아감벤의 “목적 없는 수단”과 벤야민의 이미지로서의 역사철학그리고 드보르 영화의 몽타주 기법 = Agamben`s “Means Without End”, Benjamin`s Historical Materialism, and Debord`s Cinema Poetics

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The main aim of this paper is to examine the interconnected worlds of poetics of the three theorists, Agamben, Debord and Benjamin, and to see what they commonly aim at. Agamben`s ‘Means without End’ reflects Debord`s cinema poetics. In Debord`s cinema poetics montage image functions as ‘a prolonged hesitation between image and meaning`` just as Agamben`s pure means does as “uneasy hesitation” before the separation of the sacred and the profane. Debord`s montage poetics, which aims not the return of the identical but that of the possibility of what was, perfectly matches with Benjamin`s notion of history as image. Just as Debord`s montage image aims at the decreation of what was, Benjamin`s view of history as image aims at a history of salvation. Each image, according to Benjamin, is charged with history and it is the door through which the Messiah enters. We also see Debord`s notion of spectacle helps us understand not only Agamben`s notion of profanation but also Benjamin`s notion of secularization.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 조르조 아감벤, "호모 사케르: 주권 권력과 벌거벗은 생명" 새물결 2008

2 김유동, "파괴, 구성 그리고 복원—발터 벤야민의 역사관과 그 현재성" 19 (19): 411-435, 2006

3 조르조 아감벤, "예외상태" 새물결 2009

4 조르조 아감벤, "세속화 예찬: 정치미학을 위한 10개의 노트" 난장 2010

5 윤교찬, "부정과 중단의 미학—아감벤의 바틀비론" 21세기영어영문학회 26 (26): 73-94, 2013

6 발터 벤야민, "발터 벤야민의 문예이론" 민음사 1983

7 발터 벤야민, "발터 벤야민 선집 5: 역사의 개념에 대하여, 폭력비판을 위하여, 초현실주의외" 119-131,

8 발터 벤야민, "발터 벤야민 선집 5: 역사의 개념에 대하여, 폭력비판을 위하여, 초현실주의외" 길 327-350, 2012

9 조르조 아감벤, "목적 없는 수단: 정치에 관한 11개의 노트" 난장 2009

10 윤교찬, "‘되기’의 실패와 잠재성의 정치학: 멜빌의 『필경사 바틀비』" 한국현대영어영문학회 53 (53): 69-88, 2009

11 Benjamin, Walter, "Walter Benjamin: Selected Writings, Vol 1: 1913-1926" Belknap 1999

12 Murray, Alex, "The Works of Giorgio Agamben: Law, Literature, Life" Edinburgh UP 2008

13 Clemens, Justin, "The Works of Giorgio Agamben: Law, Literature, Life" Edinburgh UP 2008

14 Debord, Guy, "The Society of the Spectacle"

15 Agamben, Giorgio, "Profanations" Zone 2007

16 Agamben, Giorgio, "Means Without End.: Notes on Politics" U. of Minnesota P 2000

17 Benjamin, Walter, "Illuminations" Schocken 147-154, 1978

18 Arendt, Hannah, "Illuminations" Schocken 1978

19 Benjamin, Walter, "Illuminations" Schocken 217-251, 1978

20 Agamben, Giorgio, "Guy Debord and the Situationist International: Texts and Documents" MIT P 313-319, 2002