과학기술계 출연연구기관 기관평가지표의 BSC 관점 분석 = Balanced Scorecard Perspective Analysis of Institutional Performance Evaluation for Government S&T Research Institutes

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This research examines the relationship between the characteristics of Government S&T Research Institutes (GRI) and their institutional performance evaluation system. First, based on Kaplan & Norton (1992) Balanced Scorecard Model, six perspectives suitable to Korean GRI are derived. Second, personnel who works on evaluation job classified current performance measures into the six perspectives. Analyzing comparative weights of individual perspectives, the characteristics of performance evaluation systems among institutes are derived and compared with their missions. The results are as follows: First, GRI evaluation systems put most weight on the customer perspective and least weight on the financial perspective. This result complies with Korean GRI's missions and strategies as well as findings of foreign cases. Second, Basic-technology GRI group relatively more priotizes long-term customer perspective, while Applied-technology GRI Group relatively more priotizes short-term customer perspective. Public-technology GRI Group is located in the middle in terms of priority of customer perspectives. Third, for three years (2000-2002), performance measure weights of Basic-technology Group are changed much less than those of the other two groups. Further research are needed for reasons of drastic changes for Applied-technology and Public-technology groups and some abnormally high and low measure weights.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 "철강업의 경영성과와 성과동인간 구조적 관계에 관한 연구" 10 : 2001

2 "정부투자기관 경영평가제도의 유효성 연구" 1991

3 "정부출연연구기관 기관성과평가지표체계 분석" 과학기술정책연구원. 2001

4 "정부출연기관 현황" 기획예산처 2003

5 "정부조직의 성과관리: 균형성과표와 성과주의 예산제도의 연계" 13 (13): 2002

6 "전사적 전략경영을 위한 SFO" 한ㆍ언출판사. 2001

7 "연구회 및 출연연구기관의 새로운 경영모형" 인문사회연구회. 2000

8 "산업기술백서" 한국산업기술진흥협회 2003

9 "기업전략에 따른 균형성과표 성과지표 비교분석" 13 (13): 2003

10 "기업생존력 분석ㆍ평가 매뉴얼" 21세기북스. 1997

11 "기관평가제도 운영의 영향요인에 관한 연구" 2004

12 "균형잡힌 성과기록표를 활용한 공기업의 경영평가" 26 : 2000

13 "균형잡힌 성과기록표(BSC)의 개념적 고찰" 27 : 2000

14 "관광호텔의 경영성과평가를 위한 BSC평가지표간의 인과관계" 2001

15 "과학기술예측조사의 방법론과 활용방안" 과학기술정책관리연구소. 1996

16 "과학기술연구활동조사보고서" 과학기술부ㆍ한국과학기술기획평가원 2003

17 "과학기술계 정부출연연구기관의 균형적 성과관리시스템 구축" 9 (9): 2003

18 "공ㆍ사부문 연구개발 관리전략의 비교분석" 2000

19 "가치실현을 위한 통합경영지표 BSC" 한언출판사. 1998

20 "Why Balanced Scorecards Fail" 1999

21 "Using the Balanced Scorecard as a Strategic Management System" 1996

22 "Use of Delphi methods in Higher education" 173-186, 1972

23 "Translation Performance Metrics from the Private to the Public Sector" 1999

24 "Translating Strategy into Action-The Balanced Scorecard" 179-, 1996

25 "Transforming the Balanced Scorecard from Performance Measurement to Strategic Management" 15 : 2001

26 "The Use of Performance Measures National Association of Accountants." 1986

27 "The Strategy-Focused Organization: How Balanced Scorecard Company Thrive In The New Business Environment" Harvard Business School Press 2001

28 "The Performance Measurement Manifesto" 131-137, 1991

29 "The Balanced Scorecard-Measures That Drive Performance" 1992

30 "The Balanced Scorecard, Competitive Strategy, and Performance" 45 (45): 15-, 2002

