포스트 소비에트 시기 러시아 정치적 전통의 재구성: 권위주의로서의 푸틴 체제 공고화 요인을 중심으로 = Reconstruction of Russia`s Political Tradition: The Consolidation of Putin`s System

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This paper discusses Russia`s return to authoritarianism. It criticizes the argument that the traditional political culture is responsible for the return of authoritarianism in post-communist Russia. By analyzing the environments and process of Putin`s turn to authoritarianism, it argues that the consolidation of the authoritarian system is the result of Putin`s deliberate institutional engineering and that defects of the 1993 Constitution have allowed the room for Putin to maneuver. The paper emphasizes that Putin has successfully exploited domestic and international environments in reshaping the Russian federalism and party system. Geopolitical factors such as color revolutions and competition with the US in Central Asia, it argues, have aided Putin to legitimize his authoritarian measures. And it also notes the resource curse in the consolidation of Russian authoritarianism. In short, the author stresses the need to avoid abusing the concept path-dependence and to observe how political strategy and institutional engineering reconstruct the authoritarian tradition in post-communist Russia.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 장훈, "정치학의 대상과 방법" 박영사 347-369, 2005

2 임경훈, "바우처 사유화의 논리 : 러시아와 체코의 경우 비교" 6 (6): 81-107, 1997

3 "www.freedomhouse.org"

4 Przeworski, Adam, "Why Do Political Parties Obey Results of Elections?, In Democracy and the Rule of Law" Cambridge University Press 114-144, 2003

5 Clark, Victoria, "Why Angels Fall: A Journey Through Orthodox Europe from Byzantium to Kosovo" Palgrave Macmillan 2000

6 Bahry, Donna, "Tolerance, Transition and Support for Civil Liberties in Russia" 30 (30): 484-510, 1997

7 Gibson, James L., "The Struggle between Order and Liberty in Contemporary Russian Political Culture" 32 (32): 271-290, 1997

8 Nichols, Thomas M., "The Russian Presidency: Society and Politics in the Second Russian Republic" Macmillan 2001

9 Remington, Thomas, "The Russian Parliament : Institutional Evolution in a Transitional Regime, 1989–1999, New Haven, In The Russian Parliament: Institutional Evolution in a Transitional Regime, 1989–1999" Yale University Press 2001

10 Gibson, James L., "The Russian Dance with Democracy" 17 (17): 101-128, 2001

11 Treisman, Daniel, "The Return" Free Press 2011

12 Roeder, Philip G., "The Rejection of Authoritarianism, In Postcommunism and the Theory of Democracy" Princeton University Press 11-53, 2001

13 Petrov, Nikolai, "The Regions under Putin and After, In After Putin’s Russia: Past Imperfect, Future Uncertain" Rowman & Littlefield 59-82, 2010

14 Petro, Nicolai, "The Rebirth of Russian Democracy: An Interpretation of Political Culture" Harvard University Press 1995

15 Gvosdev, Nikolas K., "The New Party Card? Orthodoxy and the Search for Post-Soviet Russian Identity" 47 (47): 29-38, 2000

16 Solzhenitsyn, Aleksandr I., "The Mortal Danger, In The Soviet Polity in the Modern Era" Aldine 5-40, 1984

17 Scherbak, Andrey, "The Impact of the Oil Shock on the Post-Soviet Regime Changes, In Resource Curse and Post-Soviet Eurasia: Oil, Gas and Modernization" Lexington Books 23-48, 2010

18 Myagkov, Michael, "The Forensics of Election Fraud: Russia and Ukraine" Cambridge University Press 2009

19 Brovkin, Vladimir, "The Emperor’s New Clothes: Continuity of Soviet Political Culture in Contemporary Russia" 43 (43): 21-28, 1996

20 Sakwa, Richard, "The Crisis of Russian Democracy : The Dual State, Factionalism, and the Medvedev Succession" Cambridge University Press 2011

21 Huntington, Samuel P., "The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of the Modern World" Simon and Schuster 1996

22 McDaniel, Michael, "The Agony of the Russian Idea" Princeton University Press 1998

23 Tucker, Robert C., "Sovietology and Russian History" 8 (8): 175-196, 1992

24 Brzezinski, Zbigniew, "Soviet Politics: From the Future to the Past, In The Dynamics of Soviet Politics" Harvard University Press 337-351, 1976

25 Dunlop, John B., "Sifting through the Rubble of the Yeltsin Years" 47 (47): 3-15, 2000

26 McFaul, Michael, "Russia’s Unfinished Revolution: Political Change from Gorbachev to Putin" Cornell University Press 2001

27 Fish, M. Steven, "Russia’s Crisis and the Crisis of Russology, In Reexamining the Soviet Experience: Essays in Honor of Alexander Dallin" Westview 139-165, 1996

