정책유형에 따른 정책 네트워크 구조 비교분석 = A Comparative Study on Policy Network Structure by Policy Types

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This study deduce the premise that policy network structure will appear different depending on policy types to explain relation between policy network and policy types persuasively and advance the generalization of policy network research. Policies can be classified by two dimensions 'types of coercion' and 'types of goods' , and eventually into (1) 'distribution policy', (2) 'redistribution policy', (3) 'economic regulation policy' and (4) 'social regulation policy'. For individual review of these policy types, Brain Korea 21 case was selected on distribution policy, comprehensive real estate holding tax case on redistribution policy, MIT-2000 mobile telecommunication business selection case on economic regulation policy, and GMO safety regulation case on social regulation policy. In the meantime, the issue of defining policy network was reviewed through four elements, range, power structure, and relations pattern that existing policy network researchers commonly proposed. In particular, for more objective comparison of network structure, network analysis was applied. In summary, the above analysis can reach such conclusion that the range, power structure, and relation pattern of policy network may vary systematically depending on distribution policy, redistribution policy, economic regulation policy and social regulation policy.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 박한우, "한국어의 내용분석을 위한 KrKwic 프로그램의 이해와 적용 : Daum.net에서 제공된 지역혁신에 관한 뉴스를 대상으로" 한국자료분석학회 6 (6): 1377-1387, 2004

2 김순양, "한국 보건의료 개혁과정에서의 정책 네트워크(Policy Networks) 및 정책산출(Policy Outputs) 분석" 한국정부학회 17 (17): 1063-1096, 2005

3 심원섭, "지역관광개발에 있어서 이해관계자와의정책네트워크가 지자체의 정책성과에 미치는 영향" 한국관광학회 33 (33): 51-68, 2009

4 강은숙, "정책변동의 정책네트워크 이론적 분석: 그린벨트정책을 중심으로" 13 (13): 103-125, 2002

5 박용성, "정책네트워크의 동태적 유형분석에 관한 연구: 한강 및 낙동강 유역정책 수립 및 입법화과정을 중심으로" 739-763, 2004

6 김성제, "정책네트워크와 정책혁신의 확산 : 자동통행요금징수시스템 도입사례 분석" 국토연구원 45 : 75-92, 2005

7 김옥일, "정책네트워크 변화에 관한 연구" 317-352, 2008

8 송희준, "이동통신 정책네트워크와 사업자선정의 상호관계에 관한 연구" 한국정책학회 11 (11): 359-384, 2002

9 류영아, "육아휴직제 4차 개정과정의 정책네트워크 분석" 한국정책과학학회 10 (10): 229-255, 2006

10 이용갑, "민간의료보험 활성화 정책 결정과정 연구 - 국민건강보험의 보장성 강화와 민간의료보험의 활성화 논쟁 분석 -" 한국보건사회학회 (26) : 5-39, 2009

11 김영종, "노동정책형성과정의 합의주의와 정책네트워크분석: 비정규직보호법의 제정과정을 중심으로" 한국정책과학학회 11 (11): 51-82, 2007

12 김경주, "김대중 정부의 모성보호정책네트워크 분석" 한국행정학회 37 (37): 23-44, 2003

13 박용성, "경유상용차 배출허용기준 적용유예사례 연구" 395-415, 2007

14 Miller, H. T., "Weber's ActionTheory and Lowi's Policy Types in Formulation, Enactment, and Implementation" 18 : 887-905, 1990

15 Marks, G., "Unions in Politics: Britain, Germany, and the United States in the Nineteenth and Early Twentieth Centuries" Princeton University Press 1989

16 Smith. T. A., "Toward a Comparative Theory of the Policy-Process" 1 (1): 498-515, 1969

17 Collins, R., "Theoretical Sociology" Harcourt Brace Jovanovich 1988

18 Moore, G., "The Structure of a National Elite Network" 44 : 673-691, 1979

19 Schneider, V., "The Structure of Policy Networks" 21 : 109-129, 1992

20 Hayes, M. T., "The Semi-Sovereign Pressure Groups: A Critique of Current Theory and an Alternative Typology" 40 (40): 134-161, 1978

21 Bressers, J. Th. A., "The Selection of Policy Instruments: A Network-Based Perspective" 18 (18): 213-239, 1998

22 Wilson, J. Q., "The Politics of Regulation" Basic Books 1980

23 Laumann, E. O., "The Organizational State: A Perspective on National Energy and Health Domains" University of Wisconsin Press 1987

