公益共業으로 인한 間接損失의 補償 - 판례를 중심으로 - = Indirect Compensation for Loss Caused by Public Works - Focusing on Judicial Decisions(cases) -

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Caused by public works, the loss of property rights has an effect on within and without the business district. In many cases where landowners around the business district(except for it) suffer the loss due to the public works, must compensation for loss be given? Indirect compensation for loss means the one landowners around the business district suffer on account of public works. Because of compensation for this loss, many cases occur where the effective implementation of public works is limited. So far, compensation for loss has been considered the one for direct loss only caused by the infringement for public service. Therefore, in principle, indirect loss did not belong to compensation for loss. However, the indirect loss must be included in compensation for loss because it is caused by public works. Judicial decisions show that indirect loss belongs to Compensation for Loss, provided under Section 3, Article 23 of the constitution. The conditions for indirect loss include:1. Landowners must suffer loss due to public works2. It must be predicted that the loss is going to occur because of the public works3. The range of loss must be concretely specified.This paper studies the problems of the present system through judicial decisions along with general theory on indirect compensation for loss.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 "행정법론(상" 박영사 2005

2 "토지공법강의" 삼영사 1999

3 "최신행정법강의(상" 박영사 2002

4 "영업의 간접보상" (9) : 1999

5 "영업에 대한 간접보상의 법적 문제" 2000

6 "새 토지보상법에 관한 검토" 한국감정원 2002년5-6월호

7 "공특법상 간접영업보상제도의 문제점 공법연구 제29집 제1호" 한국공법학회 29 (29): 2000

8 "공익사업을위한토지등의취득및보상에관한법률의 주요내용 토지보상법연구 제3집 한국토지보상법연구회" 3 : 2003

9 "공공사업의 시행으로 인한 간접손실의 보상 판례연구 부산판례연구회" 2004

10 "간접손실에 대한 보상의 범위 민사재판의 제문제 법원 실무연구회" 2000

11 "空港騷音訴訟のめぐる行政上の問題點" 559號

12 "事業損失補償の基準解說" 東京出版株式會社 1991