저작물의 디지털거래와 권리소진원칙

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

More works may be gradually circulated under digital environment in the future. When we consider this point, the existing first sale doctrine limited to the transactions of tangible things will need to be extended. This paper has examined the tendency of legislations, precedents and theories in the foreign countries such as the United States of America and Germany. In so doing, the author has tried to suggest the standard of the interpretation and desirable development direction of the first sale doctrine prescribed in the copyright act and computer program protection act. Regarding the first sale doctrine, i.e. the freedom of resale, there currently exists discrimination between consumers who bought a book or CD in bookstore or record store and consumers who bought the same thing through internet. A legal status of a consumer who bought music or movies through digital transmission has been weaker than the person who bought CD or videotapes. The person who bought lawfully music through Internet can record this to CD-R and enjoy the music. But, he may not resell the CD-R as a used music CD to third persons, even if he doesn't want to more enjoy the music. Supposing that more works become digitalized gradually and the sale will be realized not by the traditional transfer of tangible things but by method of transmission, is it desirable that such legal situation has to be continued in the future? Unfortunately, current laws of most countries and international treaties regard this discrimination as rightful. Resale and private reproduction have been recognised as a freedom of consumers of copyrighted works for a long time. Persons who bought a book or CD can reproduce this for private use and can resale this to third persons later. Nobody can criticise any copyright infringement towards such acts. This consumer's freedom has been established like a custom. This consumer's freedom should be guaranteed under digital environment. The transaction ability of copyrighted works that consumers bought once should be guaranteed whether these are in the forms of tangible things or digital forms. Simply because the existence form of works is different, its transaction ability should not be limited by eternal distribution right of the copyright owner. There has been controversies on whether the transmission of digital works should be classified into the category of reproduction right, distribution right or the right of communication to the public. By several reasons, international treaties and most national laws came to classify this act into the category of the newly introduced transmission right as a kind of the right of communication to the public. But classifying it into the transmission right as a kind of intangible rights has caused another problem about the application of first sale doctrine which is subject of this treatise. From such viewpoint that copyrighted works as intellectual creations are sold, it can not be denied that on-line transmission is similar to distribution. It is not important what way the consumer has purchased in determining as to whether the distribution right is exhausted or not.

목차 (Table of Contents)

• I. 서론
• II. 전통적 권리소진원칙
• 1. 이론적 근거
• 2. 적용요건
• 3. 지역적 적용범위
• III. 디지털 권리소진원칙
• 1. 문제제기
• 2. 전송의 저작권법상 취급
• 3. 외국에서의 논의
• 4. 디지털 권리소진원칙의 안정에 대한 사견
• IV. 국제적 권리소진원칙
• 1. 속지주의원칙
• 2. 유럽에서의 법률상황
• 3. 국제조약의 태도
• 4. 문헌 빛 판례의 동향
• 5. 디지털 저작물과 국제적 권리소진원칙
• V. 결론 및 전망
• 참고문헌
• Abstract

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 "컴퓨터프로그램보호법 중 개정법률 해설" 45 : 2-10, 1999년

2 "지적소유권법" 1996

3 "정보의 디지털화에 따른 저작재산권의 대응방향" 35 : 65-74, 1996년

4 "정보사회에서의 유럽저작권법의 변화 - 정보사회에서의 저작권 및 저작인접권의 특정분야를 통일하기 위한 지침안을 중심으로 -" 4 : 63-94, 2000

5 "저작권법원론" 1996

6 "저작권법상 권리소진이론" 33 : 69-106, 2003년

7 "저작권법개설" 1997

8 "디지털환경에서의 IPR 최초판매의 원칙" 경원대학교 2003.4

9 "디지털 시대의 저작권법 개정 방향에 관한 소고" 41 : 14-23, 1998년

10 "디지털 송신과 인터넷상의 저작권문제" 42 : 2-10, 1998년

11 "권리소진이론에 관한 연구 : 저작권을 중심으로" 63 : 88-95, 2003년

12 "권리소진이론에 관한 연구" 2003.2

13 "개정 저작권법 해설" 49 : 2-11, 2000년

14 "WIPO 저작권조약 및 실연음반조약 해설(下)" 38 : 4-15, 1997년

15 "WIPO 저작권조약 및 실연음반조약 해설(上)" 37 : 4-12, 1997년

16 "Verlagsrecht. Kommentar" 2001

17 "Urheberrechtliche Erschpfungslehre und digitale Informa- tionstechnologie" 198-203, 2002

18 "Urheberrecht. Kommentar" 1998

19 "Urheberrecht. Kommentar" 1999

20 "Urheberrecht und verwandte Schutzrechte im Internet" 2000

21 "Urheberrecht im Internet: Buch- und CD-Verkauf" 1997

22 "The EC Rental Directive One Year after its Adoption" 1993

23 "National Telecommunications and Information Administration, Study Examining 17 U.S.C. Sections 109 and 117 Pursuant to Section 104 of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act" U.S. Department of Commerce March2001

24 "Internetrecht" 1998

25 "Internetrecht" 1999

26 "Handbuch des Urheberrechts" 1996

27 "Green Paper - Copyright and Related Rights in the Information Society" 1995

28 "Gewerblicher Rechts- schutz und Urheberrecht im Internet" 645-657, 1996

29 "Erschpfung des Senderechts?" ZUM 1986 638-656

30 "Erschpfung Online? - Die aktuelle Problematik beim On-Demand-Vertrieb von Tontrgern im Lichte der Richtlinie zur Informationsgesellschaft" GRUR Int 2002

31 "EG-Richtlinie zum Urheberrecht in der Informations- gesellschaft" GRUR Int 733-745, 2001

32 "Don’t Judge a Sale by Its License: Software Transfers Under the First Sale Doctrine in the United States and the European Community" 36 : 2001

33 "Die Rechte der Tontrgerhersteller in internationaler und rechtsvergleichender Sicht" 1999

34 "Die Lehre von der Erschpfung des Verbreitungsrechts im Urheberrecht" 1964

35 "Die Erschpfungsproblematik aus der Sicht des Gemein- schaftsrechts" GRUR Int 571-584, 2000

36 "Der urheberrechtliche Schutz von Computerpro- grammen im Recht der Bundesrepublik Deutschland und der Republik Korea" 1999

37 "Der Erschpfungsgrundsatz im Urheberrecht und gewerb- lichen Rechtsschutz unter Bercksichtigung der Recht- sprechung des Europischen Gerichtshofes" 221-234, 1972

38 "Der Erschpfungsgrundsatz des Urheberrechts im Online- Bereich" 2000

39 "Datenbankvertrge" 1995

40 "DMCA Section 104 Report: A Report of the Register of Copyrights Pursuant to § 104 of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act" U.S. Copyright Office 2001