24 Salamon, Lester M, "The Illusion of Presidential Government" Westview Press 1981

25 Heinz, J. P., "The Hollow Core: Private Interest in National Policy making" Harvard University Press 1993

26 Heckathorn, D., "The Contractual Architecture of Public Policy: A Critical Reconstruction of Lowi's Typology" 52 (52): 1101-1123, 1990

27 Hart, H. L. A., "The Concept of Law" Oxford 1961

28 Fiedkin, N., "Structural Cohesion and Equivalence Explanations of Social Homogeneity" 12 : 235-261, 1984

29 Atkinson, M. M., "Strong States and Weak States:Sectoral Policy Networks in Advanced Capitalists Economies" 19 : 48-67, 1989

30 Knoke, D., "Sociology and the Public Agenda" Sage 164-184, 1992

31 Mayntz, R., "Societal Change Between Market and Organization" Avebury 3-18, 1991

32 Erickson, B., "Social Structures: A Network Approach" Cambridge University Press 1988

33 Spitzer, R. J., "Social Regulatory Policy" Westview Press 1987

34 Wasserman, S, "Social Network Analysis: Method and Application" Cambridge 1994

35 Kelman, Steven, "Regulation That Works"

36 Kellow, A., "Promoting Elegance in Policy Theory: Simplifying Lowi's Arenas of Power" 16 (16): 713-724, 1988

37 Smith, Martin J., "Pressure, Power, and Policy. State Autonomy and Policy Networks in Britain and the United States" Harvester Wheatsheaf 1993

38 Schattschneider, E. E., "Politics, Pressures, and the Tariff" Prentice-Hall 1935

39 Knoke, D., "Political Networks: The Structural Perspective" Cambridge University Press 1990

40 Do¨hler, M., "Policy Networks: Empirical Evidence and Theoretical Considerations" Westview Press 235-298, 1991

41 Cope, S., "Policy Network in Criminal Justice" Palgrave 2001

42 Cawson, A., "Organized Interests and the State: Studies in Meso-Corporatism" Sage 1985

43 Rhodes R. A. W., "New Directions in the Study of Policy Networks" 21 : 181-205, 1992

44 Burt, R. S., "Network items and the general society survey" 6 : 293-340, 1984

45 Dowding, K., "Model or Metaphors? A Critical Review of the Policy Network Approach" 43 (43): 136-158, 1995

46 Daugbjerg, C., "Linking Policy Networks and Environmental Policies:Nitrate Policy Making in Denmark and Sweden 1970-1995" 76 : 275-294, 1998

47 Heinz, J. P., "Inner Circles or Hollow Cores" 52 (52): 356-390, 1990

48 Lowi, T. J., "Four Systems of Policy, Politics, and Choice" 32 (32): 298-310, 1972

49 Howlett, M., "Do Policy Networks Matter? Linking Policy Network Structure to Policy Outcomes: Evidence from Four Canadian Policy Sectors 1990-2000" 35 : 235-267, 2002

50 Kjellberg, F., "Do Policies (Really) Determine Politics? And Eventually How?" 5 (5): 554-570, 1977

51 Waarden, F. V., "Dimensions and types of policy networks" 21 : 29-52, 1992

52 Browne, W. P, "Cultivating Congress: Constituents, Issues, and Interest in Agricultural Policy Making" University Press of Kansas 1995

53 Burt, R. S., "Corporate Profits and Cooperation: Networks of Market Constraints and Directorate Ties in the American Economy" Academic 1983

54 Ripley, R, "Congress, Bureaucracy, and Public Policy" The Dorsey Press 1976

55 Daugbjerg, C., "Comparing PolicyNnetworks: Policy Networks in Theoretical and Comparative Perspective" Open University Press 1998

56 Marsh, D, "Comparing Policy Networks: Policy Networks in Theoretical and Comparative Perspective" Open University Press 1998

57 Knoke, D, "Comparing Policy Networks: Labor Politics in the U.S., Germany, and Japan" Cambridge University Press 1996

58 Salisbury, R. H., "Austin Ranney" Markham 1968

59 Laumann, E. O., "Applied Network Analysis: A Methodological Introduction" Sage 18-34, 1983

60 Lowi, T. J., "American Business, Public Policy, Case Studies, and Political Theory" 16 : 667-715, 1964

61 Baumgartner, F. R., "Agendas and Instability in American Politics" University of Chicago Press 1993

62 Jordan, G., "A Preliminary Ordering of Policy Network Labels" 21 : 7-27, 1992

63 Montpetit, É., "A Policy Network Explanation of Biotechnology Policy Difference between the United States and Canada" 25 (25): 339-366, 2005