The Predicament of Europe’s ‘Last Dictator’

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Belarusian citizens elected their first president in 1994. More than 20 years later, in October 2015, the same person triumphantly won the fifth consecutive presidential election. In August 2020, President Lukashenko’s attempt to get re-elected for the sixth time ended in months’ long mass protests against the electoral fraud, unspeakable violence used by the riot police against peaceful protesters and the deepest political crisis in the modern history of Belarus. This article analyzes how and why the first democratically elected Belarusian president attained this long-serving status. It suggests that his political longevity was conditioned by a specific social contract with the society that was sustained for many years. In light of the recent events, it is obvious that the contract is breached with the regime no longer living up to the bargain with the Belarusian people. As a result, the citizens seem unwilling to maintain their obligation for loyalty. We analyze the escalating daily price for maintaining the status quo and conclude considering the possible implications of this broken pact for the future of Belarus.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Gushtyn D, "‘Wages will grow two times’. Comparing Lukashenko’s promises in all his election programs" TUT

2 Troianovski A, "‘Something broke inside Belarusians’ Why an apolitical people rose up" The New York Times

3 Zayats D, "Will wages and pensions catch up with prices?" Naviny.by

4 Nikolayenko O, "Why post-election protests persist in Belarus" Mobilizing Ideas

5 IISEPS, "What tomorrow will bring"

6 Marples D, "What to expect from the 2015 presidential elections in Belarus?" BelarusDigest

7 Meduza, "Wages growth and a referendum on the Constitution, The election program of Aleksandr Lukashenko has been published"

8 "Voice platform, Zubr platform, Honest People initiative"

9 Ioffe G, "Understanding Belarus" Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc 2008

10 U.S. Department of State, "U.S. Department of State, Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights, and Labor, 2010 Human Rights Report: Belarus"

11 IISEPS, "Twenty years later"

12 Bennetts M, "Tractors and vodka will cure Belarus of the coronavirus, says leader"

13 Lukashenko A, "The second all-Belarusian people’s assembly. Opening remarks by the President of the Republic of Belarus Alexander Lukashenko"

14 Gagyi A, "The rise and fall of civil society in East-Central Europe, Civil Society in Central and Eastern Europe: What is Left of It? European Alternatives"

15 Nikaliuk S, "The political crisis in Belarus, Everything is just beginning"

16 Grichtchenko JM, "The local political elite in the democratic transformation of Belarus" 540 : 118-125, 1995

17 Shraibman A, "The house that Lukashenko built: The foundation, evolution, and future of the Belarusian regime" Carnegie Moscow Center

18 IISEPS, "The echo of the oil and gas conflict"

19 Diamond L, "The democratic rollback: The resurgence of the predatory state" 87 (87): 36-48, 2008

20 Diamond L, "The Spirit of Democracy" Times Books, Henry Holt and Company, LLC 2008

21 Rousseau J-J, "The Social Contract" Hafner Publishing 1947

22 Pateman C, "The Sexual Contract" Stanford University 1988

23 Locke J, "The Second Treatise of Civil Government" Bobbs-Merrill 1952

24 Moghaddam FM, "The Psychology of Dictatorship" American Psychological Association 2013

25 Frantz E, "The Politics of Dictatorship" Lynne Rienner Publishers, Inc 2011

26 Glod K, "The Future of Belarus" The Center for European Policy Analysis

27 Manaev O, "The Belarus election and its aftermath – an expert analysis" Wilson Center

28 Chubrik A, "Ten years of GDP growth in Belarus : Factors and prospects" 4 (4): 454-474, 2004

29 IISEPS, "Telly vs. fridge"

30 Belsat, "Tailspin: The number of supporters of the union with Russia decreased by a third"

31 NSC, "Statistical yearbook of the Republic of Belarus"

32 Kordonsky S, "State, civil society, and corruption"

33 Fukuyama F, "Social capital, civil society and development" 22 (22): 7-20, 2001

34 Alkaev O, "Shooters Team: There Is a Profession Killing People" Open Belarus Foundation

35 Dougherty J, "Rice: Russia’s future linked to democracy" CNN

36 IISEPS, "Results of the national public opinion poll conducted in March and April of 2006"

37 IISEPS, "Results of the national opinion poll conducted in September of 2015" The data are the courtesy of the IISEPS expert, Siarhei Nikaliuk 2015

38 CCE, "Results of the election of the president of the Republic of Belarus on September 9, 2001"

39 CCE, "Results of the election of the president of the Republic of Belarus on March 19, 2006"

40 CCE, "Results of the election of the president of the Republic of Belarus on June 23, 1994 and July 10, 1994"

41 CCE, "Results of the Republican Referendum on October 17, 2004"

42 IISEPS, "Results of the Nation Opinion Poll, September 2014"

43 CCE, "Results of the Election of the president of the Republic of Belarus in 2015"

44 Charter’97, "Residential community for officials in Drazdy grows"

45 Questions, "Questions of the republican referendum in the Republic of Belarus, 24 November 1996"

46 Press Conference, "President of the Republic of Belarus Alexander Lukashenko answers questions of mass media representatives on 23 March 2014"

47 Baker P, "President claims victory in Belarus" The Washington Post

48 Gapova E, "Over the Wall/After the Fall" Indiana University Press 65-87, 2004

49 CCE, "On the results of voting at the republican referendum on November 24, 1996"

50 CCE, "On the results of voting at the republican referendum on May 14, 1995"

51 National Bank of the Republic of Belarus, "Official exchange rate of the Belarusian ruble against foreign currencies set by the National Bank of the Republic of Belarus on a daily basis"

