RISS 학술연구정보서비스

검색

인기 검색어

    다국어 입력

    http://chineseinput.net/에서 pinyin(병음)방식으로 중국어를 변환할 수 있습니다.

    변환된 중국어를 복사하여 사용하시면 됩니다.

    예시)
    • 中文 을 입력하시려면 zhongwen을 입력하시고 space를누르시면됩니다.
    • 北京 을 입력하시려면 beijing을 입력하시고 space를 누르시면 됩니다.
    닫기
    KCI등재 SCOPUS

    Is Distinction Impossible?: Comparing Risks between Radioactive Waste Facilities and Nuclear Power Stations

    한글로보기

    https://www.riss.kr/link?id=A104071795

    • 0

      상세조회
    • 0

      다운로드
    서지정보 열기
    • 내보내기
    • 내책장담기
    • 공유하기
      • URL 복사
    • 오류접수
    인용문이 복사되었습니다.

    부가정보

    다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract) kakao i 다국어 번역

    This paper explores whether people can distinguish among different risks. People are frequently regarded as rational beings who judge distinct risks differently. However, there are few risk studies analyzing the judgment of risk distinction. Hence, our study explores whether people distinguish between the risks of Nuclear Power Stations (NPS) and Radioactive Waste Facilities (RWF), and who has the ability to distinguish risk. Our analysis is based on empirical survey data from a sample of 816 people. First, according to value-differentiation, we divide the respondents into two groups, discriminate and indiscriminate, running a logistic regression to determine who is included in each group. Second, to know the object-differentiation by which people discern between the two risks, we create four groups. By logistic regression, we analyze what kinds of factors contribute to determining the probability of inclusion in each of the four groups. Third, to determine the effects of distinctive judgments, we analyze risk estimation, risk image, and the possibility of flexible negotiation according to four classified groups. In short, this study suggests that there are structural factors that determine distinctive judgments. Moreover, we demonstrate that those discretionary factors influence the interpretation of risk estimation and image, and determine the possible actions.
    번역하기

    This paper explores whether people can distinguish among different risks. People are frequently regarded as rational beings who judge distinct risks differently. However, there are few risk studies analyzing the judgment of risk distinction. Hence, ou...

    This paper explores whether people can distinguish among different risks. People are frequently regarded as rational beings who judge distinct risks differently. However, there are few risk studies analyzing the judgment of risk distinction. Hence, our study explores whether people distinguish between the risks of Nuclear Power Stations (NPS) and Radioactive Waste Facilities (RWF), and who has the ability to distinguish risk. Our analysis is based on empirical survey data from a sample of 816 people. First, according to value-differentiation, we divide the respondents into two groups, discriminate and indiscriminate, running a logistic regression to determine who is included in each group. Second, to know the object-differentiation by which people discern between the two risks, we create four groups. By logistic regression, we analyze what kinds of factors contribute to determining the probability of inclusion in each of the four groups. Third, to determine the effects of distinctive judgments, we analyze risk estimation, risk image, and the possibility of flexible negotiation according to four classified groups. In short, this study suggests that there are structural factors that determine distinctive judgments. Moreover, we demonstrate that those discretionary factors influence the interpretation of risk estimation and image, and determine the possible actions.

    더보기

    참고문헌 (Reference)

    1 Roth, E., "What Do We Know about Making Risk Comparison?" 10 (10): 375-387, 1990

    2 Slovic,P., "Trust, Emotion, Sex, Politics, and Science: Surveying the Risk-Assessment Battlefield" 689-701, 1999

    3 Flynn,J., "Trust as a Determinant of Opposition to a High-Level Radioactive Waste Repository: Analysis of a Structural Model" 12 (12): 417-429, 1992

    4 Brown,J.M., "The Public's Understanding of Radiation and Nuclear Waste" 7 (7): 61-70, 1987

    5 Covello,V.T., "The Perception of Technological Risks: A Literature Review" 285-297, 1983

    6 Renn,O., "The Need for Integration: Risk Policies Require the Input form Experts, Stakeholders and the Public at Large" 131-135, 2001

    7 Sjoberg,L., "The Different Dynamics of Personal and General Risk. In Foresight and Precaution. Volume 1" A. A. Balkema 1149-1155, 2000

    8 Gregory,R., "Technological Stigma" 83 (83): 220-223, 1995

    9 Kraus,N.N., "Taxonomic Analysis of Perceived Risk: Modeling Individual and Group Perceptions" 435-455, 1988

    10 Brody,J.G., "Sources of Public Concern About Nuclear Waste Disposal in Texas Agricultural Communities. In Public Reactions to Nuclear Waste" Durham, NC: Duke University Press 1993

