입법자의 입법형성권의 내용과 한계 = Contents and Limitations of Legislative Formation Power of lawmakers

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

“Legislative Formation Power” is lawmakers`s freedom of choice following their rationality, when they make law, which contents are regulated. The rationality means the most teleologicalist regulation among the several possibility of regulations. However, there is limitations of legislative formation power. First, as substantive limits, it can be divided into constitutional principle and constitutional contents. In nest thing, as procedural limits, it can be classified into constitution and the national assembly law and congressional autonomy. Legislative formation power of lawmakers must to be respected and be controled by other national agencies. There are 4 sections to be respected and be controled. First, Legislative formation power of lawmakers is respected by constitutional court on variant decisions such as decision incompatible with the constitution. Second, in judging standard of rights of equality “principle of the prohibition of one`s own will”, legislative formation power of lawmakers is largely accepted. Third, when the lawmakers make not the law, relating the duty of legislation, constitutional court can notify their duty of legislation to them. Fourth, as regards intensity of control of constitutional court, legislative acts are diversely controled.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 권형준, "立法裁量論에 관한 硏究" 한국헌법학회 12 (12): 495-522, 2006

2 권영성, "헌법학원론" 법문사 2010

3 배준상, "헌법재판소와 입법권자" 한양대학교 법학연구소 9 : 21-49, 1992

4 허영, "헌법이론과 헌법" 박영사 2011

5 허완중, "헌법실무연구 제11권" 박영사 321-348, 2010

6 이부하, "헌법상 평등원칙에 대한 심사기준" 법학연구소 19 (19): 263-287, 2011

7 남복현, "헌법불합치결정의 사례분석에서 나타난 한정적 청구와 한정적 판단의 필요성 검토" 2010

8 허영, "한국헌법론" 박영사 2011

9 한수웅, "평등권의 구조와 심사기준" 9 : 41-106, 1998

10 이발래, "입법형성권의 본질과 한계" 5 : 229-247, 2000

11 St. Detterbeck, "Vorrang und Vorbehalt des Gesetzes"

12 J. Isensee, "Vorbehalt der Verfassung - Das Grundgesetz als abschließende und als offene Norm, In Freiheit und Eigentum" FS für Walter Leisner 359-, 1999

13 J. Isensee, "Subsidiaritätsprinzip und Verfassungsrecht" 1968

14 St. Huster, "Rechte und Ziele" 1993

15 H.-U. Gallwas, "Grundrechte" 1995

16 K. Hesse, "Diskussionsbeitrag, In Der Gleichheitssatz im modernen Verfassungsstaat" 75-78, 1981

17 F. Ossenbühl, "Die Kontrolle von Tatsachenfeststellung und Prognoseentscheidungen durch das BVerfG, In BVerfG und GG I" 484-,

18 G. Müller, "Der Gleichheitssatz" 47 : 37-, 1989