Aiming for increasing the effectiveness of disaster responses, this study analyzed social capital and investigated how to expand it for effective disaster responses. Specifically, incorporating social capital theory into disaster responses and measuri...
Aiming for increasing the effectiveness of disaster responses, this study analyzed social capital and investigated how to expand it for effective disaster responses. Specifically, incorporating social capital theory into disaster responses and measuring the social capital of current fire service organizations, it identified the most important factor of making up social capital for disaster responses and explored the scheme of maximizing the effectiveness.
In order to analyze the social capital for disaster management, first of all, the study focused on the response phase of disaster management, and limited the range of governmental disaster-responding organizations to fire-fighting ones. As for the subjects of case analysis, it selected and analyzed two representative disaster cases occurred in Korea: the breakdown of Sampoong Department Store in 1995 and the conflagration of Daegu Subway in 2003. Conducting literature research, case analysis, positive analysis, and interviews, it investigated the influences of social capital on the disaster responses of fire service organizations and the schemes of expanding the social capital effectively, deriving the test results of the research hypotheses for the expansion schemes as follows:
H1(adopted): the trust of fire service organizations will have positive influence on the effectiveness of disaster responses; H2(adopted): the network of fire service organizations will have positive influence on the effectiveness of disaster responses; H3(rejected): the reciprocity of fire service organizations will have positive influence on the effectiveness of disaster responses; H4(adopted): the participation of fire service organizations will have positive influence on the effectiveness of disaster responses; H5(adopted): the bonding between the internal members of fire service organizations will have positive influence on the effectiveness of disaster responses; H6(rejected): the bridging between fire service organizations and other public sectors will have positive influence on the effectiveness of disaster responses; H7(rejected): the linking between fire service and private organizations will have positive influence on the effectiveness of disaster responses.
Although H6 and H7 were rejected, these results can be the basis to suggest the future direction of fire service organizations to enhance the effectiveness of disaster responses. As disaster management organizations, particularly fire-fighting ones, carry out their tasks directly in disaster sites, other public sectors like police and private organizations play an assistant role or support, and in practical disaster situations, particularly in dangerous ones, they come to carry out on-site tasks relying on their coworkers. Thus, the bonding between internal members can be considered as the most important factor for fire-fighting officials who carry out on-site responding tasks. As shown in the research result, the bonding between the internal members of fire service organizations was proved to be the more important factor that influences disaster responses than bridging with other public sectors and linking with private organizations.
Based on these findings, the schemes of expanding social capital for disaster responses were suggested: first, to construct the network with public-private organizations; second, to facilitate the collective activities related to disaster responses; third, to make up the trust between public organizations; fourth, to facilitate the network between public organizations; fifth, to expand the participation between public organizations; sixth, to collect various opinions related to disaster responses; seventh, to ensure the preparation of resources for large-scale disaster responses; finally, to make up the trust between fire-fighting and private organizations.
While there is a limit that the disaster management suggested in this study is not concrete, there is also an implication that it can help to derive policy suggestions to enhance the effectiveness of fire service organizations' disaster responses. It is essentially consistent with the existing discourses that the organic cooperation system between central and municipal governments, governments and citizens, such as private-public network, partnership, and governance, should be constructed to enhance the effectiveness of disaster management, but it is different from them that it analyzed various factors and derived the results in terms of bonding, bridging, and linking.
Although the findings suggested that it is the internal bonding in fire service organizations that have important influence on their disaster responses, it can conversely verify the fact that such recognition has dominated disaster responses so far. Therefore, it is considered necessary to develop effective disaster responses by making up social capital such as trust, network, reciprocity, and participation between the disaster-response officials of fire service organizations and other public sectors like police, military, and municipality. Also, constructing social capital between fire-fighting and private organizations is considered to be the scheme for enhancing the effectiveness of disaster responses in future. Not only bridging fire service organizations with public sectors and linking them with private sectors, but also constructing social capital between public and private organizations outside fire-fighting ones are considered possible to be the important factor.