52 Shraibman A, "Oatmeal and water: The thinning Belarus-Russia relationship" Carnegie Moscow Center

53 Benedek W, "OSCE rapporteur’s report under the Moscow Mechanism on alleged human rights violations related to the presidential elections of 9 August 2020 in Belarus" OSCE Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights

54 Mercer C, "NGOs, civil society and democratization: A critical review of the literature" 2 (2): 5-22, 2002

55 Manaev O, "More state than nation: Lukashenko’s Belarus" 65 (65): 93-113, 2011

56 National Bank of the Republic of Belarus, "Main tendencies in the economy and money-and-credit sphere of the Republic of Belarus"

57 National Bank of the Republic of Belarus, "Main tendencies in the economy and money-and-credit sphere of the Republic of Belarus"

58 Shraibman A, "Lukashenko’s vicious circle" Carnegie Moscow Center

59 Naviny.by, "Lukashenko’s election program: To become richer and freer"

60 Narodnaya Gazeta, "Lukashenko’s Election Program 1994, ‘To divert the people from the abyss’"

61 Heritage T, "Lukashenko: “I am the last and only dictator in Europe”" Atlantic Council

62 Matveev V, "Lukashenko: There will be no Maidan in Minsk, there is no room for Maidan here" Belta

63 Hobbes T, "Leviathan" Penguin 1968

64 Ulasiuk I, "Language policies and law in education in post-Soviet Belarus" 7 (7): 31-39, 2011

65 IISEPS, "It’s all about context"

66 Goble PA, "Is Lukashenko worried about the loyalty of the Belarusian siloviki?" Euromaidan Press

67 Hann C, "International Encyclopaedia of Anthropology Vol. 2" Wiley Blackwell 877-879, 2016

68 Kordonsky S, "In reality and in sober fact"

69 IMF, "IMF country report No 05/217, Republic of Belarus: Selected issues"

70 Magaloni B, "Hegemonic Party Survival and Its Demise in Mexico" Cambridge University Press 2006

71 Weiss TG, "Governance, good governance and global governance : Conceptual and actual challenges" 21 (21): 795-814, 2000

72 Niebel D, "Good governance in practice. Approaches and examples from development practice"

73 Clem RS, "Going it alone : Belarus as the non-European European state" 52 (52): 780-798, 2011

74 Quigley KFF, "Funding Virtue" The Brookings Institution Press 191-216, 2000

75 Freedom House, "Freedom in the world 2020" Poland

76 Rácz A, "Four scenarios for the crisis in Belarus" German Council on Foreign Relations

77 Belarus Segodnya, "Election Program of the Candidate for the Presidency Aleksandr Lukashenko: A state for the people"

78 Belta, "Election 2015. The election program of Alexander Lukashenko, candidate for the office of the President of the Republic of Belarus"

79 IISEPS, "Dynamics of annualized monthly employees’ wages (2001–2010)"

80 Baturo A, "Democracy, Dictatorship, and Term Limits" The University of Michigan Press 2014

81 Shraibman A, "Coronavirus inflames Russia-Belarus quarrel" Carnegie Moscow Center

82 Korosteleva EA, "Contemporary Belarus" Routledge Curzon 1-20, 2003

83 Greene AT, "Comparative development of post-communist civil societies" 54 (54): 455-471, 2002

84 Grødeland AB, "Civil society in post-communist Europe : Perceptions and use of contacts" 7 (7): 129-156, 2011

85 Shelest O, "Civil society in Belarus: The current status and conditions of development"

86 Wallace C, "Changing patterns of civil society in Europe and America 1995–2005 : Is Eastern Europe different?" 26 : 3-19, 2012

87 United Nations, "Best practice in the development of entrepreneurship and SMEs in countries in transition:The Belarusian experience" 2003

88 Ioffe G, "Belarus’s sovereignty and Russia’s brotherly embrace" 16 (16): 2019

89 Belta, "Belarus’ losses due to tax maneuver in Russia close to $330m in 2019"

90 Belta, "Belarusian oil refineries keep domestic market well supplied, ship critical exports"

91 Fletcher M, "Belarus: Europe’s secret state" GQ

92 Woehrel S, "Belarus: Background and U.S. policy concerns" Congressional Research Service

93 Sivitsky A, "Belarus – Russia: From a strategic deal to an integration ultimatum" The Foreign Policy Research Institute

94 Shraibman A, "Belarus protests signal the autumn of Lukashenko’s regime" Carnegie Moscow Center

95 World Bank Group, "Belarus partnership country program snapshot"

96 Picheta R, "Belarus leader says there won’t be new elections ‘until you kill me’ as protesters rally against strongman"

97 Jones K, "Belarus crisis: Will the army remain loyal to Lukashenka? In UkraineAlert, Atlantic Council"

98 NSC, "Belarus average monthly wages"

99 Douglas N, "Belarus at a Crossroads: Attitudes on social and political change" Center for East European and International Studies

100 Freedom House, "Belarus"

101 Dawson M, "Behind the Mule" Princeton University 1994

102 Results, "Announcement of the Central Commission of the Republic of Belarus on Elections and Conducting Republican Referenda on the results of the voting at the republican referendum, 24 November 1996"

103 IISEPS, "Ambivalent geopolitical choice"

104 Rawls J, "A Theory of Justice" Belknap 1971

105 McCarthy E, "2017 Civil Society Organization Sustainability Index, For Central and Eastern Europe and Eurasia" U.S. Agency for International Development 2018

106 Sverdlov P, "12 years ago Lukashenko promised a wage of $500 for the first time"