기명식 선하증권의 담보 효력 = The Efficacy of Straight Bill of Lading as Collateral

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The straight bill of lading is regarded as the documents of title except in American law after The Rafaela S case. The Carewins case also decided that the exclusion clause of bill of lading did not exempt carriers from liability when the carriers delivered the cargo to the consignee without the production of original bill of lading. And the court said that the carrier was responsible for delivering the goods against a forged bill of lading regardless of exemption clause of bill of lading in the Motis case. It may be assumed through these cases that the straight bill of lading as a document of title gives documentary security to the banks in trade finance.
However, there can be some downside to the efficacy of the straight bill of lading as collateral. First, when it is subject to the English law, the shipper can arbitrarily change the consignee different from the one named in the document. Second, some bills of lading bear provisions relating to the carrier delivering the goods upon reasonable proof of identity without the surrender of an original and/or genuine bill of lading.

목차 (Table of Contents)

• Ⅰ. 서론
• Ⅱ. 기명식 선하증권의 의의와 국가간 법률 비교
• Ⅲ. 판례 분석
• Ⅳ. 실무적 시사점 및 제언
• Ⅴ. 결론
• 참고문헌
• ABSTRACT

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 이시환, "로테르담 규칙상의 운송인의 책임" 한국무역상무학회 42 : 189-210, 2009

2 한낙현, "기명식 선하증권에서 운송인의 인도의무에 관한 판례분석－ Rafaela S호 사건을 중심으로 －" 한국해운물류학회 51 : 163-191, 2006

3 강영문, "국제운송규칙의 변화와 선하증권의 면책약관에 관한 연구" 한국무역상무학회 31 (31): 59-78, 2006

4 林錫珉, "記名式 선하증권의 讓渡에 관한 判例分析" 한국해운물류학회 (43) : 2004

5 金昌俊, "背書가 禁止된 記名式 船荷證券의 法的 性質" 한국해법학회 25 (25): 265-300, 2003

6 유중원, "背書禁止文言과 記名式 船荷證券의 法理" 한국법학원 112 : 240-264, 2009

7 이성웅, "‘라파엘라’ 사건과 기명식 선하증권의 유통성" 한국해법학회 30 (30): 153-192, 2008

8 Kozolchyk, Boris, "The unwarranted comeback of the FIATA Bills of Lading" 11 (11): 2005

9 Pejovic, Caslav, "The straight bill of lading: do we really need it?" 303-310, 2005

10 Treitel, Guenter H., "The legal status of straight bills of lading" 608 : 2003

11 Bacon, Laurence A.J., "The intrinsic value of a bill of lading" 10-12, 2004

12 Kozolchyk, Boris, "Supply chain financing, straight bills of lading and standby letter of credit" 2 (2): 100-122, 2011

13 D'arcy, Leo, "Schmitthoff's Export Trade" Sweet & Maxwell 2001

14 UNCTAD, "Review of Maritme Transport 2010" 2011

15 Tetley, W., "Marine Cargo Claims" Blais Inc 1988

16 Panesar, Sukhninder, "Is a straight bill of lading a document of title?" 196-199, 2004

17 Branch, Alan E., "Elements of Shipping" Routledge 2007

18 Pejovic, Caslav, "Delivery of the Goods without a Bills of Lading: Old Problems Revives in the Far East" 9 (9): 448-460, 2003

19 Treitel, Guenter H., "Carver on Bills of Lading" Sweet and Maxwell 2001

20 Smith, Jermy, "Bills of lading clauses:the legal background" 11 (11): 2005

21 Debattista, Charles, "Bills of Lading in Export Trade" Tottel Publishing 2008

22 Girvin, Stephen, "Bill of lading and straight bills of lading: principles and practice" 86-116, 2006

23 최명국, "A Case Study on the Straight Bill of Lading" 한국무역상무학회 24 (24): 3-24, 2004