학교자문에서의 저항에 대한 사회인지이론적 고찰 = Resistance in School Consultation:A Social Cognitive Theory Perspective

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

When delivering consultative services in schools, consultants need to understand 'resistance' within the context of consultation and develop skills to effectively manage it. With a growing interest in psychological and educational consultation in schools over the last few decades, research in this area has significantly been increased and a fair amount of literature has been published concerning resistance in school consultation. However, currently available discussions on this topic are limited in terms of their scopes and theoretical foundations, and an attempt to integrate them from a theoretical perspective has not been made yet. This article examines various aspects of resistance in school consultation from the perspective of Bandura(1986)'s Social Cognitive Theory. Specifically, this article conceptualizes resistance in school consultation and reviews various causes and types of resistance based on triadic reciprocality. This article also explores a potential role of self-efficacy in the consultee's motivational process of resistance. Overall. this article demonstrates that Social Cognitive Theory can serve as a useful theoretical and conceptual framework for understanding various aspects of resistance and developing a management plan with resistance in school consultation.

국문 초록 (Abstract)

학교장면에서 효과적으로 자문을 제공하기 위해서는 자문과정에서 나타나는 다양한 ‘저항’을 이해하고 이에 적극적으로 대처하는 노력이 필요하다. 학교자문에 대한 전문적 관심이 증가하면서 외국 문헌을 중심으로 이 분야의 연구물이 꾸준히 증가하였고 학교자문에서의 저항에 대한 전문적 논의도 적지 않게 있었지만, 저항의 다양한 측면에 대한 개관이나 종합적인 이론적 분석은 부족하였다. 본 연구는 자문의 과정 및 성과에 영향을 미치는 주요 변인으로 지목되고 있는 저항에 대하여 사회인지이론적 관점에서 고찰함으로써 학교자문에 대한 연구와 실무 기반이 아직 취약한 국내의 실정에서 연구자와 실무자에게 유용한 지식 기반을 제공하고자 한다. 구체적으로 본 연구는 사회인지이론의 인과모델인 삼원교호작용(triadic reciprocality)에 기초하여 학교자문에서의 저항을 정의하고, 저항의 요인 및 유형에 대한 외국의 선행 연구들을 체계적으로 개관한다. 또한 자기효능감이 저항의 동기화 과정 이해에 어떻게 도움이 될 수 있는지를 탐색함으로써 이 개념의 잠재적인 역할을 고찰한다. 본 연구는 저항에 대한 사회인지이론적 분석이 저항의 다양한 측면을 이해하고 저항에 효과적으로 대처하는 데 유용한 이론적, 개념적 틀을 제공할 수 있음을 시사한다.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 윤초희, "학습컨설팅의 모형과 현장 적용 가능성 고찰" 1 : 1-18, 2009

2 Kampwirth, T. J., "학습과 행동 문제 해결을 위한 학교 컨설팅" 학지사 2010

3 김동일, "학교상담 컨설테이션" 학지사 2008

4 강진령, "초등학교 상담교사의 교사자문 모형 구안" 한국상담학회 6 (6): 973-988, 2005

5 박상민, "초등 교사의 학교상담 컨설테이션 요구분석" 서울대학교 대학원 2009

6 이명경, "주의력결핍 및 과잉행동장애 학생의 문제행동에 대한 학교상담 컨설테이션 효과 검증" 서울대학교 대학원 2006

7 노안영, "인간이해와 성장을 위한 성격심리학" 학지사 2003

8 이동형, "가족-학교 협력에 기초한 자문모델의 이해와 활용" 한국심리학회 30 (30): 419-442, 2011

9 Stenger, M. K., "Variables that distinguish elementary teachers who participate in school-based consultation from those who do not" 7 : 271-284, 1992

10 Margolis, H., "Understanding, facing resistance to change" 75 : 1-8, 1991

11 Gajria, M., "Treatment acceptability: A critical dimension for overcoming teacher resistance to implementing adaptations for mainstreamed students" 12 : 91-108, 1996

12 Martens, B. K., "Training school psychologists in behavior support consultation" 24 : 147-163, 2002

13 Caplan, G., "The theory and practice of mental health consultation" Basic Books 1970

14 Skrtic, T. M., "The special education paradox: Equity on the way to excellence" 61 : 148-206, 1991

15 Dougherty, A. M., "The sources and management of resistance to consultation" 38 : 178-186, 1991

16 Gallesich, J., "The profession and practice of consultation" Jossey-Bass 1982

17 Hughes, J. N., "The application of cognitive dissonance theory to consultation" 21 : 349-357, 1983

18 Gutkin, T. B., "Teachers' perceptions of control over presenting problems and resulting preferences for consultation versus referral services" 26 : 395-398, 1988

