A Study on the Improvement of Density and Diversity Indicators Reflecting Network Distance in Interpretation of Urban Spatial Structure

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This study deals with the ambiguity of the design index among the 3Ds indices (Density, Design, and Diversity) of transit-oriented development (TOD). Unlike density and diversity, design is difficult to quantify arithmetically.
We have thus developed a methodology in our study to replace existing 3Ds indices with “2Ds with D (Density with Design, Diversity with Design).” “2Ds with D” is a method that considers the accessibility of walkways at each point in calculating the density and diversity indices. We applied this analytical methodology to 287 station areas of the Seoul Metropolitan Railway. Furthermore, we compared and analyzed which index is better in reflecting the station user among “3Ds” and “2Ds with D” indices. The analysis found that in CBD, the analysis method presented in this study showed higher explanatory power than the existing method, but the difference was not large, and the explanatory power was rather low in other regions. This paper is the first to present the concept of 2Ds with D index to academia and confirm its applicability. It will have a great influence on the study of TOD in the future.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 우찬일, "퍼지 추론부의 성능 향상에관한 연구" 105-116, 1997

2 성현곤, "철도역 접근성이 건축물 개발밀도에 미치는 영향" 대한국토·도시계획학회 49 (49): 63-78, 2014

3 이금숙, "지하철 접근성 증가의 공간적 파급효과 산출모형 개발" 1 (1): 137-149, 1998

4 박현영, "중심지체계 및 지하철역 접근성에 따른 건축활동 특성에 관한 연구: 서울시 2001~2008년 건축허가건을대상으로" 서울대학교 환경대학원 2015

5 유경상, "역세권 토지이용 특성을 기반으로 한 도시철도 통행발생 모형" 서울연구원 14 (14): 145-157, 2013

6 안영수, "도시철도 역세권에서 보행네트워크 기반 접근거리와 건물개발밀도의 연관성에 대한 실증 연구" 대한국토·도시계획학회 51 (51): 179-192, 2016

7 김태호, "거리기반 TOD계획요소와 서울시 역세권 대중교통 이용수요와의 연관성에 관한 연구" 대한국토·도시계획학회 48 (48): 51-63, 2013

8 Lee Seungil, "Urban structural hierarchy and the relationship between the ridership of the Seoul Metropolitan Subway and the land-use pattern of the station areas" 35 : 69-77, 2013

9 Hamin, E. M, "Urban form and climate change: Balancing adaptation and mitigation in the US and Australia" 33 (33): 238-245, 2009

10 Cervero, R, "Travel demand and the 3Ds: Density, diversity, and design" 2 (2): 199-219, 1997

11 Ewing, R, "Travel and the built environment: A synthesis" 1780 (1780): 87-114, 2001

12 Cervero, R., "Transitoriented development and joint development in the United States: A literature review" Transportation Research Board 2002

13 Sung Hyungun, "Transit-oriented development in a high-density city: Identifying its association with transit ridership in Seoul, Korea" 28 (28): 70-82, 2011

14 Gutiérrez, J., "Transit ridership forecasting at station level: An approach based on distance-decay weighted regression" 19 (19): 1081-1092, 2011

15 Zhang, M, "The role of land use in travel mode choice:Evidence from Boston and Hong Kong" 70 (70): 344-360, 2004

16 Renne, J. L., "The cost and affordability paradox of transit-oriented development: A comparison of housing and transportation costs across transit-oriented development, hybrid and transit-adjacent development station typologies" 26 (26): 819-834, 2016

17 Calthorpe, P., "The Next American Metropolis: Ecology, community, and the American dream" Princeton Architectural Press 1993

18 Lin, J. J., "TOD planning model to review the regulation of allowable development densities around subway stations" 23 (23): 353-360, 2006

19 Taki, H. M., "Re-assessing TOD index in Jakarta metropolitan region (JMR)" 1 (1): 26-35, 2017

20 Cervero, R, "Rail and property development in Hong Kong: Experiences and extensions" 46 (46): 2019-2043, 2009

21 Sung Hyungun, "Operationalizing Jane Jacobs’s urban design theory:Empirical verification from the great city of Seoul, Korea" 35 (35): 117-130, 2015

22 Cervero, R, "Mixed land-uses and commuting:Evidence from the American housing survey" 30 (30): 361-377, 1996

23 Singh, Y. J., "Measuring TOD around transit nodes: Towards TOD policy" 56 : 96-111, 2017

24 Li, C. N., "Low carbon management concepts in TOD planning" 2012

25 Guerra, E., "Is a Half-Mile Circle the Right Standard for TODs?" University of California Transportation Center

26 Guerra, E., "Half-mile circle: Does it best represent transit station catchments?" 2276 (2276): 101-109, 2012

27 Ewing, R., "Growing Cooler: The evidence on urban development and climate change" Urban Land Institute 2007

28 오규식, "GIS-퍼지 접근방법의 유용성" 34 (34): 71-83, 1999

29 Andersen, J. L. E, "GIS-based approaches to catchment area analyses of mass transit" 2009

30 안영수, "GIS 네트워크분석을 활용한 도시철도역 주변지역 상업시설 입지분포패턴 추정 연구- 서울시 도시철도 2호선 신림역을 사례로 -" 대한국토·도시계획학회 47 (47): 199-213, 2012

31 Wang, F., "Fuzzy information representation and processing in conventional GIS software: Database design and application" 4 (4): 261-283, 1990

32 Sung Hyungun, "Exploring the impacts of land use by service coverage and station-level accessibility on rail transit ridership" 36 : 134-140, 2014

33 Lin, J. J, "Does transit-oriented development affect metro ridership? Evidence from Taipei, Taiwan" 2063 (2063): 149-158, 2008

34 Chatman, D. G, "Does TOD need the T? On the importance of factors other than rail access" 79 (79): 17-31, 2013

35 Dirgahayani, P, "Development of Methodology to Evaluate TOD Feasibility in Built-up Environment (Case Study: Jakarta and Bandung, Indonesia)" 158 (158): 2018

36 Lyu, G., "Developing a TOD typology for Beijing metro station areas" 55 : 40-50, 2016

37 Cerin, E., "Destinations that matter: Associations with walking for transport" 13 (13): 713-724, 2007

38 Olaru, D, "Designing TOD precincts:Accessibility and travel patterns" 15 (15): 6-26, 2015

39 Schlossberg, M, "Comparing transit-oriented development sites by walkability indicators" 1887 (1887): 34-42, 2004

40 Tobler, W. R, "A computer movie simulating urban growth in the detroit region" 46 : 234-240, 1970