사용자책임의 요건으로서 사용관계 = Examining the employemnt realtion for employer’s vicarious liability

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

According to art. 756 of the Korean Civil Code, the employer’s vicariousliability presupposes the employment relation betweein her and thewrongdoer. Case law as well as academic doctrine for long time have usedthe control test for this purpose: the employer must have right to orderand supervise the course of the tasks being done. If reviewed critically,however, it is not sure whether other policy considerations are at workbehind the prima facie coherent and stable case law. In this article, theauthor tries to clarify these policy factors from comparative perspective.
He gives an overview of the Korean case law, compares it with thosefrom other jurisdictions (Germany, France and England) and describes hisown suggestions. It is submitted that the control test still plays animportant role, while other elements and circumstances must be taken intoconsideration and that the joint vicarious liability should be accepted incase of transferred employee.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 박수근, "파견근로자의 불법행위와" 2004

2 문영화, "파견근로자보호 등에 관한 법률에 의한 근로자 파견에 있어서 파견사업주가 파견근로자의 파견업무에 관련한 불법행위에 대하여 사용자책임을 부담하는지 여부, In 대법원판례해설, 제47호" 2003

3 이은영, "채권각론" 2007

4 곽윤직, "채권각론" 2003

5 김증한, "채권각론" 2006

6 김형석, "사용자책임의 입법주의 연구- 역사적⋅비교법적 접근 -" 법학연구소 53 (53): 419-482, 2012

7 김형석, "사용자책임에서 사무집행관련성의 판단- 비교법적 연구로부터의 시사 -" 법학연구소 53 (53): 351-418, 2012

8 이상광, "사용자책임론" 1992

9 권용우, "사용자배상책임, In 민법학의 회고와 전망(민법전시행 삼십주년기념논문집)" 1993

10 곽윤직, "민법주해 [XVII]" 박영사 2005

11 곽윤직, "민법주해 [XIX]" 박영사 2005

12 민의원 법제사법위원회 민법안심의소위원회, "민법안심의록, 상권" 상권 1957

13 김형배, "민법 제391조와 제756조를 비교⋅검토함" 1986

14 "未定稿本 民法修正案理由書"

15 엄동섭, "名義貸與者의 損害賠償責任과 求償權" 민사판례연구회 (33) : 541-578, 2011

16 平井宜雄, "債権各論 II: 不法行爲" 1992

17 田上富信, "使用關係, In 新 現代損害賠償法 講座 4" 1997

18 김형배, "使用者責任과 判例 -比較法的 視覺에서-" 법학연구원 (48) : 1-35, 2007

19 Atiyah, "Vicarious Liability in the Law of Torts" 1967

20 Giliker, "Vicarious Liability in Tort. A Comparative Perspective" 2010

21 Viney, "Traité de droit civil, Les conditions de la responsabilité" 2006

22 Markesinis, "Tort Law" 2008

23 Winfield, "Tort" 2002

24 Brun, "Responsabilité civile extracontractuelle" 2005

25 Starck, "Obligations, 1. Responsabilité délikctuelle" 1996

26 "Münchener Kommentar zum Bürgerlichen Gesetzbuch, Band 5"

27 Flour, "Les obligations, 2. Le fait juridique" 2003

28 Terré, "Les obligations" 2009

29 Larenz, "Lehrbuch des Schuldrechts, Band II/2" 1994

30 Julien, "La Responsabilité civile du fait d’autrui. Ruptures et continuités" 2001

31 Staudinger, "Kommentar zum Bürgerlichen Gesetzbuch" 2008

32 von Caemmerer, "Gesammelte Schriften, Band III" 1983

33 Le Tourneau, "Droit de la responsabilité et des contrats" 2004

34 Voirin, "Droit civil, tome 1" 2011

35 Kötz, "Deliktsrecht" 2010

36 Erman, "Bürgerliches Gesetzbuch, Band II" 2011

37 Palandt, "Bürgerliches Gesetzbuch" 2012

38 Weir, "An Introduction to Tort Law" 2006