영국의 근로복지(Workfare) 개혁에 관한 연구: 노동당의 이념적 변화를 중심으로

국문 초록 (Abstract)

본 논문은 영국 블레어 정부의 근로복지 개혁이 유럽대륙 국가의 개혁과는 다른 한편으로, 미국식 신자유주의적 재편과도 다른 성격을 가지고 발전하게 된 배경을 살펴보고 그 원인을 규명할 목적을 가지고 작성되었다. 이러한 목적을 달성하기 위해서, 근로복지형 제도의 도입과정을 영국 노동당의 이념적 변화, 특히 당헌 제4조의 개정을 둘러싸고 나타난 당내(黨內) 좌ㆍ우파간의 갈등과 타협을 통해서 신노동당 프로젝트가 성립되는 과정에 초점을 맞추어 설명하고자 한다. 따라서 제2장에서는 영국 노동당의 제3의 길과 신노동당 프로젝트를 중심으로 노동당의 이념적 변화를 살펴보고, 이러한 변화의 핵심이라고 할 수 있는 ‘권리와 의무의 상호주의 원칙’을 추출한다. 그리고 제3장에서는 이러한 상호주의 원칙이 1997년 집권 이후 전개되고 있는 영국의 근로복지 개혁에 어떻게 반영되어 나타나는 가를 살펴본다. 그리고 제4장에서는 영국의 근로복지 개혁이 유럽대륙 국가와 다른 한편으로, 미국식 근로복지 개혁과도 다르게 전개되는 배경과 그 원인을 영국의 독특한 정치질서에서 찾고, 특히 노동당의 이념적 체질변화 과정에서 확립된 상호주의 원칙이 근로복지 개혁을 지도하였기 때문이라는 결론을 도출한다

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This study purports to explain the difference between the welfare reform of Britain and that of either European countries or USA. For this purpose, Chapter two documents and reviews the inter-party debates around the Clause Four in the Labour Constitution, and duly ascertains the role of the reciprocity principle in the development of New Labour Project. Then, Chapter three argues that this reciprocity principle guides and controls the whole process of workfare reform of the Labour Government since 1997. Finally, Chapter four concludes that the salient features of the British workfare reform originated from recent changes of the British political climates, that is, the ideological change of the Labour Party.

목차 (Table of Contents)

• 요약
  
• 1. 서론
  
• 2. 제3의 길과 신노동당 프로젝트
  
• 3. 노동당 정부에서의 근로복지 개혁
  
• 4. 결론: 상호주의의 원칙과 근로복지 개혁
  
• 참고 문헌
  
• 영문 초록

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Jon Sopel, "토리 블레어 : 새로운 영국의 미래=Tony Blair : the Moderniser" 당대 1997

2 문진영, "제3의 길의 함의와 전망" 143 : 7-19, 1999

3 Noberto Bobbio, "제3의 길은 가능한가 : 좌파냐 우파냐=Destra e Sinistra : Ragioni e significati di una distinzione politica" 새물결 1998

4 양재진, "세계화 신보수주의 그리고 미국 사회복지개혁" 2 : 16-29, 2002

5 김영순, "미국 영국 한국의 근로연계복지 비교연구" 196-219, 2002

6 Marquand, "edited by D" 219-230, 1994

7 Kavanagh, "edited by B" 240-267, 1991

8 Latham, "edited by A" 25-35,

9 Peck. J, "Workfare States" The Guilford Press 2001

10 Wright, T, "Why Vote Labour" Penguin 1997

11 "Why I am a Christian" 1996April

12 McCrate, E, "When Work Does Not Work : The Failure of Current Welfare Reform" 12 (12): 61-80, 1998

13 Evers, "Understanding the Pluralism of Welfare Systems New Welfare Mixes in Care for the Elderly edited by A" 3-31, 1993

14 Esping-Andersen, G, "Towards the Good Society Once Again" Oxford University Press 1-25, 2002

15 Johnson,N, "The Welfare State in Transition:The Theory and Practice of Welfare Pluralism" Harvest Wheatsheaf 1987

16 Briggs, "The Welfare State in Historical Perspective in The Collected Essays of Asa Briggs Volume II edited by A The University of Illinois Press" 177-211, 1985

17 Giddens, A, "The Third World : The Renewal of Social Democracy" Polity 1998

18 "The Third Way : New Politics for the New Century" The Fabian Society 1998

19 "The Road to the Good Society" 13 (13): 25-27, 2000

20 London, "The Radical Coalition A Speech at a Fabian Society Commemoration of the Fiftieth Anniversary of the 1945 General Election" 1995July

