RISS 학술연구정보서비스

검색

인기 검색어

    다국어 입력

    http://chineseinput.net/에서 pinyin(병음)방식으로 중국어를 변환할 수 있습니다.

    변환된 중국어를 복사하여 사용하시면 됩니다.

    예시)
    • 中文 을 입력하시려면 zhongwen을 입력하시고 space를누르시면됩니다.
    • 北京 을 입력하시려면 beijing을 입력하시고 space를 누르시면 됩니다.
    닫기

    National Identity and Citizenship in China and Korea

    한글로보기

    https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T8984698

    • 0

      상세조회
    • 0

      다운로드
    서지정보 열기
    • 내보내기
    • 내책장담기
    • 공유하기
      • URL 복사
    • 오류접수
    인용문이 복사되었습니다.

    부가정보

    다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract) kakao i 다국어 번역

    Pointing out the limitations of culturalist approaches, my dissertation deals with factors that contribute to the legal definition of citizenship in China and South Korea. Specifically, I argue that the understanding of political and economic interests, rather than cultural aspects, is important in explaining the changes of the definition of citizenship, in these two cases and presumably elsewhere as well. My dissertation shows that concerns about sovereignty, diplomatic considerations, economic development programs, and civil movements often change nationality law and citizenship policy in ways that run counter to traditional national identity in China and Korea.
    China developed and institutionalized a state-centered, inclusionist national identity, while Korea constructed an ethnic-centered, exclusionist national identity as they became integrated into the international order as nation-states. However, both China and Korea adopted jus sanguinis despite great difference in the ethnic structure of their nations and national identity. This shows that various political and economic factors rather than cultural factors such as national identity strongly influence the legal definition of citizenship in China and Korea.
    First, when the modern citizenship was established in China and Korea in the late 19th century, international legal practices, the household system, and the Japanese experience of adopting modern citizenship deeply affected their systems. Second, sovereignty, national security, and economic interests rather than national identities directly influenced the governments’ decision over dual citizenship both in China and Korea. Finally, both the PRC and ROK made important changes in their legal definitions of citizenship regardless of their distinct national identities in the past decade.
    Considering their national interests in the global era, both the PRC and ROK adopted new citizenship policies and defined new legal definitions of citizenship, which are often inconsistent with their existing national identities. Brubaker argued that citizenship is not a politics of interests, but a politics of identity in France and Germany. China and Korea are often viewed as strongly oriented toward their distinctive cultural values. Yet here we find the politics of interests is key to understanding citizenship in these two countries. Thus, my study strongly discredits culturalist explanations of the East Asian developments.
    번역하기

    Pointing out the limitations of culturalist approaches, my dissertation deals with factors that contribute to the legal definition of citizenship in China and South Korea. Specifically, I argue that the understanding of political and economic interest...

    Pointing out the limitations of culturalist approaches, my dissertation deals with factors that contribute to the legal definition of citizenship in China and South Korea. Specifically, I argue that the understanding of political and economic interests, rather than cultural aspects, is important in explaining the changes of the definition of citizenship, in these two cases and presumably elsewhere as well. My dissertation shows that concerns about sovereignty, diplomatic considerations, economic development programs, and civil movements often change nationality law and citizenship policy in ways that run counter to traditional national identity in China and Korea.
    China developed and institutionalized a state-centered, inclusionist national identity, while Korea constructed an ethnic-centered, exclusionist national identity as they became integrated into the international order as nation-states. However, both China and Korea adopted jus sanguinis despite great difference in the ethnic structure of their nations and national identity. This shows that various political and economic factors rather than cultural factors such as national identity strongly influence the legal definition of citizenship in China and Korea.
    First, when the modern citizenship was established in China and Korea in the late 19th century, international legal practices, the household system, and the Japanese experience of adopting modern citizenship deeply affected their systems. Second, sovereignty, national security, and economic interests rather than national identities directly influenced the governments’ decision over dual citizenship both in China and Korea. Finally, both the PRC and ROK made important changes in their legal definitions of citizenship regardless of their distinct national identities in the past decade.
    Considering their national interests in the global era, both the PRC and ROK adopted new citizenship policies and defined new legal definitions of citizenship, which are often inconsistent with their existing national identities. Brubaker argued that citizenship is not a politics of interests, but a politics of identity in France and Germany. China and Korea are often viewed as strongly oriented toward their distinctive cultural values. Yet here we find the politics of interests is key to understanding citizenship in these two countries. Thus, my study strongly discredits culturalist explanations of the East Asian developments.

    더보기

    목차 (Table of Contents)

