The Developmental Welfare State and Social Policy: Shifting From Basic to Universal Social Protection

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Most people would agree that developing countries should advance from basic, informal, and insecure welfare provision toward universal, formal,and secure welfare regimes. This article examines how analytical concepts of developmental statehood and developmental welfare statehood might be applied to this issue. In particular, how is it possible to combine economic and social development objectives in a mutually beneficial manner? The article reviews the history of both concepts and some of their shortcomings; examines policy features of developmental (welfare) statehood, focusing on the examples of South Korea and four other countries that have frequently been referred to as “East Asian welfare regimes”; and explores some policy options for developing countries seeking to expand their economic and social policy-making capabilities.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Shin, J.-S., Routledge 2003

2 Hwang, S.-J., "Zur kapitalistischen Entwicklung und Kapitalismus-Debatte in Südkorea" Frankfurt am Main: Peter Lang 1994

3 ILO, "World social security forum—building a “social security floor” worldwide where growth can meet equity"

4 Parsons, A. D., "World Bank poverty figures: What do they mean?"

5 Brütt, C., "Workfare als Soziales. Zur Arbeitsmarkt- und Sozialpolitik der Groβen Koalition. In Die Groβe Koalition: Regierung-Politik-Parteien 2005-2009, ed" 123-141, 2010

6 Verdery, K., "What was socialism, and what comes next?" Princeton University Press 1996

7 Kwon, H.-j., "Transforming the developmental welfare state in East Asia" 36 (36): 477-497, 2005

8 UNRISD, "Transformative social policy: Lessons from UNRISD research" UNRISD 5 : 2006

9 Aspalter, C., "Towards a human capital welfare state? In search of win-win solutions" 6 (6): 1-46, 2007

10 Esping-Anderson, G., "The three worlds of welfare capitalism" Princeton University Press 1990

11 Cypher, J. M., "The process of economic development. 3rd ed" Routledge 2009

12 Kasza, G. J., "The illusion of welfare “regimes”" 31 (31): 271-287, 2002

13 Polanyi, K., "The great transformation: The political and economic origins of our time" Beacon Press 1967

14 Kwon, H.-j., "The future challenges of the developmental welfare state: The case of Korea"

15 Valli, V., "The economic ascent of a technological power: South Korea" Department of Economics “S. Cognetti de Martiis,” Universitá di Torino 2010

16 Johnson, C., "The developmental state: Odyssey of a concept. In The developmental state, ed" Cornell University Press 32-60, 1999

17 Amsden, A. H., "The Rise of “The Rest”: Challenges to the West from Late-Industrializing Economies" Oxford University Press 2001

18 Aspalter, C., "The East Asian welfare model" 16 : 290-301, 2006

19 Hamilton, G. G., "Taiwan’s industrialisation: The rise of a demand-responsive economy" Brill 3 : 95-131, 2008

20 Wu, Y.-S., "Taiwan’s developmental state: After the economic and political turmoil" 47 (47): 977-1001, 2007

21 Dore, R., "Stock market capitalism: Welfare capitalism. Japan and Germany versus the Anglo-Saxons" Oxford University Press 2000

22 Cumings, B., "State building in Korea: Continuity and crisis. In States and development:Historical antecedents of stagnation and advance, ed" Palgrave 211-235, 2005

23 Sumarto, S., "Social safety nets: Indonesia" Overseas Development Institute 2006

24 Cook, S., "Social protection in East and South East Asia: A regional review"

25 Mishra, R., "Social protection by other means: Can it survive globalisation? In A handbook of comparative social policy, ed" Edward Elgar 68-88, 2004

26 Cook, S., "Social protection and inclusive growth: The critical like between protection and production" 2010

27 Casey, B. H., "Social pensions and policy learning: The case of southern Africa" 62 (62): 81-102, 2009

28 Dore, R., "Shareholder capitalism comes to Japan. Working Paper in Technology Governance and Economic Dynamics 11, The Other Canon Foundation,Norway, and Tallinn University of Technology"