19 Hughes, J. N., "Teachers' expectancies, participation in consultation, and perceptions of consultant helpfulness" 5 : 167-179, 1990

20 Gonzalez, J. E., "Teacher resistance to school-based consultation: A survey of teacher perceptions" 12 : 30-37, 2004

21 Tysinger, P. D., "Teacher expectations on the directiveness continuum in consultation" 46 : 319-332, 2009

22 Reschly, D. J., "Special education reform: School psychology revolution" 17 : 459-475, 1998

23 Bandura, A., "Social foundations of thought and action: A social cognitive theory" Prentice Hall 1986

24 Bandura, A., "Self-efficacy: The exercise of control" Freeman 1997

25 Gutkin, T. B., "School-based consultation: The science and practice of indirect service delivery, In Handbook of school psychology (4th ed)" Wiley 591-635, 2009

26 Fagan, T. K., "School psychology: Past, present, and future (3rd ed.)" National Association of School Psychologists 2007

27 Merrell, K. W., "School psychology for the 21st century: Foundations and practices" Guilford Press 2006

28 Erchul, W. P., "School psychologists' perceptions of social power bases in teacher consultation" 12 : 1-24, 2001

29 Smith, D. K., "School psychologists' attributions for success and failure in consultation with parents and teachers" 17 : 205-209, 1986

30 Erchul, W. P., "School consultation: Conceptual and empirical bases of practice (3rd ed.)" Springer 2010

31 Hughes, J. N., "Resistance, reactance, and consultation" 19 : 134-141, 1981

32 Wickstrom, K. F., "Resistance within school-based consultation, In Handbook of consultation services for children" Jossey -Bass 159-178, 1993

33 Piersel, W. C., "Resistance to school-based consultation: A behavioral analysis of the problem" 20 : 311-320, 1983

34 Randolph, D. L., "Resistance to consultation: A synthesis for counselor -consultants" 6 : 182-184, 1988

35 Powell, G., "Resistance to change reconsidered: Implications for managers" 17 : 29-34, 1978

36 Gutkin, T. B., "Relationship of consultant, consultee, and organizational characteristics to consultee resistance to school-based consultation: An empirical analysis" 1 : 111-122, 1990

37 Gutkin, T. B., "Reconceptualizing school psychology from a service delivery perspective: Implications for practice, training, and research" 28 : 203-223, 1990

38 Dougherty, A. M., "Psychological consultation and collaboration in school and community settings (5th ed.)" Brooks/Cole 2009

39 Erchul, W. P., "Overview: the state of scientific research in school consultation, In Handbook of research in school consultation" Taylor & Francis Group/Routledge 3-12, 2008

40 Pajares, F., "Overview of social cognitive theory and of self-efficacy"

41 Ellis, A., "Overcoming resistance: Rational emotive therapy with different clients" Springer 1985

42 Friend, M., "Managing resistance: An essential consulting skills for learning disabilities teachers" 21 : 556-561, 1988

43 Cormier, W. H., "Interviewing strategies for helpers (3rd ed.)" Brooks/Cohen 1991

44 Gross, S., "Interpersonal threat as a basis for resistance in consultation" 1980

45 Gutkin, T. B., "Impact of organizational variables on the delivery of school-based consultation services" 14 : 230-235, 1985

46 Marks, E. S., "Entry strategies for school consultation" Guilford 1995

47 DeForest, P. A., "Effect of teacher involvement and teacher self-efficacy on ratings on consultant effectiveness and intervention acceptability" 3 : 301-316, 1992

48 Erchul, W. P., "Dyadic agreement concerning the consultation process and its relationship to outcome" 3 : 119-132, 1992

49 Parsons, R. D., "Developing consultation skills" Jossey-Bass 1984

50 Cautilli, J., "Current behavioral models of client and consultee resistance: A critical review" 1 : 147-164, 2005

51 Butler, T. S., "Countering teacher resistance in behavioral consultation: Recommendations for the school-based consultant" 3 : 282-288, 2002

52 Martin, R. P., "Consultants' perceptions of causality for success and failure of consultations" 12 : 670-676, 1981

53 Kratochwill, T. R., "Best practices in school-based problem -solving consultation, In Best practices in school psychology-IV" National Association of School Psychologists 583-608, 2002

54 Sheridan, S. M., "Acceptability of conjoint behavioral consultations: A national survey of school psychologists" 24 : 633-647, 1995