대학도서관의 외국학술지 평가모형 개발을 평가지표 분석 = Analysis of Evaluation Indicators for the Development of Evaluation Models of Foreign Academic Journals

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The purposes of this study are to compare and analyze the evaluation indicators for selection of journal suggested by scholars and organizations and to prepare theoretical background for the ideal model to meet opposing paradigms of collection management in academic libraries. A web survey method was employed to investigate applications of various selection criteria (27 for printed and 37 for electronic academic Journal) from the top 40 academic libraries in Korea. In addition, data were analysed statistically using factor analysis, t-test, Analysis of Variance(ANOVA), and Spearman's Rank Oder Correlation. The mean ranking for 9 evaluation indicators for printed were as follows: subscribing volumes per departments, degree of use, selection authority, electronic/print bundle, ISI impact factor, Internationality and reputation, costs for subscription, ILL & DDS, space considerations for printed materials. But, 11 evaluation indicators for electronic were as follows: costs for subscription, accessibility, electronic/print bundle, consortia, selection authority, access expandability, subscribing volumes per departments, scholarly features of the university, ISI impact factor, ILL & DDS, internationality and reputations.

국문 초록 (Abstract)

본 연구는 인쇄잡지 중심의 소장 패러다임 대 전자잡지 위주의 접근 패러다임이 대립하는 상황에서 대학도서관의 하이브리드형 학술지 수집정책의 이론적 토대가 되는 평가요소를 분석하여 한국적 실정을 고려한 외국 학술지의 평가모형 개발에 필요한 기초자료를 마련하는데 그 목적이 있다. 구체적으로 질문지법을 통하여 학술지 수집규모 상위 40개 대학도서관의 외국학술지 선정과정에서 예비평가지표(인쇄형 27개, 전자형 37개)의 적용도를 조사하고, 그 데이터를 다양한 통계적기법으로 분석하였다. 인쇄학술지 평가지표의 요인별 상대적 중요성은 응답 평균값으로 산출하였는데 그 결과는 학과당 구독종수, 이용도, 선정권한, 전자학술지 구독조건, ISI 영향지수, 국제성과 지명도, 구독가격, ILL/DDS, 수장공간 순으로 나타났다. 한편, 전자학술지는 구독가격, 접근성, 전자학술지 구독조건, 컨소시엄, 선정권한, 접근확장성, 학과당 구독종수, 대학의 학문적 특성, ISI 영향지수, ILL/DDS, 국제성과 지명도 순으로 나타났다.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 "사회과학 자료분석" 다산출판사 2001

2 "국내학술지 평가에 관한 실험적 연구" 5 : 109-114, 1998

3 "a Survey of North American Academic Lib- raries" 29-46, 1991

4 "Serials Acquisi- tion" 29 (29): 153-161, 1996

5 "Serial Selection Policy" 2003

6 "Serial Policy, Selection Criteria" 2003

7 "Ranking of Na- tions and Heightened Competition in Matthew Core Journal: Two Faces of the Matthew Effect for Countries" 50 (50): 440-460, 2002

8 "Planning for the Balance between Print and Elec- tronic Journals in the Hybrid Di- gital Library: Lessons Learned from Large ARL Libraries" University Of Pitts- burgh 2001

9 "Management of Serials in Libraries" Libraries Unlimited 1998

10 "Journal Selection Criteria for 2003" 2003

11 "Journal Evalu- ation: Technical and Practical Is- sues" 50 (50): 418-439, 2002

12 "Full-Text Database and the Journal Cancellation Pro- cess: a Case Study" 26 (26): 19-31, 2000

13 "Factors to Consider in Evaluating Journals" 2003

14 "Fact Sheet Journal Selection for Index Medicus/MEDLINE" 2003

15 "Fac- tors to Consider in Evaluating Jour- nal" 2003

16 "E-Journal Build- ing and Its Impact on Academic Libraries: Some Early Result" 30 (30): 2001

17 "De- tailed Journal Selection Criteria" 2003

18 "Collec- tion Development Policy State- ment: Electronic Publications" 2003

19 "Col- lection Development Policy: Gene- ral Serial Selection Guidelines" 2003