Development Cooperation as a Foundation of Japan's Foreign Policy

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This paper addresses the question of what do Japanese foreign policymakers exactly mean when they repeatedly state that development cooperation has been, and still is, a foundation of postwar Japanese foreign policy, through a case study of Japan's official development assistance (ODA) towards China. More particularly, it investigates the complex policy objectives of Japanese ODA and the broader interests behind it, in order to clarify roles and significance of development assistance within Japan's overall foreign policy. My research demonstrates that despite its inherently economic nature, Japan's ODA provision to recipient countries has in application been more politico-strategic than commercial. Thus, it supports the point that development cooperation has undoubtedly been a foundation of postwar Japanese foreign policy.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Beeson, Mark, "nstitutions of the Asia-Pacific: ASEAN, APEC and beyond" London and New York: Routledge 2009

2 Kojima,Tomoyuki, "Zaisei kiki no naka no kokubōhi zōdai(The Increase in Chinese Defence Expenditure in the Budget Crisis)." 54-75, 1991

3 Hasegawa, Keitarō, "Yōsō no chōtaikoku Chūgoku (Myth of Superpower China)" Tokyo: Tokuma shoten 1995

4 Katada,Saori N, "Why Did Japan Suspend Foreign Aid to China? Japan's Foreign Aid Decision-making and Source of Aid Sanction" 4 (4): 39-58, 2001

5 Brown,Lester, "Who Will Feed China?" New York:Norton 1995

6 "Wagakuni no seifu kaihatsu enjo 1994 (Japan's ODA 1994)" Economic Cooperation Bureau, Ministry of Foreign Affairs 1994

7 Clarke,Duncan L, "US Security Assistance to Egypt and Israel:Politically Untouchable?." 51 (51): 200-214, 1997

8 Poats,Rutherford M, "Twenty-five Years of Development Cooperation:A review" OECD 1986

9 Ikenberry,G.John, "The Rise of China and the Future of the West." 87 (87): 23-37, 2008

10 Takamine, Tsukasa, "The Political Economy of Japanese Foreign Aid: The Role of Yen Loans in China's Economic Growth and Openness" 79 (79): 29-48, 2006

11 Krugman,Paul, "The Myth of Asia's Miracle." 73 (73): 62-78, 1994

12 Wright-Neville,David., "The Evolution of Japanese Foreign Aid 1955-1990. Monograph No. 2" Melbourne: Monash Development Studies Centre 1990

13 Orr,Robert M, "The Emergence of Japan's Foreign Aid Power." Columbia University Press:New York 1990

14 Herbert Yee, "The China Threat: Perceptions, Myths and Reality" London, New York: RoutledgeCurzon 1-19,

15 Nakane,Chie, "Tekiō no jōken:Nihonteki renzoku no shikō(Conditions of Adaptation:Japanese Thought)." Tokyo:Kōdansha 1972

16 Kusano, Atsushi, "Taigaienjyo ni kakawaru taisei no henka to sono haikei (Changes in the Foreign Aid System and Its Background)" JAIR 2008

17 Hiramatsu,Shigeo, "Tai-Chū ODA,gun-min ryōyō no jittai(The Military-Civilian Dual Use of Japanese ODA by China)." 6-21, 2000

18 "Tai-Chū ODA no keizaiteki shakaiteki inpakuto ni tsuite no kisoteki chōsa(Basic Research on the Economic and Social Impact of China ODA).Unpublished report.Tokyo" JIIA 2000

19 Nihon kokusai mondai kenkyūjo, "Tai-Chū ODA no keizai sakai inpakuto ni tsuiteno kisoteki chōsa (Basic Research on the Economic and Social Impact of China ODA)"

20 Duckett,Jane, "Tackling Unemployment in China:State Capacity and Governance" 21 (21): 211-230, 2008

21 Tow,William T, "Sino-Japanese Security Cooperation:Evolution and Prospects." 56 (56): 51-83, 1983

22 Kidera,Masato, "Sechō jūshi no enjyo moderu wo sekaihe(Spreading Development-centred Aid Model to the world)." 36-41, 2008

