도시철도 노선의 비용구조 분석 = The Cost Structure of the Lines of Urban Railway

국문 초록 (Abstract)

본 연구는 우리나라 공공기관이 운영하는 대도시의 도시철도 노선에 대하여 비용 비효율성의 정도를 도출하고, 이러한 비효율성의 발생 원인을 파악하고자 하였다. 이를 위하여 도시철도 노선을 노동, 동력, 유지보수의 세 가지 생산요소를 투입하여 열차-km의 산출물을 생산하는 형태로 상정하고, 확률적 비용변경 접근법을 이용한 초월대수 함수형태의 가변비용함수모형을 설정하였다. 확률적 비용변경 접근법을 적용한 도시철도 노선의 운영비용 비효율성 분석 결과, 노선 전체의 6년간 절감가능 비용은 약 6,672억원으로 추정되었으며, 비효율성이 높은 상위 5개 노선은 부산1호선, 대구1호선, 대전1호선, 광주1호선, 대구2호선으로 파악되었다. 비효율의 발생원인은 노동과 유지보수 요소에 기인하며, 본 연구의 결과를 활용하면, 도시철도 운영에 있어서의 인력 및 유지보수 비용 절감을 위한 대책의 우선순위와 구체적인 방안 모색에 있어 참고가 가능할 것이라 사료된다.

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The purpose of this study is to estimate the degree of cost inefficiency for the urban railway lines of a metropolitan city operated by public institutions in Korea and identify the causes of this inefficiency. To this end, we assume that the urban railway lines produce the output of train-km by putting three production factors of labor, electric power and maintenance and set the variable cost function model with the translog function to make a stochastic cost frontier analysis. Based on estimated result, we conclude that the cost savings for 6 years of all lines are about 6,672 hundred million won and top five lines with high inefficiency are Busan Line1, Daegu Line1, Daejeon Line1, Gwangju Line1, and Daegu Line2. The causes of inefficiency are attributable to labor and maintenance factors. The results of this study can be useful in case of finding the priorities of measures and specific plans for reducing labor and maintenance costs in the urban railway operation.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 김민정, "확률적 비용변경접근법을 이용한 도시철도 운영기관의 효율성과 생산성 분석 (자료포락분석기법을 이용한 추정결과와의 비교를 중심으로)" 대한교통학회 23 (23): 15-25, 2005

2 박진경, "확률적 비용변경 접근법을 이용한 한국과 일본 철도산업의 효율성과 생산성 분석" 대한교통학회 25 (25): 141-157, 2007

3 박진경, "일반초월대수 비용함수모형을 이용한 한국 철도산업의 규모 및 범위의 경제성 분석" 대한교통학회 22 (22): 159-173, 2004

4 Christensen, L. R., "Transcendental logarithmic production frontiers" 55 (55): 28-45, 1973

5 Suh, S. D., "The estimation of the operating cost function for korea regional railroad" The Korea Transport Institute 1996

6 Kim, Y. H., "The estimate of cost function of busan urban transit authority and seoul metropolitan subway corporation:Focused on Economies of Scale and Density" Seoul National University 2004

7 Viton, P. A., "Once again, The costs of urban rapid transit" 27 (27): 401-412, 1993

8 Jondrow, J., "On the estimation of technical inefficiency in the stochastic frontier production function model" 19 (19): 233-238, 1982

9 Lee, J. K., "MICROECONOMICS" Bobmunsa 2002

10 Schmidt, P., "Estimating technical and allocative efficiency relative to stochastic production and cost frontiers" 9 (9): 343-366, 1979

11 Mizutani, F., "Does vertical separation reduce cost? An empirical analysis of the rail industry in European and East Asian OECD Countries" 43 (43): 31-59, 2012

12 김수현, "DEA를 활용한 도시철도 노선별 수송효율성 분석" 대한토목학회 34 (34): 605-616, 2014

13 유경상, "DEA 기법을 활용한 도시철도 운영효율성 분석에 관한 연구" 서울연구원 13 (13): 237-246, 2012

14 Song, J. Y., "Cost structure of the korean urban bus transit industry: An Application of the Fourier Flexible Functional Form" Seoul National University 2014

15 Incheon Transit Corp, "Business report" 2007

16 Daejeon Express Transit Corp, "Business report" 2007

17 Busan Transportation Corp, "Business report" 2007

18 Seoul Metropolitan Rapid Transit Corp, "Business report" 2007

19 Gwangju Metropolitan Transit Corp, "Business report" 2007

20 Daegu Metropolitan Transit Corp, "Business report" 2007

21 Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport, "Appraisal guidelines of transportation investments"

22 Seoul Metropolitan Rapid Transit Corp, "Annual accounts" 2007

23 Gwangju Metropolitan Transit Corp, "Annual accounts" 2007

24 Seoul Metro, "Annual accounts" 2007

25 Daegu Metropolitan Transit Corp, "Annual accounts" 2007

26 Incheon Transit Corp, "Annual accounts" 2007

27 Daejeon Express Transit Corp, "Annual accounts" 2007

28 Busan Transportation Corp, "Annual accounts" 2007

29 Bae, Y. S., "Analyzing the economies of scale and scope in Korean Railways Industry" Seoul National University 1998

30 Kim, J. K., "An empirical study on efficient structure by cost characteristics analysis of railway industry : by using Data of Seven Countries Owning High-Speed Rail" Seoul National University 2013

31 Kim, H. W., "A study on the efficiency of korean railway transport service using data envelopment analysis" Seoul National University of Technology 2010

32 Kim, S. Y., "A study on efficiency and productivity of Korea railroad lines: Focused on marketing, Operation of KORAIL" Sunchon National University 2013

33 Ha, H. K., "A study on cost characteristics in Korean Railroad Industry" The Korea Transport Institute 2002

34 Kim, M. J., "A stochastic frontier cost approach to the analysis of cost structure of the seoul's rail transit industry:Deriving Optimal Fare Levels and the Efficient Number of Firms" Seoul National University 2000

35 Olson, J. A., "A monte carlo study of estimators of stochastic frontier production functions" 13 (13): 67-82, 1980

36 Park, J. S., "A development of the operating cost models for urban railways" Hanyang University 2007