브리콜뢰르로서 미술교사에 관한 소고 = A Study on the Art Teacher as Bricoleur

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This article reconceptualises art teachers as “innovative bricoleurs” who construct meaningful assemblages of classroom practice, under the circumstances of limited resources and newly introduced competency-based curriculum.
The concept of bricolage and bricoleur has been used in numerous fields - organization, institution, methodology, etc. -, enhancing the understanding of creative processes and positive enactors that draw out the most value from the available resources in light of real-world constraints.
Likewise, eschewing the technical bricolage of adhochism and devious means, art teachers have been asked to build the capacity of innovative bricoleurs, who accept a complex array of educational conditions and, for himself/herself, assemble available resources to solve problems creatively.
For this, art teacher training courses should be improved to the extent of integrating pedagogical theories with teaching practices. Also, it is needed to create a positive school climate to provide the opportunities of sharing and reflecting bricolage experiences. Above all things, local teacher communities should be facilitated to collaborate and work together for arts education.
Lastly, subsequent studies, which delve into the behavioral elements of bricolage, are required for the competency development approach of empowering knowledge creation and sharing.

국문 초록 (Abstract)

본 연구는 제한된 교육 여건과 새로이 제시된 역량기반 교육과정 하에서 양질의 미술교육을 실현하고자 노력하고 있는 현장의 미술교사들이 혁신적 브리콜뢰르로서 자리매김을 할 수 있도록 이론적 토대를 마련할 목적으로 수행되었다. 브리콜라주와 브리콜뢰르 개념은 조직, 제도, 방법론 등 다양한 분야에서 현실의 제약을 정확히 인지하고 주어진 것으로부터 최대의 가치를 이끌어 내기 위해 창의성을 발휘하는 과정과 긍정적 행위자에 대한 이해를 도모하는 데 새롭게 활용되고 있다. 미술교사가 단지 생존전략으로서 임기응변과 기만적 수단으로 브리콜라주를 구사하던 방식에서 벗어나 점차 복잡해지는 미술교육의 요건들을 수용하고 조합하여 창의적으로 문제를 해결해 나가는 혁신적 브리콜뢰르로서의 역량을 육성해 나갈 필요가 있다. 이것은 현실과 괴리가 있는 미술교사 양성과정의 문제를 개선하고 혁신적 브리콜라주 경험과 성찰의 기회를 제공하기 위한 학교 풍토 조성과 지역별 협력적 교사커뮤니티를 활성화하는 것으로부터 출발할 수 있다. 더불어 지식 창출의 권한을 부여하고 공유하는 새로운 형태의 교수역량 개발의 접근법으로 브리콜라주 행동을 계속 연구할 필요가 있음을 제안한다.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 김미남, "중학교 미술교사가 교직 경험 속에서 인지한 “전문성”에 대한 현상학적 연구" 한국국제미술교육학회 17 (17): 133-166, 2016

2 정연희, "중등미술교육에 영향을 미치는 학습환경 요인 연구" 한국미술교육학회 30 (30): 1-34, 2016

3 박정애, "시각적 텍스트로서의 미술작품 : 의미 읽기" 3 : 179-194, 2002

4 안인기, "시각문화의 브리콜라주로서 미디어 리터러시 재고" 한국미술교육학회 25 (25): 145-172, 2011

5 교육부, "미술과 교육과정"

6 Derrida, J., "Writing and Difference" University of Chicago Press 1978

7 Derrida, J., "Writing and Difference" Taylor and Francis e-library 358-370, 1967

8 Starr-Glass, D. B., "Wild pansies, trojan horses, and others : International teaching and learning as bricolage" 4 (4): 24-, 2010

9 Grant, C. A., "Who determines teacher work : The teacher, the organization, or both?" 1 (1): 209-220, 1985

10 Feiman-Nemser, S., "When is student teaching teacher education" 3 : 255-273, 1987

11 Louvel, S., "Understanding change in higher education as bricolage: how academics engage in curriculum change" 66 (66): 669-691, 2013

12 Bolster, A. S., "Towards a more effective model of research on teaching" 59 (59): 294-308, 1983

13 Duymedjian, R., "Towards a foundation of bricolage in organization and management theory" 31 (31): 133-151, 2010

14 Denscombe, M., "The work context of teaching : an analytic framework for the study of teachers in classrooms" 1 (1): 279-292, 1980

15 Tinning, R., "The student teaching experience : All that glitters is not gold" 4 (4): 53-62, 1984

16 Lévi-Strauss, C., "The savage mind" University of Chicago Press 1966

17 Schön, D., "The reflective practitioner" Basic Books Inc 1983

18 Tushnet, M., "The possibilities of comparative constitutional law" 108 : 1225-1306, 1999

19 Denscombe, M., "The hidden pedagogy and its implications for teacher training" 3 (3): 249-265, 1982

20 Duboule, D., "The evolution of “bricolage”" 14 : 54-59, 1998

21 Zeichner, K., "The belief systems of university supervisors in an elementary student teaching program" 8 (8): 34-54, 1982

22 Denzin, N. K., "The Sage Handbook of Qualitative Research" Sage 1-32, 1999

23 Chao, E., "The Maoist shaman and the madman : Ritual bricolage, failed ritual, and failed ritual theory" 14 : 505-534, 1999

