, 2015, art. 7"

46 "Cheongsonyeon boho beop [Juvenile Protection Act], Act No. 5297, Mar. 7, 1997, amended by Act No. 14967, Mar. 3, 2016, art. 24"

47 Da-sol Kim, "Changing Definition of Korean Family"

48 "Cal. Penal Code §261.5"

49 "AgeOfConsent home page"

50 "Adong cheongsonyeon seong bohooe gwanhan beoblyul [Act on the Protection of Children and Juveniles against Sexual Abuse] Act No. 9765, July 9, 2009, art. 7, Amended by Act No. 12361, Jan. 28, 2014"

51 이수진, "13세 이상 미성년자의 성적 자기결정권" 한국비교형사법학회 17 (17): 117-145, 2015