    1 Roth, E., "What Do We Know about Making Risk Comparison?" 10 (10): 375-387, 1990

    2 Slovic,P., "Trust, Emotion, Sex, Politics, and Science: Surveying the Risk-Assessment Battlefield" 689-701, 1999

    3 Flynn,J., "Trust as a Determinant of Opposition to a High-Level Radioactive Waste Repository: Analysis of a Structural Model" 12 (12): 417-429, 1992

    4 Brown,J.M., "The Public's Understanding of Radiation and Nuclear Waste" 7 (7): 61-70, 1987

    5 Covello,V.T., "The Perception of Technological Risks: A Literature Review" 285-297, 1983

    6 Renn,O., "The Need for Integration: Risk Policies Require the Input form Experts, Stakeholders and the Public at Large" 131-135, 2001

    7 Sjoberg,L., "The Different Dynamics of Personal and General Risk. In Foresight and Precaution. Volume 1" A. A. Balkema 1149-1155, 2000

    8 Gregory,R., "Technological Stigma" 83 (83): 220-223, 1995

    9 Kraus,N.N., "Taxonomic Analysis of Perceived Risk: Modeling Individual and Group Perceptions" 435-455, 1988

    10 Brody,J.G., "Sources of Public Concern About Nuclear Waste Disposal in Texas Agricultural Communities. In Public Reactions to Nuclear Waste" Durham, NC: Duke University Press 1993

    11 Hermand,D., "Societal Risk Perception among Children, Adolescents, Adults and Elderly People" 6 (6): 137-143, 1999

    12 Krannich,R.S., "Rural Community Residents' Views of Nuclear Waste Repository Siting in Nevada. In Public Reactions to Nuclear Waste" Durham: Duke University Press 1993

    13 Grasmuck,D., "Risk Perception of Heavy Metal Soil Contamination by High-Exposed and Low-Exposed Inhabitants: The Role of Knowledge and Emotional Concern" 25 (25): 611-622, 2005

    14 Williams, B. L., "Risk Perception in Context: The Savannah River Site Stakeholder Study" 19 (19): 1019-1034, 1999

    15 Rohrmann,B., "Risk Perception Research. In Cross-Cultural Risk Perception: A Survey of Empirical Studies" Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers 2000

    16 Bord,R.J., "Risk Communication, Knowledge, and Attitudes: Explaining Reactions to a Technology Perceived as Risky" 10 (10): 499-506, 1990

    17 Slovic, P., "Rational Actors or Rational Fools Implications of the Affect Heuristic for Behavioral Economics" 329-342, 2002

    18 Hine, D. W., "Public Opposition to a Proposed Nuclear Waste Repository in Canada: An Investigation of Cultural and Economic Effects" 17 (17): 293-302, 1997

    19 Kunreuther,H., "Public Attitudes toward Sitting a High-Level Nuclear Waste Repository in Nevada" 10 (10): 469-484, 1990

    20 Siegrist,M., "Perception of Hazards: The Role of Social Trust and Knowledge" 20 (20): 713-720, 2000

    21 Slovic,P., "Perceived Risk, Trust, and Nuclear Waste: Lesson From Yucca Mountain. In Public Reactions to Nuclear Waste" Durham: Duke University Press 1993

    22 Slovic, P., "Perceived Risk, Stigma, and Potential Economic Impacts of a High-Level Nuclear Waste Repository in Nevada" 683-696, 1991

    23 Desvousges,W.H., "Perceived Risk and Attitudes Toward Nuclear Wastes: National and Nevada Perspective. In Public Reactions to Nuclear Waste" Durham, NC: Duke University Press 1993

    24 Basset Jr.,G.W., "On-Site Storage of High Nuclear Waste: Attitudes and Perception of Local Residents" 16 (16): 309-319, 1996

    25 Rankin, W. L., "Nuclear Power and the Public: An Update of Collected Survey Research on Nuclear Power" Seattle: Battelle Memorial Institute, Human Affairs 1981

    26 Marks,G., "Not in My Back Yard: Influence of Motivational Concerns on Judgements about a Risky Technology" 408-415, 1984

    27 Mushkatel, A. H., "Nevada Urban Residents' Attitudes Toward a Nuclear Waste Repository. In Public Reactions to Nuclear Waste" Durham: Duke University Press 1993

    28 Tanaka,Y., "Major Psychological Factors Determining Public Acceptance of the Siting of Nuclear Facilities" 34 (34): 1147-1165, 2004