24 Freebody P., "The Literacy Lexicon" Prentice-Hall 51-66, 2003

25 Fox, G. T., "The C.M.T.I. Impact Study" USOE/Teacher Corps 1976

26 Connell, R. W., "Teachers’ work" Allen & Unwin 1985

27 Huberman, M., "Teachers’ Work: Individuals, Colleagues and Contexts" Teachers College Press 11-50, 1993

28 Honan, E., "Teachers as researchers using the four resources model as a map of practices" 2003

29 Kincheloe, J. L., "Teachers as Researchers : Qualitative inquiry as a path to empowerment" Routledge Falmer 2003

30 Tabachnick, B., "Teacher education and the professional perspective of student teachers" 10 (10): 12-29, 1979

31 Olsen, B., "Teacher as mediator of school reform : an examination of teacher practice in 36 California restructuring schools" 104 (104): 301-324, 2002

32 Hebdige, D., "Subculture : The meaning of style" Routledge 1979

33 Hargreaves, A., "Sociological Interpretations of Schooling and Classrooms: a reappraisal" Nafferton 1978

34 Woods, P., "School experience" Croom Helm 1977

35 Berry, K., "Rigour and complexity in educational research : conducting educational research" Open University Press 2004

36 Zeichner, K., "Reflective teaching and field‐based experience in teacher education" 12 (12): 1-22, 1981

37 Patterson, A., "Questions of English: ethics, aesthetics, rhetoric and the formation of the subject in England, Australia and the United States" Routledge 254-282, 2000

38 Talbert, Joan, T., "Professional communities and the artisan model of teaching" 8 (8): 325-343, 2002

39 Taylor, J., "Playing it queer: Popular music, identity and queer world-making" Peter Lang 2012

40 Feiman-Nemser, S., "Pitfalls of experience in teacher preparation" 87 : 53-65, 1985

41 Freathy, R., "Pedagogical bricoleurs and bricolage researchers : The case of religious education" 65 (65): 425-443, 2017

42 Campbell, L., "Pedagogical bricolage and teacher agency : Towards a culture of creative professionalism" 51 (51): 31-40, 2019

43 Kincheloe, J. L., "On to the next level : Continuing the conceptualization of the bricolage" 11 (11): 323-350, 2005

44 Hull, N. E. H., "Networks and bricolage : A prolegomenon to a history of 20th-century American academic jurisprudence" 35 : 307-322, 1991

45 Hatton, E., "Lévi-Strauss's Bricolage and theorizing teachers' work" 20 (20): 74-96, 1989

46 Lévi-Strauss, C., "La Pensée sauvage" Plon 1966

47 Baker, T., "Improvising firms : Bricolage, account giving and improvisational competencies in the founding process" 32 (32): 255-276, 2003

48 Popkewitz, T., "Ideology as a problem of teacher education"

49 Lampert, M., "How do teachers manage to teach? Perspectives on problems in practice" 55 (55): 178-194, 1985

50 Weinstein, D., "Georg Simmel: sociological flaneur bricoleur" 8 (8): 151-168, 1991

51 Luke, A., "Further notes on the four resources model"

52 Campbell, J. L., "Evolutionary Economics and Path Dependence" Edward Elgar 10-32, 1997

53 Senyard, J. M., "Entrepreneurial bricolage and firm performance: Moderating effects of firm change and innovativeness" 2010

54 Barnard, A., "Encyclopedia of social and cultural anthropology" Routledge 2002

55 Ball, S., "Education reform : A critical and post-structural approach" Open University Press 1994

56 Dent, J. N., "Education and poverty : an Australian primary school case study" 40 : 46-64, 1996

57 Cleaver, F., "Development through bricolage: Rethinking institutions for natural resource management" Routledge 2012

58 Kincheloe, J. L., "Describing the bricolage : Conceptualizing a new rigor in qualitative research" 7 (7): 679-692, 2001

59 Baker, T., "Creating something from nothing : Resource construction through entrepreneurial bricolage" 50 (50): 329-366, 2005

60 Giles, J. R., "Changes, Issues and Prospects in Australian Education" University of Queensland Press 189-194, 1981

61 Phillimore, J., "Bricolage: Potential as a conceptual tool for understanding access to welfare in superdiverse neighbourhoods" IRIS 2016

62 Casteran, T., "Bricolage: Innovation without destruction"

63 Garud, R., "Bricolage versus breakthrough : distributed and embedded agency in technology entrepreneurship" 32 : 277-300, 2003

64 Zollo, L., "Bricolage and social entrepreneurship to address emergent social needs: A “deconstructionist” perspective" 14 (14): 19-47, 2018

65 Senyard, J. M., "Bricolage and early stage firm performance" Queensland University of Technology 2015

66 Hutchinson, S., "Boundaries, bricolage and student-teacher learning" The Open University 2008

67 Lanzara, G. F., "Between transient constructs and persistent structures : Designing systems in action" 8 : 331-349, 1999

68 Deleuze, G., "Anti-Oedipus: Capitalism and schizophrenia" Les Éditions de Minuit 1972

69 Zahra, S., "A typology of social entrepreneurs : motives, search processes and ethical challenges" 24 (24): 519-532, 2009

70 Deleuze, G., "A thousand plateaus. capitalism and schizophrenia" The Athlone Press 1987

71 Zimpher, N., "A closer look at university student teacher supervision" 31 (31): 11-15, 1980