    • LIST OF TABLES = viii
    • LIST OF FIGURE = ix
    • ACKNOWLEDGMENTS = x
    • CURRICULUM VITAE = xii
    • ABSTRACT OF THE DISSERTATION = xiii
    • LIST OF TABLES = viii
    • LIST OF FIGURE = ix
    • ACKNOWLEDGMENTS = x
    • CURRICULUM VITAE = xii
    • ABSTRACT OF THE DISSERTATION = xiii
    • CHAPTER ONE = 1
    • I. Introduction = 1
    • 1. Research Question = 1
    • 2. The Study = 3
    • 3. Methodology = 7
    • 4. Outline = 13
    • CHAPTER TWO = 15
    • II. Theoretical Review = 15
    • 1. Culture and Structure = 15
    • 2. Culturalism vs. Structuralism in the Study of the Nation-state = 16
    • 3. Culturalism vs. Structuralism in the Study of Citizenship = 20
    • 4. Culturalism vs. Structuralism in the Study of the East Asian Case = 25
    • CHAPTER THREE = 29
    • III. Development of State-centered, Inclusionist Nationalism (Aiguozhuyi or patriotism) in China = 29
    • 1. Historical and demographic background of State-centered, Inclusionist Nationalism and National Identity in China = 30
    • 2. Ethnic Nationalism vs. State Nationalism: Late Qing (until 1911) = 33
    • 3. Development of State Nationalism: The Republic of China (1912∼1949) = 36
    • 4. Confirmation of State Nationalism under Communism: The People's Republic of China (1949~) = 39
    • 4.1. Anti-Chauvinist State Nationalism during Mao Period (1949∼1978): = 39
    • 4.2. The Rise of New Nationalism in the Post-Mao Period (1978∼): = 44
    • 5. The Effect of State Nationalism on Ethnic Minority Identity: the Korean-Chinese case = 50
    • 5.1. History of Korean Migration into Manchuria: = 50
    • 5.2. Identity of Chaoxianzu (or Joseonjok in Korean): = 53
    • CHAPTER FOUR = 55
    • IV. The Development of Ethnic Nationalism in Korea = 55
    • 1. The Historical and Demographic Background of Ethnic Nationalism and the Exclusionist National Identity in Korea = 56
    • 2. Ethnic Nationalism: late Joseon (1880-1910) = 58
    • 3. The Development of Ethnic Nationalism under Colonialism and Anti-Colonialism: 1910∼1945 = 60
    • 4. The Development of Ethnic Nationalism under Division: 1945∼ = 64
    • 5. The Effect of Ethnic Nationalism on Ethnic Minority Identity: Chinese case = 70
    • 5.1. History of Chinese Migration into Korea: = 71
    • 5.2. Identity of Huaqiao in Korea: = 74
    • CHAPTER FIVE = 76
    • V. The Legal Definition of Citizenship (or Subjectship) in China: = 76
    • 1. The Legal Definition of Chinese Subjectship/Citizenship in Late Qing (1850s∼1910): = 78
    • 1.1. The Politics of Jus Sanguinis: = 79
    • 1.2. Policy toward Chinese with Foreign Citiznship and Dual Citizenship: = 87
    • 1.3. The Qing’s Policy toward Korean Immigrants: = 90
    • 2. The Legal Definition of Citizenship under the Nationalist Regime (1912∼1949): = 92
    • 2.1. Naturalization: = 94
    • 2.2. Discrimination against Women: = 96
    • 2.3. Policy toward Ethnic Chinese and Dual Citizenship: = 97
    • 2.4. Naturalization of Korean Immigrants: = 101
    • 3. The Legal Definition of Chinese Citizenship from 1949 to 1978: = 103
    • 3.1. Policy toward Overseas Chinese and Dual Citizenship: = 104
    • 3.2. The Naturalization of Korean Immigrants: = 108
    • 3.3. The 1980 Nationality Law: = 115
    • 3.4. Naturalization: = 117
    • 3.5. Discrimination against Women: = 119
    • 4. Economic Reform and the Definition of Citizenship after 1978: = 120
    • 4.1. Overseas Chinese: = 120
    • 4.2. Introduction of the "Permanent Residence System (or Denizenship)": = 126
    • CHAPTER SIX = 129
    • VI. Legal Definition of Subjectship/Citizenship in South Korea: = 129
    • 1. Subjectship in Joseon (1392∼1910): = 129
    • 2. Subjectship under the Japanese Colonialism (1910∼1945): = 133
    • 3. Citizenship under the U.S. Military Government Occupation (1945. 8. 15∼1948. 8. 15): = 135
    • 4. The Legal Definition of Citizenship in the Republic of Korea before 1990s: = 137
    • 4.1 Naturalization: = 139
    • 4.2. Discrimination against Women: = 141
    • 4.3. Policy toward Residents of Chinese Ethnicity: = 143
    • 4.4. Policy toward Ethnic Koreans Abroad and Dual Citizenship: = 147
    • 5. Changes in Legal definition of Citizenship after the mid-1990s: = 151
    • 5.1. Naturalization: = 154
    • 5.2. Discrimination against Women: = 155
    • 5.3. Policy toward Foreign Workers: = 157
    • 5.4. Policy toward Residents of Chinese Ethnicity: = 166
    • 5.5. Policy toward Ethnic Koreans with Foreign Citizenship and Dual Citizenship: Joseonjok case = 169
    • CHAPTER SEVEN = 180
    • VII. Conclusion = 180
    • REFERENCES = 190
    • APPENDICES = 210
    • 1. Summary of the 1909 statute on Nationality of the Qing = 210
    • 2. The 1929 Nationality Law of the ROC = 212
    • 3. The 1980 Nationality Law of the People's Republic of China = 216
    • 4. The Law of the People's Republic of China of the Protection of the Rights and Interests of Returned Overseas Chinese and Relatives of Overseas = 218
    • 5. The 1948 Provisional Rules on Nationality of the South Korea Interim Government = 223
    • 6. The 1997 Nationality Law of the ROK = 224
    • 7. The 1997 Nationality Law of the ROK = 227
    • 8. The Law on the Entry, Exit, and Legal Status of Overseas Koreans = 237
    더보기

    분석정보

    View

    상세정보조회

    0

    Usage

    원문다운로드

    0

    대출신청

    0

    복사신청

    0

    EDDS신청

    0

    동일 주제 내 활용도 TOP

    더보기

    주제

    연도별 연구동향

    연도별 활용동향

    연관논문

    연구자 네트워크맵

    공동연구자 (7)

    유사연구자 (20) 활용도상위20명

    해외이동버튼