국제투자법상 투자의 개념과 가상화폐의 지위 = The Definition of Investment under International Investment Law and the Status of Cryptocurrencies

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The use of cryptocurrencies(virtual currencies) has exploded across the world in recent years, however, the term that refers to this new asset has not been settled yet. In addition, investment in cryptocurrencies has also been growing over the past years, and it raises the question whether cryptocurrencies could be protected under the international investment regime. In other words, it is questionable whether the investment in cryptocurrencies could be classified as “investment” under international investment law, and as investment disputes concerning investment in cryptocurrencies are likely to be raised soon, it is important to look at the definition of investment and the legal status of cryptocurrencies under the existing investment law. Thus, this article examines the characteristics of cryptocurrencies, and then analyzes the definition of investment under the investment treaties and arbitral awards. Several elements, including territorial link, that are controversial particularly in the case of cryptocurrencies are examined in order to find out whether the investment in cryptocurrencies itself might be fitted into the definition of investment. However, investment in cryptocurrency-related entities, institutions, or funds, which is similar to investment in foreign companies, is not addressed in this paper. Overall, it might not be able to give a definite answer to this question as the investment in cryptocurrencies can be made in various ways. Yet, it is likely that the investment in cryptocurrencies could be classified as investments under the international investment regime except in cases where the investors are only holding deposits of the cryptocurrencies in foreign cryptocurrency exchanges or financial institutions. Nevertheless, since the features of cryptocurrencies are constantly evolving, it is necessary to understand their features and the most important thing to consider would be how the relevant investment treaties define the term “investment”.

목차 (Table of Contents)

• Ⅰ. 서 론 Ⅱ. 가상화폐와 해외투자 Ⅲ. 가상화폐 관련 해외투자가 국제투자법상 “투자”에 해당할 수 있는지 여부 Ⅳ. 결 론

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 정순섭, "중앙은행 디지털화폐(CBDC) 관련 법적 이슈 및 법령 제·개정 방향"

2 이명활, "주요국의 CBDC 관련 논의 및 시사점" 한국금융연구원 28 (28): 16-, 2019

3 정대형, "국제결제은행의 화폐 분류에 따른 디지털 화폐의 유형별 특징 및 시사점" 산업은행 미래전략연구소 (762) : 38-39, 2019

4 정래원, "“유엔 전문가패널 위원”북한, 가상화폐 해킹·돈세탁 정교화"

5 한국은행, "“암호자산(crypto-assets)”이라는 용어를 사용하였으며, 다수의 국가와 국제기구에서 암호자산이라는 용어가 점차 많이 이용될 것으로 예상된다"

6 Tom Miles, "Venezuela launches WTO challenge to U.S. sanctions"

7 Julian Davis Mortenson, "The Meaning of Investment: ICSID's Travaux and the Domain of International Investment Law" 51 (51): 298-, 2010

8 Christoph Schreuer, "The ICSID Convention: A Commentary" Cambridge University Press 2009

9 Alex Grabowski, "The Definition of Investment under the ICSID Convention: A Defense of Salini" 15 (15): 298-, 2014

10 Aashna Agarwal, "Status of Cryptocurrencies under Investment Law: Not so Cryptic Anymore?" 7 (7): 1-3, 2019

11 UNCTAD, "Scope and Definition: A Sequel"

12 "Salini Costruttori S.p.A. and Italstrade S.p.A. v. Kingdom of Morocco [I] (Decision on Jurisdiction), [200I] ICSID Case No. ARB/00/4, para. 52"

13 "Republic of Korea v. Mohammad Reza Dayyani & 5 ors , [2019] EWHC 3580(Comm), paras. 53-54"

14 "Quiborax S.A., Non Metallic Minerals S.A. and Allan Fosk Kaplún v. Plurinational State of Bolivia (Decision on Jurisdiction) , [2012] ICSID Case No. ARB/06/2, para. 220"

15 Rudolf Dolzer, "Principles of International Investment Law" OUP 61-, 2012

16 "Poštová banka, a.s. and ISTROKAPITAL SE v. Hellenic Republic (Award) , [2015] ICSID Case No. ARB/13/8, para. 361"

17 "Plama Consortium Limited v. Bulgaria(Award) , [2008] ICSID Case No. ARB/03/24, paras. 138-139"

18 "Phoenix Action, Ltd. v. The Czech Republic (Award) , [2009] ICSID Case No. ARB/06/5, para. 85"

19 Kei Nakajima, "Parallel Universes of Investment Protection? A Divergent Finding on the Definition of Investment in the ICSID Arbitration on Greek Sovereign Debts" 15 (15): 485-, 2016

20 Santiago Rodriguez Senior, "Investor State Arbitration for Central Bank Digital Currencies: The Future of Investment Disputes" IE Law Hub

21 Stratos Pahis, "Investment Misconceived: The Investment-Commerce Distinction in International Investment Law" 45 (45): 2020

22 Paata Simsive, "Investing in Cryptocurrencies under the Existing Investment Arbitration Regime" Kluwer Arbitration Blog

23 Krista Schefer, "International Investment Law: Text, Cases and Materials" Edward Elgar 84-, 2016

24 "Inceysa Vallisoletana S.L. v. Republic of El Salvador(Award) , [2006] ICSID Case No. ARB/03/26, paras. 190-207"

25 "ICSID 협약 제25조 제1항"

26 김병연, "ICO의 법적 개념 및 각국의 규제동향에 관한 연구" 법학연구소 (43) : 29-50, 2019

27 "Fraport AG Frankfurt Airport Services Worldwide v. The Republic of the Philippines(Award) , [2007] ICSID Case No. ARB/03/25, para. 401"

28 Felix O. Okpe, "Endangered Element of ICSID Arbitral Practice: Investment Treaty Arbitration, Foreign Direct Investment, and the Promise of Economic Development in Host States" 13 (13): 258-, 2014

29 Julien Chaisse, "Cybersecurity and the Protection of Digital Assets: Assessing the Role of International Investment Law and Arbitration" 21 (21): 570-, 2019

30 Aveek Chakravarty, "Challenges to the Assessment of Damages Claims Involving Crypto-Assets in Investment Arbitration" 20 (20): 7-, 2020

31 Arnaud Mehl, "Central bank digital currency in an open economy"

32 Morten Bech, "Central Bank Crytocurrencies"

33 조지원, "CBDC 발행 계획 없어…신중론 재확인한 한은"

34 Armand Terrien, "Blockchain and Cryptocurrencies: The New Frontier of Investment Arbitration?" Kluwer Arbitration Blog

35 UNCTAD, "Bilateral Investment Treaties 1995-2006: Trends in Investment Rulemaking"

36 David Collins, "Applying the Full Protection and Security Standard of International Investment Law to Digital Assets" 12 (12): 227-, 2011

37 "Alasdair Ross Anderson et al v. Republic of Costa Rica (Award) , [2010] ICSID Case No. ARB(AF)/07/3, paras. 48-50"

38 "Abaclat and Others v. Argentine Republic (Decision on Jurisdiction and Admissibility) , [2011] ICSID Case No. ARB/07/5, para. 374"