23 "Saikin no Chūgoku jōsei to Nitchū kankei (Current Chinese Affairs and Japan-China Relations)" Gaimushō Chūgoku-ka (China Division, Ministry of Foreign Affairs) 2000

24 Shimomura, Yasutami, "ODA taikō no seiji keizai gaku (Political Economy of the ODA Charter)" Tokyo: Yūhikaku 1999

25 Sumi,Kazuo, "ODA enjo no genjitsu(Reality of ODA)." Tokyo:Iwanami shinsho 1989

26 "ODA Targets Slipping Out of Reach?" OECD

27 Kazan-kai, "Nitchū keizai kyōryoku no shin-dankai:Chūgoku no gendaika to enshakkan o megutte(The New Phase of Japan-China Economic Cooperation:Regarding Chinese Modernisation and the Yen Loans)." 1980

28 Tanaka,Akihiko, "Nitchū kankei 1945-1990(Japan-China Relations 1945-1990)." Tokyo: Tōkyō daigaku shuppan-kai. 1991

29 Inada,Jūichi, "Nihon gaikō ni okeru enjo mondai no shosokumen(Several Aspects of Foreign Aid Issues in Japanese Diplomacy)." 2-20, 1987

30 Murai, Yoshinori, "Musekinin enjo taikoku Nihon (Japan as an Irresponsible Foreign Aid Power)" Tokyo: JICC shuppan-kyoku 1989

31 Levy,Wendy, "Major Returns to Local Firms in Aid to China" 2 (2): 13-14, 1993

32 Komori,Yoshihisa, "Machigai darake no Chūgoku enjo(Japan's Mistaken China Aid)" 94-109, 2002

33 Abe,Junichi, "Kaiyō o mezasu Chūgoku no gunji senryaku(China's Military Strategy Aiming at the Ocean)." 58-73, 1996

34 Inoguchi,Takashi, "Kaibutsu Chūgoku ni dō tsukiau noka?(How Should We Deal with a Monster China?)." 7 (7): 34-45, 1996

35 Kawashima,Yutaka, "Japanese Foreign Policy at The Crossraods:Challenges and options for the Twenty-First Century." Washington,D.C.:Brookings Institution Press 2003

36 Ōkita,Saburō, "Japan,China and the United States:Economic Relations and Prospects." 57 (57): 1090-1110, 1979

37 Peng Er and Lam, "Japan's Relations with China: Facing a Rising Power" London and New York: Routledge

38 Peng Er, Lam, "Japan's Relations with China: Facing a Rising Power" London and New York: Routledge

39 Economic Cooperation Bureau.2000.Japanese Ministry of Foreign Affairs,Japan's Official Development Assistance Annual Report, "Japan's Official Development Assistance Annual Report 1999" Japanese Ministry of Foreign Affairs 2000

40 Economic Cooperation Bureau, "Japan's ODA 1998" Ministry of Foreign Affairs 1999

41 "Japan's ODA 1993" Ministry of Foreign Affairs 1994

42 "Japan's ODA 1990" Ministry of Foreign Affair 1991

43 Inoguchi, Takashi, "Japan's International Relations" Boulder: Westview Press 1991

44 Rix,Alan, "Japan's Economic Aid:Policymaking and Politics." London:Croom Helm 1980

45 Kesavan,K.V, "Japan and the Tiananmen Square Incident:Aspects of the Bilateral Relationship." 30 (30): 669-681, 1990

46 "Japan" NIDS 1999

47 "Interview with Yoshihide Soeya"

48 "Interview with Yoshihide Soeya"

49 "Interview with Ryōsei Kokubun"

50 "Interview with Jūichi Inada"

51 Interview with F, "Interview with F"

52 Interview with F, "Interview with F"

53 Saori N. Katada, "Gloabal Governance: Germany and Japan in the International System" Aldershot and Burlington: Ashgate

54 Mōri Kazuko, "Gendai Chūgoku no kōzō hendō (Structural Change in Contemporary China)" Tokyo: Tōkyō daigaku shuppan- kai.

