Comparative study of two collagen membranes for guided tissue regeneration therapy in periodontal intrabony defects: a randomized clinical trial

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Purpose: The purpose of this study was to assess and compare the clinical and radiographic outcomes of guided tissue regeneration therapy for human periodontal intrabony defects using two different collagen membranes: a porous nonchemical cross-linking collagen membrane (NC) and a bilayer collagen membrane (BC).
Methods: Thirty subjects were randomly assigned and divided into the following 3 groups: a test group (NC+BM), in which a NC was used with xenograft bone mineral (BM), a positive control group (BC+BM), in which a BC was used with xenograft BM, and a negative control group (BM), in which only xenograft BM was used. The following clinical measurements were taken at baseline and 3 months after surgery: plaque index, gingival index, probing pocket depth, gingival recession, and clinical attachment level. Radiographic analysis was performed at baseline, 1 week and 3 months after surgery.
Results: Membrane exposure was not observed in any cases. Significant probing depth reduction, attachment-level gain and bone fill were observed for both test and control groups compared to baseline at 3 months after surgery (P<0.05). However, there were no statistically significant differences in clinical improvement and radiographic bone fill between treatment protocols (P>0.05).
Conclusions: Within the limitations of this study, the results suggest that both NC and BC were comparable in terms of clinical and radiographic outcomes for the treatment of periodontal intrabony defects in human subjects.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Sanz M, "Treatment of intrabony defects with enamel matrix proteins or barrier membranes: results from a multicenter practice-based clinical trial" 75 : 726-733, 2004

2 Sculean A, "Treatment of intrabony defects with enamel matrix proteins and guided tissue regeneration. A prospective controlled clinical study" 28 : 397-403, 2001

3 Hugoson A, "Treatment of class II furcation involvements in humans with bioresorbable and nonresorbable guided tissue regeneration barriers. A randomized multi-center study" 66 : 624-634, 1995

4 Quteish D, "The use of irradiated-crosslinked human collagen membrane in guided tissue regeneration" 19 : 476-484, 1992

5 Loe H, "The gingival index, the plaque index and the retention index systems" 38 : 610-616, 1967

6 Hammerle CH, "Single stage surgery combining transmucosal implant placement with guided bone regeneration and bioresorbable materials" 12 : 9-18, 2001

7 Trombelli L, "Retrospective analysis of factors related to clinical outcome of guided tissue regeneration procedures in intrabony defects" 24 : 366-371, 1997

8 Zitzmann NU, "Resorbable versus nonresorbable membranes in combination with Bio-Oss for guided bone regeneration" 12 : 844-852, 1997

9 Nevins M, "Platelet-derived growth factor stimulates bone fill and rate of attachment level gain: results of a large multicenter randomized controlled trial" 76 : 2205-2215, 2005

10 Haney JM, "Periodontal repair in dogs: expanded polytetrafluoroethylene barrier membranes support wound stabilization and enhance bone regeneration" 64 : 883-890, 1993

11 Camelo M, "Periodontal regeneration with an autogenous bone-Bio-Oss composite graft and a Bio-Gide membrane" 21 : 109-119, 2001

12 Robert PM, "Periodontal guided tissue regeneration with a new resorbable polylactic acid membrane" 65 : 414-422, 1994

13 Melcher AH, "On the repair potential of periodontal tissues" 47 : 256-260, 1976

14 Magnusson I, "New attachment formation following controlled tissue regeneration using biodegradable membranes" 59 : 1-6, 1988

15 Nyman S, "New attachment following surgical treatment of human periodontal disease" 9 : 290-296, 1982

16 Stahl SS, "Human histologic responses to guided tissue regenerative techniques in intrabony lesions. Case reports on 9 sites" 17 : 191-198, 1990

17 Caton J, "Histometric evaluation of periodontal surgery. II. Connective tissue attachment levels after four regenerative procedures" 7 : 224-231, 1980

18 Cortellini P, "Histologic assessment of new attachment following the treatment of a human buccal recession by means of a guided tissue regeneration procedure" 64 : 387-391, 1993

19 Hardwick R, "Guided bone regeneration in implant dentistry" Quintessence 101-136, 1994

20 Olde Damink LH, "Glutaraldehyde as a crosslinking agent for collagen-based biomaterials" 6 : 460-472, 1995

21 Zahedi S, "Evaluation of a diphenylphosphorylazide-crosslinked collagen membrane for guided bone regeneration in mandibular defects in rats" 69 : 1238-1246, 1998

22 Zucchelli G, "Enamel matrix proteins and guided tissue regeneration with titanium-reinforced expanded polytetrafluoroethylene membranes in the treatment of infrabony defects: a comparative controlled clinical trial" 73 : 3-12, 2002

23 Karring T, "Development of the biological concept of guided tissue regeneration: animal and human studies" 1 : 26-35, 1993

24 Black BS, "Comparative study of collagen and expanded polytetrafluoroethylene membranes in the treatment of human class II furcation defects" 65 : 598-604, 1994

25 Rao KP, "Collagen, vol. III. Biotechnology" CRC Press Inc 63-86, 1988

26 Camelo M, "Clinical, radiographic, and histologic evaluation of human periodontal defects treated with Bio-Oss and Bio-Gide" 18 : 321-331, 1998

27 Chvapil M, "Biology of collagen" Academic Press 313-325, 1980

28 이창균, "Biological effects of a porcine-derived collagen membrane on intrabony defects" 대한치주과학회 40 (40): 232-238, 2010

29 Rothamel D, "Biocompatibility of various collagen membranes in cultures of human PDL fibroblasts and human osteoblast-like cells" 15 : 443-449, 2004

30 Trombelli L, "A systematic review of graft materials and biological agents for periodontal intraosseous defects" 29 (29): 117-135, 2002