노조 미가입 근로자의 근로자대표제도 인식에 대한 영향요인 연구: 노동조합과 노사협의회 관계를 중심으로 = Factors Affecting Non-union Workers' Perceptions of Employee Representation Systems in Korea

국문 초록 (Abstract)

이 연구에서는 한국노동연구원의 한국노동패널조사 결과를 활용하여 근로자대표제도에 대한 근로자들의 인식변화에 대한 분석을 실시하였다. 2005년과 2013년 조사에 대해 둘 다 응답한 자를 대상으로 살펴본 결과, 조합원과 비조합원 집단 모두에서 인식수준이 낮아진 것으로 나타났다. 이는 노동조합 조직률 정체상태, 소규모 사업장 대표성 한계 등이 향후에도 계속될 수 있음을 시사한다. 한편, 2013년 패널조사 결과를 이용하여 노동조합 미가입 근로자들의 근로자대표제도 인식요인을 분석한 결과, 근로자 직무만족도가 높을수록 노동조합뿐 아니라 노사협의회에 대한 필요성 인식이 낮아졌다. 또한 근로조건 개선 등에 있어 노동조합의 역할, 즉 노조수단성이 높을수록 노사협의회 필요성에 정(+)의 영향을 미치고, 노사협의회가 있는 사업장의 경우 노동조합 필요성에 정(+)의 영향을 미치는 것으로 나타났다. 이는 노동조합과 노사협의회의 관계에 대한 근로자들의 인식이 대체적이기보다는 보완적일 수 있음을 시사한다.

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This paper analyzes the perceptions held by workers about employee representation systems such as labor unions and works councils, using data from the Korean Labor and Income Panel Studies of 2005 and 2013. Superficially, data from the 1,301 respondents completing both surveys shows that perceptions of representation systems have worsened not only among non-union workers, but amongst union workers as well over the period. This finding suggests the stagnation in union density will continue for some time. Yet when examining the particular factors effecting perceptions held by non-union workers from the 2013 panel data, the labor instrumentality variable positively affected the favorability of respondents to work councils, and furthermore, employees working at a workplace with works councils responded positively to the necessity of labor unions. This finding indicates a potentially complementary relationship between works councils and labor unions, with works councils potentially expanding into the space left by the abatement of unions.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 김유선, "한국의 노동조합 조합원수 증감요인 분석" 16 : 287-312, 2001

2 이영면, "성공적인 노사협의회 운영의 영향요인에 대한 연구" 한국노동연구원 9 (9): 83-118, 2009

3 노용진, "무노조기업 내 근로자의 의사결정참여와 노조가입 의사" 181-203, 2007

4 오계택, "동조합과 노사협의회의 관계: 대체재인가 보완재인가" 409-431, 2007

5 이시균, "노동조합 가입성향 결정요인과 대표권의 갭-근로자의의사결정참여와 노조가입 의사" 204-228, 2007

6 이영면, "글로벌 금융위기 이후 고용형태와 노동조합조합원 여부에 따른 노동조합 우호도 변화에 관한 연구" 128-145, 2014

7 Rogers, J., "Works Councils :Consultation. Representation, and Corporation in Indu.stria! Relations" University of Chicago Press 3-26, 1995

8 Freeman, B. R., "Works Councils : Consultation, Representation, and Cooperation in Industrial Relations" University of Chicago Press 27-50, 1995

9 Hammer, W. C., "Work Attitudes as Predictors of Union Activity" 63 (63): 415-421, 1978

10 Brett, Jeanne M., "Why Employee Want Unions" 8 (8): 273-282, 1980

11 Charlwood, A., "Why Do Nonunion Employees Want to Unionize? Evidence from Britain" 40 (40): 463-491, 2002

12 Freeman, R. B., "What Workers Want" Cornell University Press 1999

13 Glick, William, "Union Satisfaction and Participation" 16 (16): 145-151, 1977

14 Helfen, M., "Uncovering Divergence :Management Attitudes towards HRM Practices and Works Council Presence in German SMEs" 20 (20): 207-240, 2009

15 Kochan, T. A., "The Transformation of American Industrial Relations" Basic Books 1986

16 Appelbaum, E., "The New American Workplace : Transforming Work Systems in the United States" ILR Press 1994

17 Montgomery, R. B., "The Influence of Attitudes and Normative Pressures on Voting Decisions in a Union Certification Election" 42 (42): 262-279, 1989

18 McClendon J. A., "The Individual Decision to Unionize" 23 (23): 34-54, 1998

19 Youngblood, S. A., "The Impact of Work Environment, Instrumentality Beliefs, Perceived Labor Union Image, and Subjective Norms on Union Voting Intentions" 27 (27): 576-590, 1984

20 Pil, F. K., "The Adaption of HIgh Involvement Work Practices" 35 (35): 423-455, 1996

21 Terry, M., "System of Collective Employee Representation in Non-union Firms in the UK" 30 (30): 16-30, 1999

22 Gollan., P. J., "So What's the News? Management Strategies towards Nonunion Employee Representation at News International" 33 (33): 316-331, 2002

23 Bamberger, Peter A., "Research Notes : The Antecedents and Consequences of Union Commitment : A Meta-Analysis" 42 (42): 304-318, 1999

24 Kaufman, B. E., "Nonunion Employee Representation :History, Contemporary Practice, and Policy" M. E. Sharpe 2000

25 Schriesheim, Chester A., "Job Satisfaction, Attitude toward Unions and Voting in a Union Representation Election" 63 (63): 548-552, 1978

26 Premack, S. L., "Individual Unionization Decisions" 103 (103): 223-234, 1988

27 Kochan, Thomas A., "How American Workers View Labor Unions" 22 (22): 23-31, 1970

28 Cappelli, P., "High Performance Work Practice Improve Establishment Level Outcomes?" 54 (54): 737-775, 2001

29 Kaufman, B. E., "Finding a Voice at Work? New Perspectives on Employment Relations" Oxford University Press 278-299, 2014

30 Bigoness, William J., "Correlates of Voting Behavior in a Union Decertification Election" 27 (27): 654-659, 1984

31 Brewster, C., "Are Works Councils and Joint Consultative Committees a Treat to Trade Union? A Comparative Analysis" 28 (28): 49-77, 2007

32 Gordon, Michael, "A Re-Examination of the Relationship between Union Membership and Job Satisfaction" 48 (48): 222-236, 1995

33 DeCotiis, T. A., "A Predictive Study of Voting Behavior in a Representation Election Using Union Instrumentality and Work Perceptions" 27 (27): 103-118, 1981

34 Kim, Dong-One, "A Comparison of the Effectiveness of Unions and Non-union Works Councils in Korea: Can Non-union Employee Representation Substitute for Trade Unionism?" 15 (15): 1069-1093, 2004

35 고용노동부, "2013년 노조조직률은 10.3%로 전년과 동일"