공과대학생의 팀 기반 수업에서 동료평가와 자기평가의 관계 = Relationships between Peer- and Self-Evaluation in Team Based Learning Class for Engineering Students

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This paper aims to apply two ways of student evaluation, i.e. peer- and self-evaluation to TBL(team based learning) class and to explore the difference between two evaluations by gender and grade as well as their relationships, and finally to provide an explanation for the improvement of evaluation ways in TBL class. There has been much research about TBL and its related factors. However, according to the examination of both domestic and overseas researches concerning the application of peer- and self-evaluation to TBL class, few studies have focused on them in terms of the engineering curriculum. This study was conducted with 251 engineering students at P University, and peer- and self-evaluation in TBL class have been measured. Our findings show that firstly, there were significant grade differences in self-evaluation of engineering students. Second, there were no significant gender and grade differences in peer-evaluation.
Third, we found a significant correlation between the two factors, self- and peer-evaluation. Also there was a significant correlation among variables of subcategories. Based on these findings, it is expected to provide an explanation for the application of peer- and self-evaluation in TBL class and will be useful for the improvement plans of the related courses in engineering school.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 변영계, "협동학습의 이론과 실제" 학지사 1999

2 전성연, "협동학습 모형 탐색" 학지사 2007

3 전영욱, "팀 학습에 영향을 미치는 요인에 관한 구조분석" 한국성인교육학회 12 (12): 115-146, 2009

4 정은실, "팀 구성 방식에 따른 학습활동 만족도: 질적 자료 분석에 의한 사례연구" 한국교육방법학회 22 (22): 67-95, 2010

5 채수진, "의과대학 문제중심학습에서 학생평가방법의 일관성 검토 : 튜터평가, 동료평가, 자기평가를 중심으로" 한국열린교육학회 14 (14): 331-349, 2006

6 이영민, "웹기반 팀 학습환경에서 성격유형에 의한 팀 구성방식이 팀 과제수행력, 팀워크, 상호작용에 미치는 영향" 한국교육공학회 22 (22): 1-21, 2006

7 이동주, "온라인 협동학습 환경에서 동료평가의 역할: 평가자 및 피평가자 경험을 통한 개별 책무성 강화" 원격교육연구소 9 (9): 181-211, 2013

8 이경미, "쓰기과업에서 동료평가가 자기평가에 미치는 영향 : 교육대학원생을 중심으로" 중앙대학교 교육대학원 2010

9 오수학, "수행평가에서 동성 및 이성동료평가 간 차이" 3 (3): 73-79, 2001

10 강경희, "발표 활동에서 예비 과학교사들의 동료평가에 관한 결과와 인식 분석" 교육연구원 25 (25): 261-275, 2009

11 정은이, "문제해결 토의 활동이 대학생의 창의성에 미치는 효과" 교육연구소 10 (10): 27-49, 2009

12 김수진, "문제중심학습에서 평가주체에 따른 평가 - 튜터평가, 동료평가, 자기평가를 중심으로" 한국산학기술학회 14 (14): 3732-3738, 2013

13 강정은, "동료평가를 이용한 개인 기여도 평가에 관한 연구" 건국대학교 대학원 2010

14 조성균, "대학체육 발표수업에서의 동료평가 활용사례 연구" 한국체육교육학회 15 (15): 211-223, 2010

15 황순희, "‌팀 기반 스피치 수업의 교육적 효과 분석 ― 창의성 함양을 위한 교육 사례를 중심으로" 한국교양교육학회 8 (8): 287-322, 2014

16 Dommeyer, C. J., "Using the diary method to deal with social loafers on the group project : Its effects on peer evaluations, group behavior, and attitudes" 29 (29): 175-188, 2007

17 Smith, K. A., "Using active learning in college classes: A range of options for faculty" Jossey-Bass 71-82, 1996

18 Fellenz, M. R., "Toward fairness in assessing student groupwork : A protocol for peer evaluation of individual contributions" 30 (30): 570-591, 2006

19 Dochy, F. J. R. C., "The use of self-, peer and co-assessment in higher education : A review" 24 (24): 331-350, 1999

20 May, G. L., "The effect of social style on peer evaluation ratings in project teams" 43 (43): 4-20, 2006

21 Resta, P., "Technology in Support of Collaborative Learning" 19 : 65-83, 2007

22 KitFaiPun, Y., "Teaching new product development in universities : an action learning approach" 28 (28): 339-352, 2003

23 Slavin, R. E., "Synthesis of Research of Cooperative Learning" 48 (48): 71-82, 1991

24 Raban, R., "Supporting peer assessment of individual contributions in groupwork" 23 (23): 34-, 2007

25 McCroskey, J. C., "Self-report as an approach to measuring communication competence" 5 : 108-113, 1988

26 Boud, D., "Quantitative studies of student self-assessment in higher education : A critical analysis of findings" 18 (18): 529-549, 1989

27 Kilpatrick, D. J., "Procedural justice and the development and use of peer evaluations in business and accounting classes" 19 (19): 225-246, 2001

28 Kennedy, G. J., "Peer-assessment in group projects: is it worth it?" Australian Computer Society, Inc 42 : 2005

29 Ryan, G. J., "Peer, professor and self-evaluation of class participation" 8 (8): 49-61, 2007

30 Herbert, N., "Peer assessment: is it fair?" 2012

31 Conway, R, "Peer assessment of an individual‘s contribution to a group project" 18 (18): 45-56, 1993

32 Topping, K., "Peer assessment between students in colleges and universities" 68 (68): 249-276, 1998

33 Keith, J. T., "Peer assessment" 48 (48): 20-27, 2009

34 Burchfield, C. M., "Participation in Classroom Discussion" 26 (26): 290-291, 1999

35 Parsons, D., "Justice in the classroom: Peer assessment of contributions in group projects" 145-152, 2004

36 Cheng, W., "Having second thoughts : student perceptions before and after a peer assessment exercise" 22 (22): 233-239, 1997

37 Harskamp, E., "Group composition and its effect on female and male problem-solving in science education" 50 (50): 307-318, 2008

38 Bean, J. C., "Engaging ideas: The professor’s guide to integrating writing, critical thinking, and active learning in the classroom" Jossey-Bass 1996

39 Stapleton, J. L., "Effects of team composition on problem solving : an empirical investigation of the assembly effect" 49 (49): 94-108, 2007

40 Marjo, V. Z., "Effective peer assessment processes : Research findings and future directions" 20 (20): 270-279, 2010

41 Resta, P., "Development and validation of a Web-based tool for individual and group accountability" 2005

42 Dingel, M. J., "Cooperative learning and peer evaluation : The effect of free riders on team performance and the relationship between course performance and peer Evaluation" 13 (13): 45-56, 2013

43 Gueldenzoph, L. E., "Collaborative peer evaluation : Best practices for group member assessments" 65 (65): 9-20, 2002

44 McCroskey, J. C., "An introduction to rhetorical communication" Prentice Hall 1993

45 Gopinath, C., "Alternatives to instructor assessment of class participation" 75 (75): 10-14, 1999

46 Johnson, D. W., "Active learning: Cooperation in the college classroom" Interaction Book Company 2006