29 Adesina, J. O., "Rethinking the social protection paradigm: Social policy in Africa’s development. In Strategies for social protection in the global multi-crises, ed" Graduate School of Public Administration 7-32, 2010

30 ESCAP, "Regional trends and emerging issues in the field of social development, particularly social protection for the most vulnerable social groups" ESCAP 2010

31 Holliday, I., "Productivist welfare capitalism: Social policy in East Asia" 48 (48): 706-723, 2000

32 Kiely, R., "Poverty reduction through liberalisation? Neoliberalism and the myth of global convergence" 33 (33): 415-434, 2007

33 Ito Peng, "Postindustrial Pressures, Political Regime Shifts, and Social Policy Reform in Japan and South Korea" 동아시아연구원 4 (4): 389-426, 2004

34 Kasza, G. J., "One world of welfare: Japan in comparative perspective" Cornell University Press 2006

35 Eckert, C. J., "Offspring of empire: The Koch’ang Kims and the colonial origins of Korean capitalism 1876-1945" University of Washington Press 1945

36 박찬웅, "Making Sense of the Asian Welfare Regimes with the Western Typology" 한국사회학회 43 (43): 57-86, 2009

37 Johnson, C., "MITI and the Japanese Miracle: The Growth of Industrial Policy, 1925-1975" Stanford University Press 1975

38 ILO, "Issue paper for session 4: Social security policies for social cohesion and economic development"

39 Riesco, M., "Is global welfare and a global New Deal possible?"

40 Kwon, H.-j., "Introduction: Social policy and economic development in late industrializers" 18 : 1-11, 2009

41 Chang, H.-J., "Industrial policy: Can we go beyond an unproductive confrontation?" 2009

42 Kim, B.-s., "IT industry development and policy tools in Korea. In Global and national strategy for poverty reduction, ed" Graduate School of Public Administration 15-35, 2009

43 Blyth, M., "Great Transformations: Economic Ideas and Institutional Change in the Twentieth Century" Cambridge University Press 2002

44 Wade, R., "Governing the market: Economic theory and the role of government in East Asian industrialization" Princeton University Press 1990

45 Yusuf, S., "Freeing the world of poverty. In Development economics through the decades: A critical look at 30 years of the World Development Report, ed" World Bank 19-49, 2009

46 NPF, "Establishment of the pension system in Taiwan"

47 ILO, "Employment growth and basic needs: A one-world problem" ILO 1976

48 Lee, Y.-J., "East Asian welfare regimes: Testing the hypothesis of the developmental state" 41 (41): 197-212, 2007

49 MSF, "Corporate restructuring promotion law legislated"

50 Kim, E. M., "Contradictions and limits of a developmental state: With illustrations from the South Korean case" 40 (40): 228-249, 1993

51 Evans, P. B., "Constructing the 21st century developmental state: Potentialities and pitfalls. In Constructing a democratic developmental state in South Africa: Potentials and challenges, ed" HSRC Press 37-58, 2010

52 UNRISD, "Combating poverty and inequality: Structural change, social policy and politics" UNRISD 2010

53 Hamilton, C., "Capitalist industrialization in Korea" Westview Press 1986

54 Chang, D.-o., "Capitalist development in Korea: Labour, capital and the myth of the developmental state" Routledge 2009

55 Timmer, M., "Capital formation and foreign direct investment in Korea and Taiwan: Coping with diminishing returns?"

56 Hagemejer, K., "Can low-income countries afford basic social security? In Promoting pro-poor growth: Social protection, ed" OECD 89-109, 2009

57 Kim, Y.-M., "Beyond East Asian welfare productivism in South Korea" 36 (36): 109-125, 2008

58 GESS, "Basic social protection package"

59 Wade, R., "After the crisis: Industrial policy and the developmental state in low-income countries" 1 (1): 150-161, 2010

60 Wood, G., "A comparative welfare regime approach to global social policy" 34 (34): 1696-1712, 2006