범죄 피해자와 범죄 판단자의 성별이 양형판단에 미치는 영향 = The gender effect of victim and judge on the assessment of a case

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The study aims to examine the gender effect of victim and judge on the assessment of a case. For this aim, the data was collected from 183 students regarding their assessment of cases including murder, assault, rape, and arson as well as their values related to those cases. The result shows the strong gender effects of judge on the assessment of a case. Women sentenced longer sentence than men on the given cases. And also, Women showed more sterner values regarding the cases than men. Especially, in the rape case, women sentenced longer sentence when they sentenced the woman victim case than the man case. On the other hand, men sentenced longer sentence when they sentenced the man victim case than the woman case. Finally, Implications and limits of the study are discussed.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 박광배, "형사재판에서의 유무죄판결 및 선고의 일관성." 7 : 73-89, 1993

2 고재홍, "처벌크기 판단에 관여하는 정보들의 통합방식" 9 : 29-50, 1995

3 고재홍, "책임판단 연구의 개관" 10 : 1-20, 1996

4 고재홍, "잘못, 책임 및 처벌 : 처벌판단에 관한 한 가상적 모형" 6 : 1-21, 1991

5 김관현, "양형의 실태와 합리화 방안" 연세대학교 관리과학대학원 2000

6 김지현, "법전문가와 비전문가의 선고목적 선호와 형량결정 과정에 미치는 선고맥락 효과" 서울대학교 대학원 1992

7 손동현, "범행비례적 양형론에 관한 연구" 한국형사정책연구원 2006

8 고재홍, "범죄유형에 따른 처벌기준의 사용차이" 경남대 사회과학연구소 6 : 77-88, 1994

9 조은경, "범죄에 대한 두려움에 있어서 남성과 여성의 차이" 한국문화및사회문제심리학회 9 (9): 1-21, 2003

10 고재홍, "가해자 외모와 형량판단간의 매개과정" 8 : 68-84, 1994

11 손지선, "가족살해 가해자의 특성과 양형요인에 대한 연구" 한국사회및성격심리학회 21 (21): 1-17, 2007

12 Bowker, L. H., "Women, crime, and the criminal justice system" Health 1978

13 Killias, M., "Vulnerability : Towards a better understanding of a key variable in the genesis of fear of crime" 5 : 97-108, 1990

14 Miller, J., "The strengths and limits of 'doing gender' for understanding street crime" 6 : 433-460, 2002

15 Maxfield, M, "The limits of vulnerability in explaining fear of crime : A comparative neighborhood analysis" 21 : 233-250, 1984

16 Rye, B. J., "The case of the guilty victim : The effects of gender of victim and gender perpetrator on attributions of blame and responsibility" 54 : 639-649, 2006

17 Thomas, C. W., "Public opinion on criminal law and legal sanction : Am examination of two conceptual models" 67 : 110-116, 1976

18 Garofalo, J., "Public opinion about crime: The attitudes of victims and non-victims in selected cities"

19 Dion, K., "Physical attractiveness and evaluation of children's transgression" 24 : 207-213, 1972

20 Drout, C. E., "Gender differences in reactions to female victims" 22 : 267-278, 1994

21 Moulds, E. F., "Chivalry and Paternalism : Disparities of treatment in the criminal justice system" 31 : 416-440, 1978