체질, 생물, 진화: 인류학 분과 명칭의 변화 = Physical, Biological, Evolutionary: Changes in the Terminology of Anthropological Subfields

국문 초록 (Abstract)

본 연구는 체질인류학에서 생물인류학, 그리고 진화인류학으로 이어지는 인류학 분과 명칭 변화의 역사와 현대적 전환을 고찰하였다. 19세기 프랑스의 폴 브로카와 독일의 루돌프 피르호는 인간 형태학과 인종 분류를 중심으로 체질인류학을 정립하였지만, 식민주의와 우생학의 영향 속에서 그 한계가 분명해졌다. 이러한 배경 속에서, 본 연구는 문헌 조사와 역사적 문서 분석을 통하여 각 시기별 인류학의 학문적 변화와 명칭 변화를 추적하였다. 이후 20세기 중반, 유전학·생태학·인간 적응 연구의 부상과 함께 생물인류학은 고정된 인종 개념을 벗어나 진화 이론과 학제적 접근을 통합하였으며, 셔우드 워시번의 “신 체질인류학”은 이 전환점을 상징하였다고 할 수 있다. 그리고 진화인류학은 생물학·행동·문화적 차원을 아우르며 현대 인류학의 핵심 분야로 자리 잡았다. 본 연구는 프랑스, 독일, 영국, 미국, 한국 등 다양한 지역에서 벌어진 학문적 발전 과정을 살펴보았고, 각국의 사회적·역사적 맥락과 대표 연구자들의 활동이 인류학 분과 명칭 전환에 어떤 영향을 주었는지 분석하였다. 이 명칭 변화는 단순한 어휘 조정이 아니라, 인간 다양성과 진화를 해석하는 학문적 틀의 성숙과 확장을 상징한다고 할 수 있다. 이러한 논의를 통해서 향후 인류학 내 학문적 융합과 협력을 촉진하는 바탕을 마련하고자 한다.

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This study examined the historical transition from physical anthropology to biological anthropology, and then to evolutionary anthropology, exploring the changes in the sub-disciplinary names within anthropology and their modern implications. In the 19th century, Paul Broca in France and Rudolf Virchow in Germany established physical anthropology centered around human morphology and racial classification. However, the limits of this approach became clear under the influences of colonialism and eugenics. Against this backdrop, this research tracked the academic changes and nomenclature shifts in anthropology through literature reviews and historical document analysis. By mid-20th century, as genetics, ecology, and studies on human adaptation rose to prominence, biological anthropology moved beyond the fixed concepts of race, integrating evolutionary theory and an interdisciplinary approach. Sherwood Washburn's "New Physical Anthropology" symbolized this turning point. Furthermore, evolutionary anthropology has become a core area of modern anthropology, encompassing biological, behavioral, and cultural dimensions. This study examined the academic development processes in various regions including France, Germany, the UK, the USA, and Korea, and analyzed how the social and historical contexts and the activities of representative researchers influenced the changes in sub-disciplinary names within anthropology. These name changes represent not merely lexical adjustments but the maturation and expansion of the academic framework for interpreting human diversity and evolution. Through these discussions, the study aimed to lay the groundwork for promoting academic integration and cooperation within anthropology.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Massin B, "Volksgeist as method and ethic: essays on Boasian ethnography and the German anthropological tradition" University of Wisconsin Press 1996

2 Silver GA, "Virchow, the heroic model in medicine : health policy by accolade" 77 : 82-88, 1987

3 Stocking GW, "Victorian anthropology" Free Press 1987

4 Halpern DF, "The science of sex differences in science and mathematics" 8 : 1-51, 2007

5 Knox R, "The races of men: a fragment" H. Renshaw 1850

6 Silberstein LJ, "The other in Jewish thought and history: constructions of Jewish culture and identity" NYU Press 1994

7 Washburn SL, "The new physical anthropology" 13 : 298-304, 1951

8 Hunt J, "The negro’s place in nature : a paper read before the London Anthropological Society" Van Evrie, Horton & Co 1864

9 신규환, "The intellectual genealogy of physical anthropological anatomy knowledge in colonial Korea : focusing on the biometric study in statistical method" 23 : 41-62, 2020

10 Hooton E, "The importance of primate studies in anthropology" 26 : 179-188, 1954

11 Zihlman AL, "The human evolution coloring book" Collins Reference 2001

12 Ashok SS, "The history of race in anthropology : Paul Broca and the question of human hybridity" 4 : 26-2017, 2017

13 Shapiro HL, "The history and development of physical anthropology" 61 : 371-379, 1959

14 Ellison PT, "The evolution of physical anthropology" 165 : 615-625, 2018

15 Kelly A, "The descent of Darwin: the popularization of Darwinism in Germany, 1860-1914" University of North Carolina Press; 2012

16 Kuper A, "The chosen primate : human nature and cultural diversity" Harvard University Press 1994

17 Jowett B, "The Politics of Aristotle" Clarendon Press 1887

18 Trinkaus E, "The Neandertals: Of skeletons, scientists, and scandal" Vintage 1994

19 Kuper A, "The Cambridge History of Modern European Thought" Cambridge University Press 398-421, 2019

20 Mayr E, "Systematics and the origin of species, from the viewpoint of a zoologist" Harvard University Press 1942

21 Helm J, "Social contexts of American ethnology, 1840-1984" 26 : 13-, 1985

22 Ackerknecht EH, "Rudolf Virchow: doctor, statesman, anthropologist" University of Wisconsin Press 1953

23 Boak AER, "Rudolf Virchow-anthropologist and archeologist" 13 : 40-45, 1921

24 Broca P, "Revue d’anthropologie" C. Reinwald 1872

25 Oyserman D, "Rethinking individualism and collectivism : evaluation of theoretical assumptions and meta-analyses" 128 : 3-, 2002

