섹슈얼리티 개념 분석과 성윤리의 정립

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Alan Goldman criticizes means-end analyses in that they define the concept of sexuality in terms of extrinsic values to sexuality, such as reproduction, love, and communication. And he claims that sexual desire in itself is only desire for contact with another person`s body and for the pleasure which such contact produces. I suggest that his analysis of sexuality also fails to offer the exact definition of sexuality, and that it also produces the hierarchial conception of sexuality just as those analyses that he refuses do. I agree to Christopher Hamilton`s suggestion of Wittgenstein`s idea of family resemblance and suggest a new sexual ethics focusing on the sexual autonomy. New sexual ethics demands that each person should formulate, reflect, evaluate, and revise his or her sexuality according to his or her own conception of sexuality and teleology. And I claim that new sexual ethics does not formulate distinct domain, but belongs to general ethics which general behaviors are judged through.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 장필화, "성차별과 성윤리: 성윤리에서의 성적 불평등 in:현대사회와 성윤리" 아산사회복지사업재단 1997

2 류지한, "성윤리" 울력 2002

3 이민수, "성 평등주의와 성윤리 문제" 2 (2): 1998

4 Vannoy, Russell, "사랑이 없는성: 철학적 탐구" 철학과현실사 2003

5 Aquinas, Thomas, "The Purpose of Sex, Philosophy and Sex,3rd edition" Prometheus Books 91-95, 1988

6 Soble, Alan, "The Philosophy of Sex: Contemporary Readings, (ed) 5th." Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc. 2008

7 Soble, Alan, "The Philosophy of Sex and Love, 2nd." Paragon House 2008

8 Soble, Alan, "Sexuality and Sexual Ethics, in Encyclopedia of Ethics, 2nd., vol. 3" Routledge 1570-1576, 2001

9 Nagel, Thomas, "Sexual Perversion" 66 : 5-17, 1969

10 Priest, Graham, "Sexual Perversion" 75 (75): 360-372, 1997

11 Solomon, Rober, "Sexual Paradigms" 71 : 336-345, 1974

12 Scruton, Roger, "Sexual Desire: A Philosophical Investigation" Phoenix 1986

13 Hamilton, Christopher, "Sex in The Philosophy of Sex: Contemporary Readings, edited by Alan Soble and Nicholas Power, 5th ed" Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc. 99-116, 2008

14 Goldman, Alan, "Plain Sex" 6 (6): 267-287, 1977

15 Pope Paul Ⅵ, "Humanae Vitae, in Philosophy and Sex, 3rd edition" Prometheus Books 96-105, 1988

16 Belliotti, Raymond A, "Good Sex: Perspectives on Sexual Ethics" University Press of Kansas 1993

17 Primoratz, Igor, "Ethics and Sex in Better Sex, Philosophy and Sex, 1st ed. and 2nd ed." Routledge 1999

18 MacIntyre, Alasdair, "After Virtue, 2n ed." University of Notre Dame Press 1984