31 "The Balanced Scorecard for Public-Sector Organization" 1999

32 "Research and Development Performance Measurement: A Case Study" 9. : 1998

33 "R&D평가시스템의 이론적 체계구축 및 적용방안에 관한 연구" 과학기술정책연구원. 2000

34 "R&D Performance Measurement: More than Choosing a Set of Metrics" 29 (29): 1999

35 "Putting the Balanced Scorecard to Work" 1993

36 "Performance Measurement" 49 (49): 64-, 2000

37 "Performance Drivers" John Wiley & Sons Ltd. 299-300, 1998

38 "Note on Improving Korea?s Public Enterprises Evaluation Effort" 87-180, 1985

39 "Measuring the Performance of American Science and Technology Laboratories" 2000

40 "Measuring R&D Productivity" july-august : 11-15, 1988

41 "Making R&D More Effective at Westinghouse" 39 (39): 1996

42 "Linking the Balanced Scorecard to Strategy" 39 (39): 1996

43 "Linking the Balanced Scorecard to Strategy" 30. : 1997

44 "Linking Balanced Scorecard Measures to Size and Market Factors: Impact on Organizational Performance" 12. : 2000

45 "Information Technology Evaluation Methods & Management" Idea Group Publishing. 2001

46 "Designing Metrics for Government Agency Performance" 1999

47 "Chemical Bank: Implementing the Balanced Scorecard" 1999

48 "Building a Strategy-Focused Organization" 2001

49 "Balanced Scorecards for New Product Development" 1997

50 "Balanced Scorecard: Step-by-step for government and nonprofit agencies" John Wiley & Sons, Inc. 2003

51 "Balanced Scorecard: Maximizing Performance and Maintaining Results" John Wiley & Sons, Inc. 2002

52 "BSC의 구축과 실행을 위한 전략체계도 Strategy Maps" 21세기북스. 2004

53 "BSC실천매뉴얼" 시그마인사이트. 2001

54 "BSC를 활용한 출연연구기관 기관평가제도의 유효성 연구" 2004

55 "BSC를 응용한 성과측정지표 가중치 산정과 활용" 2000

56 "BSC 성과지표간 인과관계 분석" 2002

57 "BSC 모형의 비재무적 성과측정치와 재무적 성과측정치의 관계에 관한 실증적 연구" 2001

58 "BSC 도입기업에 대한 사례연구" 7 : 2000

59 "BSC Online Members Survey" OECD 2003

60 "Approaches to the Evaluation of Organizational Effectiveness" 2. : 1977

61 "An evaluation of Delphi" 131-150, 1991

62 "An Empirical Study of Accounting Data in Performance Evaluation Journal of Accounting Research." 1972

63 "Achieving Performance Excellence with the Balanced Scorecard" 2002

64 "Academy of Management Review" 5 : 211-217, 1980

65 "A Comparative Analysis of the Balanced Scorecard as Applied in Government and Industry Organizations" 2001

66 "2004년도 3개 연구회 업무현황 편람" 국회 정무위원회 2004

67 "2002년도 소관연구기관 평가편람" 산업기술연구회 2003

68 "2002년도 기관평가편람" 기초기술연구회 2003

69 "2002년도 기관평가 편람" 공공기술연구회 2003

70 "2001년도 소관연구기관 평가편람" 산업기술연구회 2002

71 "2001년도 기관평가편람" 기초기술연구회 2002

72 "2001년도 기관평가 편람" 공공기술연구회 2002

73 "2000년도 소관연구기관 평가편람" 산업기술연구회 2001

74 "2000년도 기관평가편람" 기초기술연구회 2001

75 "2000년도 기관평가 편람" 공공기술연구회 2001

76 "1999년도 소관출연연구기관 기관평가종합보고서" 산업기술연구회 2000

77 "04년도 정부연구개발예산 현황" 한국과학기술기획평가원 2004