28 Bashkirova, Elena, "Russian Public Opinion Between Elections" 47 (47): 553-565, 1995

29 Mendras, Marie, "Russian Politics: The Paradox of a Weak State" Columbia University Press 2012

30 Duncan, Peter J. S., "Russian Messianism: Third Rome, Holy Revolution, Communism and After" Routledge 2000

31 Goldman, Marshall I., "Russian Energy: A Blessing and a Curse" 53 (53): 73-84, 1999

32 Pipes, Richard, "Russian Conservatism and Its Critics" Yale University Press 2005

33 Pipes, Richard, "Russia under the Old Regime" Weidenfeld & Nicolson 1974

34 Mikheyev, Dmitry, "Russia Transformed" Hudson Institute 1996

35 Bunce, Valerie, "Rethinking Recent Democratization: Lessons from the Postcommunist Experience" 55 (55): 167-192, 2003

36 Stevens, Paul, "Resource Impact: Curse or Blessing? A Literature Survey" 9 (9): 3-42, 2003

37 Travin, Dmitry, "Resource Curse: Rethinking the Soviet Experience, In Resource Curse and Post-Soviet Eurasia: Oil, Gas, and Modernization" Lexington Books 23-48, 2010

38 Rose, Richard, "Resigned Acceptance of an Incomplete Democracy: Russia’s Political Equilibrium" 20 (20): 195-218, 2004

39 Linz, Juan J., "Problems of Democratic Transition and Consolidation: Southern Europe, South America and Post-Communist Europe" Johns Hopkins University Press 1996

40 Fleron, Fredrik J., "Post-Soviet Political Culture in Russia: An Assessment of Recent Empirical Investigation" 48 (48): 225-260, 1996

41 Karaman, Tatyana, "Political Efficacy and Its Antecedents in Contemporary Russia" 20 (20): 30-49, 2004

42 Bova, Russell, "Political Dynamics of the Post-Communist Transition: A Comparative Perspective" 44 (44): 113-138, 1991

43 Alexander, James, "Political Culture in Post-Communist Russia: Formlessness and Recreation in a Traumatic Transition" St. Martin’s Press 2000

44 Tucker, Robert C., "Political Culture and Leadership in Soviet Russia: From Lenin to Gorbachev" Wheatsheaf 1987

45 Remington, Thomas, "Parliament and the Dominant Party Regime, In After Putin’s Russia: Past Imperfect, Future Uncertain" Rowman & Littlefield 39-58, 2010

46 Zaostrovtsev, Andrey, "Oil Boom and Government Finance in Russia: Stabilization Fund and Its Fate, In Resource Curse and Post-Soviet Eurasia: Oil, Gas and Modernization" Lexington Books 123-148, 2010

47 Lukin, Aleksander, "Myths about Russian Political Culture and the Study of Russian History" 15-41, 2005

48 Keenan, Edward L., "Muscovite Political Folkways" 45 (45): 115-181, 1986

49 Schedler, Andreas, "Measuring Democratic Consolidation" 36 (36): 66-92, 2001

50 Putnam, Robert, "Making Democracy Work : Civic Traditions in Modern Italy" Princeton University Press 1993

51 McFaul, Michael, "Lessons from Russia’s Protracted Transition from Communist Rule" 114 (114): 103-130, 1999

52 Orttung, Robert, "Key Issues in the Evolution of the Federal Okrugs and Center-Region Relations under Putin, In The Dynamics of Russian Politics: Putin’s Reform of Federal- Regional Relations, vol. 1" Lanham: Rowman & Littlefeld 19-52, 2004

53 Gel’man, Vladimir, "Introduction: Resource Curse and Post-Soviet Eurasia, In Resource Curse and Post-Soviet Eurasia: Oil, Gas and Modernization" Lexington Books 1-22, 2010

54 North, Douglas, "Institutions, Institutional Change, and Economic Performance" Cambridge University Press 1990

55 Gel’man, Vladimir, "Institution Building and ‘Institutional Traps’ in Russian Politics, In Russia in 2020" Carnegie Endowment for International Peace 215-232, 2011

56 Pipes, Richard, "Flight from Freedom: What Russians Think and Want" 83 (83): 9-15, 2004

57 Gvosdev, Nikolas K., "Emperors and Elections: Reconciling the Orthodox Tradition with Modern Politics" Nova 2000

58 Rose, Richard, "Democratization Backwards: The Problem of Third-Wave Democracies" 31 (31): 331-354, 2001

59 Fish, M. Steven, "Democracy Derailed in Russia: The Failure of Open Politics" Cambridge University Press 2005

60 Brown, A., "Conclusion: the Past, Present and Future of Post-Communist Political Culture Studies, In Political Culture and Post-Communism" Palgrave Macmillan 180-202, 2005

61 Levitsky, Steven, "Competitive Authoritarianism: Hybrid Regimes after the Cold War" Cambridge University Press 2010

62 Ledeneva, Alena V., "Can Russia Modernise? Sistema, Power Networks and Informal Governance" Cambridge University Press 2013

63 Treisman, Daniel, "Blaming Russia First" 79 (79): 146-155, 200

64 Colton, Timothy J., "Are Russians Undemocratic?" 18 (18): 91-121, 2002

65 Shleifer, Andrei, "A Normal Country" 83 (83): 20-38, 2004