인터넷 정치 토론의 담론적 특성

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This study explores the ways in which Korean internet discussants constructed political arguments by examining the postings of 'the discussion plaza' in one of the major portal sites during the national crisis of the Presidential impeachment in 2004. In particular, the argument structure of informal logic was investigated on the basis of Toulmin(1958)'s model of argumentation. We found that most of the online discussants formulated their arguments within the incomplete structure of an informal logic. It was also found that discussants also employed 'narratives' as evidence. Trait descriptions of major political actors, popular sayings, and personal experiences were extensively used as evidence for their claims. Finally, we found that most discussants deployed their own emotional reactions about the presidential impeachment as grounds for their claims. Findings were discussed in terms of the relationship between the Internet political discussion and deliberative democracy.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 김은미, "읽기의 재발견 : 인터넷 토론 공간에서 커뮤니케이션의 효과" 한국언론학회 50 (50): 65-94, 2006

2 김은미, "인터넷상에서 사회적 의사소통 양식과 합의 형성" 정보통신정책연구원 2004

3 한혜경, "인터넷 이용자의 시민적 자질들과가상공간의 숙의 경험의 관계에 관한 연구" 한국방송학회 19 (19): 604-643, 2005

4 이강형, "유권자의 정치후보에 대한 감정이 정치참여에 미치는 영향에 관한 연구" 한국언론학회 46 (46): 73-104, 2002

5 윤영철, "온라인 게시판 토론과 숙의 민주주의: 총선 연대 사이트의 게시판 분석" 14 (14): 109-150, 2000

6 이준웅, "숙의 민주주의의 커뮤니케이션 실험" 2003

7 김종길, "사이버공론장의 분화와 숙의민주주의의 조건" 한국사회학회 39 (39): 34-68, 2005

8 김주환, "민주주의에 있어서 대화의 중요성:공론장에서의 의사소통행위로서의 정치적 대화" 성곡언론문화재단 13 (13): 75-100, 2005

9 Papacharissi, Z., "The virtual sphere: The Internet as a public sphere" 4 (4): 9-27, 2002

10 Rheingold, H., "The virtual community: Home steading on the electronic frontier" HarperColloins 1993

11 Toulmin, S. E., "The uses of argument" Cambridge University Press 1958

12 Habermas, J., "The theory of communicative action: Reason and the rationalization of society. 1" Beacon 1984

13 Habermas, J., "The structural transformation of the public sphere: An inquiry into a category of bourgeois society" MIT Press 1989

14 Kuhn, D., "The skills of argument" Cambridge University Press 1991

15 Marcus, G. E., "The sentimental citizen: Emotion in democratic politics" Pennsylvania State University Press 2002

16 Mikula, G., "The role of injustice in the elicitation of differential emotional reactions" 24 : 769-783, 1998

17 Perelman, CH., "The realm of rhetoric" University of Notre Dame Press 1982

18 Walton, D., "The place of emotion in argument" Pennsylvania State University Press 1992

19 Sunstein, C., "The law of group polarization" 10 (10): 175-195, 2002

20 Bentivegna, Sara, "Talking politics on the net. Press and politics research paper" The Joan Shorenstein Center Harvard University 3-20, 1998

21 Gamson, W. A., "Talking politics" Cambridge University Press 1992

22 Keane, J., "Structural transformations of the public sphere, In Digital democracy: Issues of theory and practice" Sage 2000

23 DiMaggio, P., "Social implications of the Internet" 27 : 307-336, 2001

24 Fraser, N., "Rethinking the public sphere: A contribution to the critique of actually existing democracy, In Habermas and the public sphere" MIT Press 1992

25 Mutz, D. C., "Political persuasion and attitude change" The University of Michigan Press 1996

26 Nussbaum, M. C., "Poetic justice: The literary imagination and public life" Beacon 1995

27 Antaki, C., "Ordinary explanation in conversation: Causal structures and their defence" 15 (15): 213-230, 1985

28 Ryfe, D. M., "Narrative and deliberation in small group forums" 34 (34): 72-93, 2006

29 Fisher, W. R., "Narration as a human communication paradigm: The case of public moral argument, In Contemporary Rhetorical Theory: A Reader" The Guilford Press 1999

30 Schank, R. C., "Knowledge and memory: The real story, In Knowledge and memory: The real story. Advances in social cognition, Volume Ⅷ" Lawrence Erlbaum Associates 1995

31 Gamson, W. A., "How storytelling can be empowering, In Culture in mind: Toward a sociology of culture and cognition" Routledge 2002

32 Herring, S., "Gender and democracy in computer-mediated communication, In Computerization and controversy (2nd ed.), value conflicts and social choices" Academic Press 1996

33 Delli Carpini, M. X., "Gen.com: youth, civic engagement, and the new information environment" 17 (17): 341-350, 2000

34 Habermas, J., "Further reflections on the public sphere, In Habermas and the public sphere" MIT Press 421-461, 1992

35 Ferree, M. M., "Four models of the public sphere in modern democracies" 31 : 289-324, 2002

36 Mansbridge, J. J., "Everyday talk in the deliberative system, In Deliberative politics: Essays on democracy and disagreement" Oxford University Press 1999

37 Lazarus, R. S., "Emotion and adaptation" Oxford University Press 1991

38 Corrado, A., "Elections in cyberspace: Toward a new era in American politics" The Aspen Institute 1999

39 Ryfe, D. M., "Does deliberative democracy work?" 8 : 49-71, 2005

40 Norris, P., "Digital divide: Civic engagement, information poverty, and the internet worldwide" Cambridge University Press 2001

41 Richardson, H. S., "Democratic autonomy: Public reasoning about the end of policy" Oxford University Press 2002

42 Cohen, J., "Deliberation and democratic legitimacy, In Deliberative democracy: Essays on reason and politics" MIT Press 1997

43 Hill, K. A., "Cyberpolitics: Citizen activism in the age of the Internet" Rowman & Littlefield 1998

44 Dahlberg, L., "Computer-mediated communication and the public sphere: A critical analysis" 7 (7): 2001

45 Young, I. M., "Communication and the other: Beyond deliberative democracy, In Democracy and difference: Contesting the boundaries of the political" Princeton University Press 1996

46 Dutwin, D., "Can people talk politics? A study of deliberative democracy" University of Pennsylvania 2002

47 Sanders, L. M., "Against deliberation" 25 : 347-376, 1997

48 Bruner, J., "Actual minds. possible worlds" Harvard University Press 1986

49 Tindale, C. W., "Acts of arguing: A rhetorical model of argument" State University of New York Press 1999