26 "Results of the non-binding name change survey" American Association of Physical Anthropologists

27 Schier W, "Restitution von menschlichen Überresten aus den Sammlungen der Gesellschaft für Anthropologie, Ethnologie und Urgeschichte(BGAEU)an zwei Fallbeispielen : Vorbereitung, Durchführung und Medienecho" 41 : 71-81, 2020

28 Prichard JC, "Researches into the physical history of mankind" Sherwood, Gilbert & Piper 1841

29 Garn SM, "Races: a study of the problems of race formation in man" Library of Congress Photoduplication Service 1950

30 Weiss SF, "Race hygiene and national efficiency : the eugenics of Wilhelm Schallmayer" University of California Press 1987

31 Davenport CB, "Race crossing in Jamaica" 27 : 225-238, 1928

32 "Presidents" Royal Anthropological Institute

33 Lubbock J, "Pre-historic times: as illustrated by ancient remains and the manners and customs of modern savages" JA Hill 1865

34 Van Wyhe J, "Phrenology and the origins of Victorian scienti-fic naturalism" Routledge 2017

35 Harvey R, "Philadelphus; Or, A Defence of Brutes and the Brutans History" John Wolfe 1593

36 Huxley TH, "On the relations of man to the lower animals" Williams and Norgate 1863

37 Huxley TH, "On the geographical distribution of the chief modifications of mankind" 2 : 404-412, 1870

38 Carlyle T, "Occasional discourse on the negro question"

39 Aristotle, "Nicomachean Ethics" Cambridge University Press; 2014

40 Kuklick H, "New history of anthropology" John Wiley & Sons 2009

41 Aristotle, "Metaphysics" Harvard University Press 1933

42 Koerner L, "Linnaeus : Nature and nation" Harvard University Press 2001

43 Park H, "Lecture of Evolutionary Anthropology" Haenaim 2024

44 Wartelle J-C, "La Société d’Anthropologie de Paris de 1859 à 1920" 10 : 125-171, 2004

45 Nakao K, "Japanese anthropology in Japan and East Asia" 2002

46 MacFarlane KN, "Isidore of Seville on the Pagan Gods(Origines VIII. 11)" 70 : 1-40, 1980

47 Darnell R, "Invisible genealogies : a history of Americanist anthropology" University of Nebraska Press 2001

48 Bartholin C, "Institutions Anatomiques de Gaspar Bartholin, augmentées et enrichies pour la seconde fois tant des opinions et observations nouvelles des modernes... que de plusieurs figures" M. Hénault et J. Hénault 1647

49 Kevles DJ, "In the name of eugenics : genetics and the uses of human heredity" Harvard University Press 1985

50 Aristotle, "History of animals" Harvard Univ-ersity Press 1991

51 Barnard A, "History and theory in anthropology" Cambridge University Press 2021

52 Weindling P, "Health, race and German politics between national unification and Nazism, 1870-1945" Cambridge University Press 1993

53 Boyd WC, "Genetics and the races of man" Blackwell Oxford 1950

54 Dobzhansky T, "Genetics and the origin of species" Columbia University Press 1982

55 Pusman K, "Die ‘Wissenschaften vom Menschen’ auf Wiener Boden (1870-1959): die anthropologische Gesellschaft in Wien und die anthropologischen Disziplinen im Fokus von Wissenschaftsgeschichte, Wissenschafts- und Verdrängungspolitik" LIT Verlag Münster 2008

56 Mosse GL, "Die Geschichte des Rassismus in Europa" Europäische Verlagsanstalt 1990

57 Desmond A, "Darwin’s sacred cause: how a hatred of slavery shaped Darwin’s views on human evolution" Houghton Mifflin Harcourt; 2014

58 Hofstede G, "Culture’s consequences: Comparing values, behaviors, institutions and organizations across nations" Sage Publications 2001

59 Gelfand MJ, "Culture, leadership, and organizations: The GLOBE study of 62 societies" Sage Publications 437-512, 2004

60 Riddle O, "Biographical memoir of Charles Benedict Davenport, 1866-1944" National Academy of Sciences 1947

61 Kubo T, "Beiträge zur physischen Anthropologie der Koreaner" Tokyo Imperial University 1913

62 Aristotle, "Aristotle’s on the Soul" Peripatetic Pr 1981

63 Hooton EA, "Apes, men, and morons" G.P. Putnam’s Sons 1937

64 Zimmerman A, "Anti-Semitism as skill : Rudolf Virchow’s Schulstatistik and the racial composition of Germany" 32 : 409-429, 1999

65 "Anthropology and the British Association" 3 : 354-371, 1865

66 박순영, "Academic tasks left by physical anthropology under Japanese colonialism and lessons from experiences of Western physical anthropology" 10 : 191-220, 2004

67 L’Anthropologie, "About the journal"

68 Deutsche Gesellschaft für Anthropologie, "About Deutsche Gesellschaft für Anthropologie"

69 "AAA history" American Anthropological Association

70 Brace CL, ""Race"is a four-letter word : the genesis of the concept" Oxford University Press 2005