    29 Dunlap,R., "Local Attitudes Toward Siting a High-Level Nuclear Waste Repository at Hanford, Washington. In Public Reactions to Nuclear Waste" Durham, NC: Duke University Press 1993

    30 Sjoberg,L., "Local Acceptance of a High-Level Nuclear Waste Repository" 24 (24): 737-749, 2004

    31 Sjoberg,L., "Knowledge and Risk Perception among Nuclear Power Plant Employees. Risk Analysis" 11 (11): 607-618, 1991

    32 Knight,A., "Intervening Effects of Knowledge, Morality, Trust and Benefits on Support for Animal and Plant Biotechnology Application" 27 (27): 1553-1563, 2007

    33 Carnes, S. A., "Incentives and Nuclear Waste Sitting: Prospects and Constraints" 7 (7): 323-351, 1983

    34 Benford,R.D., "In Whose Backyard?: Concern About Siting a Nuclear Waste Facility" 63 (63): 30-47, 1993

    35 Fischhoff, B. F., "How Safe is Safe Enough? A Psychometric Study of Attitudes toward Technological Risks and Benefits" 127-152, 1978

    36 Visschers,V.H.M., "How Does the General Public Evaluate Risk Information?: The Impact of Associations with Other Risks" 27 (27): 715-727, 2007

    37 Pollock III,P., "Hard Issues, Core Values and Vertical Constraint: The Case of Nuclear Power" 29-50, 1993

    38 Sjoberg,L., "Explaining Risk Perception: An Evaluation of the Psychometric Paradigm in Risk Perception Research" Trondheim: Norweigan University of Science and Technology 2004

    39 Buuren,A.V., "Conflicting Knowledge" 32 (32): 289-299, 2004

    40 Slovic,P., "Comment: What Should We Know about Making Risk Comparison" 10 (10): 389-391, 1990

    41 Slovic P, "Beyond Numbers: a Broader Perspective on Risk Perception and Risk Communication. In Acceptable Evidence: Science and Values in Risk Management" Oxford University Press: Oxford 1991

    42 Van Der Plight, J., "Attitudes toward Nuclear Energy: Familiarity and Salience" 18 (18): 75-93, 1986

    43 Sjoberg,L., "Attitudes and Risk Perceptions of Stakeholders in a Nuclear Waste Siting Issues" 23 (23): 2003

    44 Rundmo,T., "Associations between Affect and Risk Perception" 5 (5): 119-135, 2002

    45 Kunreuther,H., "Are Risk-Benefit Tradeoffs Possible in Sitting Hazardous Facilities" 252-256, 1990

    46 xxxGarvin,T., "Analytical Paradigms: The Epistemological Distance between Scientists, Policy Makers and the Public" 21 (21): 443-455, 2001

    47 YONG-JINCHA, "AN ANALYSIS OF NUCLEAR RISK PERCEPTION:WITH FOCUS ON DEVELOPING EFFECTIVE POLICY ALTERNATIVES" 한국행정학회 8 (8): 33-47, 2003

    더보기

    분석정보

    View

    상세정보조회

    0

    Usage

    원문다운로드

    0

    대출신청

    0

    복사신청

    0

    EDDS신청

    0

    동일 주제 내 활용도 TOP

    더보기

    주제

    연도별 연구동향

    연도별 활용동향

    연관논문

    연구자 네트워크맵

    공동연구자 (7)

    유사연구자 (20) 활용도상위20명

    인용정보 인용지수 설명보기

    학술지 이력

    학술지 이력
    연월일 이력구분 이력상세 등재구분
    2023 평가 해외DB학술지평가 신청대상 (해외등재 학술지 평가)
    2020-01-01 등재 등재학술지 유지 (해외등재 학술지 평가) KCI등재
    2011-01-01 등재 등재학술지 유지 (등재유지) KCI등재
    2009-01-01 등재 등재학술지 유지 (등재유지) KCI등재
    2007-01-01 등재 등재학술지 유지 (등재유지) KCI등재
    2004-01-01 등재 등재학술지 선정 (등재후보2차) KCI등재
    2003-01-01 등재 등재후보 1차 PASS (등재후보1차) KCI등재후보
    2002-01-01 등재 등재후보학술지 유지 (등재후보1차) KCI등재후보
    1999-07-01 등재 등재후보학술지 선정 (신규평가) KCI등재후보
    더보기

    학술지 인용정보

    학술지 인용정보
    기준연도 WOS-KCI 통합IF(2년) KCIF(2년) KCIF(3년)
    2016 0.29 0.29 0.28
    KCIF(4년) KCIF(5년) 중심성지수(3년) 즉시성지수
    0.25 0.27 0.381 0.05
    더보기
    해외이동버튼