Information, rebel organization and civil war escalation: The case of the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Current literature on civil war is well aware of the importance of defection by rebel members for civil war dynamics, including that of ethnic defection. However, scholars have not closely examined the effects of defection on civil war. In this article, I argue that rebel members’ defection and resultant information leaks to the state increase the likelihood of the state’s military escalation through their effects on three aspects of conflict: the efficiency of the state’s offensives against the rebel group; the efficiency of the state’s defenses against rebel group’s offensives; and the level of uncertainty for the state in war. These effects of defection, however, are conditional on the credibility and consequentiality of the information from the defectors. The utilities of the alternative courses of action for the state also matters. The theory is applied to the case of civil war in Sri Lanka to explain the state’s initiation of Eelam War IV, which ended with a swift and thorough state victory. An implication of the theory is that the experience in Sri Lanka is not easily replicable elsewhere. The findings have implications to the studies of the duration and termination of civil war as well as to the studies of the use of violence against civilians.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 The World Bank, "World Development Indicators"

2 The World Bank, "World Development Indicators"

3 Obayashi K, "Why does the LRA continue abduction? An intra-group politics approach" 2011

4 Fearon JD, "Why do some civil wars last so much longer than others?" 41 (41): 275-301, 2004

5 Beehner L, "What Sri Lanka can teach us about COIN" Small Wars Journal

6 Powell R, "War as a commitment problem" 60 (60): 169-203, 2006

7 Höglund K, "Violence and the peace process in Sri Lanka" 7 (7): 156-170, 2005

8 Agence France Presse, "Victory’s price: 6,200 Sri Lankan troops"

9 Cunningham DE, "Veto players and civil war duration" 50 (50): 875-892, 2006

10 Smith N, "Understanding Sri Lanka’s defeat of the Tamil Tigers" 59 (59): 40-44, 2010

11 Uppsala Conflict Data Program, "UCDP Database"

12 Byman D, "Trends in Outside Support for Insurgent Movements" Rand 2001

13 Moorcraft PL, "Total Destruction of the Tamil Tigers: The Rare Victory of Sri Lanka’s Long War" Pen & Sword Military 2012

14 Swamy MRN, "Tigers of Lanka, from Boys to Guerrillas, 7th edn" Vijitha Yapa Publications 2006

15 Sri Lankan Ministry of Defence, Public Security, Law & Order, "The spatial and temporal distribution of terrorist activities and government humanitarian efforts 1981–2009"

16 Axelrod R, "The rational timing of surprise" 31 (31): 228-246, 1979

17 Slantchev BL, "The power to hurt : Costly conflict with completely informed states" 97 (97): 123-133, 2003

18 Kalyvas SN, "The paradox of terrorism in civil war" 8 (8): 97-138, 2004

19 Beber B., "The logic of child soldiering and coercion" 67 (67): 65-104, 2013

20 Rajasingham K, "The execution of Mahattaya in “Sri Lanka: The Untold Story" Asia Times Online

21 DeRouen Jr KR., "The dynamics of civil war duration and outcome" 41 (41): 303-320, 2004

22 Walter BF, "The critical barrier to civil war settlement" 51 (51): 335-364, 1997

23 United States Deptartment of the Army and United States Marine Corps, "The U.S. Army/Marine Corps Counterinsurgency Field Manual: U.S. Army Field Manual no.3-24" University of Chicago Press 2007

24 Swamy MRN, "The Tiger Vanquished : LTTE’s Story" SAGE 2010

25 Gunaratna R, "The Political Economy of Armed Conflict: Beyond Greed and Grievance" Lynne Rienner 197-223, 2003

26 Kalyvas SN, "The Logic of Violence in Civil War" Cambridge University Press 2006

27 DeVotta N, "The Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam and the lost quest for separatism in Sri Lanka" 49 (49): 1021-1051, 2009

28 Hirshleifer J, "The Dark Side of the Force: Economic Foundations of Conflict Theory" Cambridge University Press 102-130, 2001