21 Macmillan,H, "The Middle Way" Macmillan 1938

22 Harmer, H, "The Labour Party 1900-1998" Longman 1999

23 Hayek,F, "The Constitution of Liberty" The University of Chicago Press 1960

24 Cox, "The Consequences of Welfare Reform How Conceptions of Social Rights are Changing Journal of Social Policy 27" 1-16,

25 Norton, P, "The British Polity" Longman 1984

26 "The Battle against Exclusion Volume 3 : Social Assistance in Canada and Switzerland" OECD 1999

27 OECD, "The Battle against Exclusion Volume 2 : Social Assistance in Belgium the Czech Republic the Netherlands and Norway" OECD 1998

28 Walker, R, "The Americanization of British Welfare : A Case Study of Policy Transfer" 19 : 32-40, 1998

29 Kavanagh,D, "Thatcherism and British Politics:The End of Consensus? 2nd ed" Oxford University Press 1990

30 Callaghan,J, "Socialism in Britain since 1884" Basil Blackwell 1990

31 Eardley, T, "Social Assistance in OECD Countries : Synthesis Report" HMSO 46 : 1996

32 Rodes, M, "Restructuring the British Welfare State: Between Domestic Constraint and Global Imperatives" Oxford University Press 19-68, 2000

33 Jessop, B, "Regulation Theories in Restropect and Prospect" 19 (19): 153-216, 1990

34 MacMurray, "Persons in Relation" Humanities Press 19611979

35 Bryson, A, "Permanent Revolution : the Case of Britain's Welfare-to-work Regime" 11 (11): 11-17, 2003

36 Peck, J, "New Labourers Making a New Deal for the Workless Class" 17 : 345-372, 1999

37 Fielding, S, "New Labour and 1945?" 45 (45): 11-14, 1995

38 Driver, S, "New Labour : Politics after Thatcherism" Polity Press 1998

39 Department of Work and Pensions, "New Deal for Young People and Long-term Unemployed People aged 25+ Statistics" Department of Work and Pensions 2003

40 HMSO, "New Ambitions for Our Country : A New Contract for Welfare" HMSO 3805 : 1998

41 Grover, C, "Market Welfare : Social Security Social Regulation and Competitiveness in the 1990s" 28 (28): 73-96, 1999

42 Philpott, J, "Lessons from America: Workfare and Labour's New Deal" Institute of Economic Affairs 65-79, 1997

43 Heron, "Labour's Attempt to Forge a New Welfare Deal Between the Individual and the State" 91-104,

44 Mulgan, G, "Is UK Welfare Reform a Copycat Exercise" 19-30, 1998

45 Etzioni, A, "How to Make a Humane Market" 11 (11): 25-27, 1998

46 Holden, C, "Globalization Social Exclusion and Labour's New Work Ethics" 19 (19): 529-538, 1999

47 Deacon, A, "From Welfare to Work : Lessons from America" Institute of Economic Affairs 1997

48 Finn, D, "From Full Employment to Employability : A New Deal for Britain's Unemployed" 21 (21): 384-399, 2000

49 King, "From Clinton to Blair Origins of Welfare to Work" 62-74,

50 2nd ed, "Freedom in the Modern World" Faber & Faber Press 19681974

51 Peck, J, "Exporting Workfare/Importing Welfare to Work : Exploring the Politics of Third Way Policy Transfer" 20 : 427-460, 2001

52 Kay, J, "Evolutionary Politics" 28 (28): 31-35, 1998

53 Titmuss, R, "Essays on The Welfare State" George Allen and Unwin 1976

54 Scharpf, F, "Economic Changes, Vulnerabilities, and Institutional Capabilities" Oxford University Press 21-124, 2000

55 Guttman, A, "Democracy and Disagreement" The Belknap Press 1996

56 Kern, W, "Current Welfare Reform : A Return to the Principles of 1834" 32 (32): 427-432, 1998

57 Nyta, M, "Blair Set for Clause Four Victory" 8 (8): 7-8, 1995

58 Teles, S, "Be Ware the Clinton Welfare Trap" 10 (10): 22-23, 1997

59 "A Speech to the Labour Conference" 2003September

60 "A Speech to the Congress of Socialist Parties" 1997bJune

61 "A Speech to Labour Party Conference" -2, 1994

62 "A Speech at the Aylesbury Estate" 1997aJune

63 Yang, J, "A Critical Appraisal of the US Workfare Program : Policy Implications for the Korean Public Assistance Program" 16 (16): 77-89, 2002