55 Murai,Yoshinori, "Gaimushō no ODA rinen o tou?(Question the ODA Philosophy of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs?)" 315-324, 1992

56 Hirohisa Kohama, "External Factors for Asian Development" Singapore: Institute of Southeast Asian Studies.

57 Takamine,Tsukasa, "Domestic Determinants of Japan's China Aid Policy:The Changing Balance of Foreign Policymaking Power." 22 (22): 191-206, 2002

58 Ensign,Margee M, "Doing Good or Doing Well? Japan's Foreign Aid Program." New York:Columbia University Press 1992

59 IMF(International Monetary Fund), "Direction of Trade Statistics" Washington DC: IMF. 2003

60 Schrader, Peter J, "Clarifying the Foreign Aid Puzzle: A Comparison of American, Japanese, French, and Swedish Aid Flows" 50 (50): 294-323, 1998

61 Hiramatsu,Shigeo, "Chūgokugun o tsuyokusuru ODA(The ODA which Makes the Chinese Military Stronger)" 152-160, 2000

62 Amako,Satoshi, "Chūgoku,Tenanmon jiken to sōgō kokuryoku(China,the Tiananmen Square Incident and Comprehensive National Power)" 146-151, 2001

63 Nakajima,Mineo, "Chūgoku wa kyōi ka?(Is China a Threat?)" 1-18, 1997

64 Amako Satoshi, "Chūgoku wa kyōi ka? (Is China a Threat?)" Tokyo: Keisō shobō.

65 Yanai,Shinichi, "Chūgoku to no keizai kyōryoku ni tsuite(Japanese Economic Cooperation with China).A record of lecture given by the then Director of Gaimushō keizai kyōryoku kyoku(Economic Cooperation Bureau of the Foreign Ministry)." 79-81, 1980

66 Chūgoku sōran henshū iinkai, "Chūgoku sōran 1998" okyo: Zaidan hōjin kazankai. 1998

67 Chūgoku sōran henshū iinkai, "Chūgoku sōran 1978" Tokyo: Zaidan hōjin kazankai

68 Kojima,Tomoyuki, "Chūgoku no seiji to gaikō wa fukuzatsu sakusō(Complicated Chinese Politics and Diplomacy)." 60-, 1996

69 Takagi,Seiichirō, "Chūgoku no keizai taikoku ka to taigai kankei(China as an Emerging Economic Power and its Foreign Relations)." 60-76, 1994

70 Hiramatsu, Shigeo, "Chūgoku no gunji ryoku (China's Miliatry Capability)" Tokyo: Bunshun shinsyo 1999

71 "Chūgoku kunibetsu enjo kenkyū-kai hōkoku-sho: dai niji (Second Report by the China Aid Research Group)" JICA 15-25, 1999

72 JETRO, "Chūgoku deita fairu 1999/2000(China Data File 1999/2000"

73 Whiting,Allen S, "Chinas Use of Force,1950-96,and Taiwan" 26 (26): 103-131, 2001

74 Christensen,Thomas J, "China,the US-Japan Alliance,and the Security Dilemma in East Asia." 23 (23): 49-80, 1999

75 Overholt, William H, "China's Economic Squeeze" 44 (44): 13-34, 2000

76 Narramore,Terry, "China and Europe:Engagement,Multipolarity and Strategy," 21 (21): 87-108, 2008

77 David Arase, "Buying Power: The Political Economy of Japan's Foreign Aid" London: Lynne Rienner Publishers.

78 Arase, David, "Buying Power: The Political Economy of Japan's Foreign Aid" London: Lynne Rienner Publishers 1995

79 Atwood, J. Brian, "Arrested Development: Making Foreign Aid a More Effective Tool" 87 (87): 123-133, 2008

80 Kayahara,Ikuo, "Anzen hoshō kara mita Nitchū kankei(Security Perspective on Japan-China Relations)." 21 (21): 75-96, 2001

81 Morgenthau,Hans, "A Political Theory of Foreign Aid," 56 (56): 301-309, 1962

82 Ampiah,Kweku, "A One Sided Partnership" 28 (28): 2221-2238, 1988

83 Okada,Tomihiro, "2010-nen no Chūgoku keizai zō(The Chinese Economy in 2010)." 21-36, 1994