29 Hirshleifer J, "The Dark Side of the Force: Economic Foundations of Conflict Theory" Cambridge University Press 43-67, 2001

30 Bueno de Mesquita E, "Terrorist factions" 3 (3): 399-418, 2008

31 Reuters, "Tamil Tigers may be second richest rebel group worldwide"

32 Mehta A, "Sri Lanka’s Ethnic Conflict: How Eelam War IV was Won" Centre for Land Warfare Studies 2010

33 International Crisis Group, "Sri Lanka: The failure of the peace process" Asia Report

34 Stedman SJ, "Spoiler problems in peace processes" 22 (22): 5-53, 1997

35 Fearon JD., "Sons of the Soil, migrants, and civil war" 39 (39): 199-211, 2011

36 Kydd AF., "Sabotaging the peace : The politics of extremist violence" 56 (56): 263-296, 2002

37 Global Terrorism Database, "START"

38 Gates S, "Recruitment and allegiance : The microfoundations of rebellion" 46 (46): 111-131, 2002

39 Singer JD, "Reconstructing the Correlates of War dataset on material capabilities of states, 1816–1985" 14 : 115-132, 1987

40 Leites N., "Rebellion and Authority; An Analytic Essay on Insurgent Conflicts" Markham 1970

41 Fearon JD, "Rationalist explanations for war" 49 (49): 379-414, 1995

42 Lyall J., "Rage against the machines : Explaining outcomes in counterinsurgency wars" 63 (63): 67-106, 2009

43 Singer JD., "Peace, War, and Numbers" Sage Publications 1972

44 Collier P., "On the duration of civil war" 41 (41): 253-273, 2004

45 Mao Z, "On Guerrilla Warfare" Praeger 1961

46 Correlates of War, "National Material Capabilities (version 4.0)"

47 Doyle MW., "Making War and Building Peace: United Nations Peace Operations" Princeton University Press 2006

48 Human Rights Watch, "Living in fear: Child soldiers and the Tamil Tigers in Sri Lanka" Human Rights Watch November

49 Cunningham DE., "It takes two : A dyadic analysis of civil war duration and outcome" 53 (53): 570-597, 2009

50 "International Institute for Strategic Studies (various years) The Military Balance" International Institute for Strategic Studies

51 Wijewardana D, "How LTTE lost the Eelam War: Defeat of the Tamil Tiger Terrorists who Ravaged Sri Lanka for over 30 Years" Pannipitiya 2010

52 Powell R, "Guns, butter, and anarchy" 87 (87): 115-132, 1993

53 National Consortium for the Study of Terrorism and Responses to Terrorism, "Global Terrorsim Database: GTD variables & inclusion criteria"

54 National Consortium for the Study of Terrorism and Responses to Terrorism, "GTD Global Terrorism Database: Data collection methodology"

55 Kalyvas SN, "Ethnic defection in civil war" 41 (41): 1043-1068, 2008

56 Toft MD, "Ending civil wars: A case for rebel victory?" 34 (34): 7-36, 2010

57 Lyall J, "Does indiscriminate violence incite insurgent attacks?" 53 (53): 331-362, 2009

58 Clarke R, "Conventionally defeated but not eradicated: Asian arms networks and the potential for the return of Tamil militancy in Sri Lanka" 13 (13): 157-188, 2011

59 Bueno de Mesquita E, "Conciliation, counterterrorism, and patterns of terrorist violence" 59 (59): 145-176, 2005

60 Walter BF, "Committing to Peace: The Successful Settlement of Civil Wars" Princeton University Press 2002

61 Staniland P, "Between a rock and a hard place : Insurgent fratricide, ethnic defection, and the rise of prostate paramilitaries" 56 (56): 16-40, 2012

62 Powell R, "Bargaining theory and international conflict" 5 : 1-30, 2002

63 Lyall J, "Are coethnics more effective counterinsurgents? Evidence from the second Chechen war" 104 (104): 1-20, 2010

64 Höglund K., ""Damned if you do, and damned if you don’t" : Nordic involvement and images of third-party neutrality in Sri Lanka" 13 (13): 341-364, 2008