Is the Morality of Human Beings Superior to the Morality of Non-Human Beings? : Debate over Human versus Animal Nature in the Joseon Period

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Confucian scholars of Joseon Korea carried out a philosophical debate on what they referred to as the original nature of humans versus non-human beings including animals. This debate arose from the correspondence between two followers of the Zhu Xi School in Korea, Oeam and Namdang, in 1709. The main question of the debate was whether humans and other beings including animals have equal natures. Following them, many scholars engaged in the debate, dividing into two groups: Nak-ron 洛論 and Ho-ron 湖論. Nak-ron scholars thought that the original nature of humans and other non-human beings was equal. Ho-ron scholars thought that the original nature of humans was different than that of other beings. According to Nak-ron opinion, animals inherently possessed a morality equal to the morality of humans. According to Ho-ron opinion, animals also possessed a morality; however, because the temperaments of animals were considered inferior to those of humans, the morality of animals was also considered inferior to the morality of humans.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 최훈, "동물을 도덕적으로 고려해야 할 진화론적 이유" 철학연구회 (88) : 283-305, 2010

2 홍정근, "朝鮮時代 湖洛論辨에서의 人間本性 논의에 관한 考察" 한국유교학회 (38) : 133-164, 2009

3 Confucius, "Zhongyong 中庸(Doctrine of the Mean)"

4 Kim, Sung Dong, "Yulli-neun jinhwaronjeok giwon-eul gatgo-inneunga?-dodeokseong-eun ingan goyu-ui balmyeongpum-i anieotda(Do Ethics Have Evolutionary Origin?-Morality was not an Invention of the Human)"

5 Hu, Kuang, "Xingli daquan (Great Compendium on Nature and Principle)" 1415

6 Bekoff, Marc, "Wild Justice: The Moral Lives of Animals" University of Chicago Press 2009

7 Goodall, Jane, "The Ten Trusts: What We Must Do to Care for The Animals We Love" HarperOne 2002

8 Kim, Chang-heup, "Samyeonjip 三淵集(The Collected Works of Samyeon Kim Chang-heup)"

9 Yi, Gan, "Oeam yugo 巍巖遺稿(The Posthumous Writings of Oeam Yi Gan)"

10 Han, Won-jin, "Namdangjip 南塘集(The Collected Works of Namdang Han Won-jin)" 1765

11 Kim, Won-haeng, "Mihojip 渼湖集(The Collected Works of Miho Kim Wonhaeng)"

12 Jeong, Jung-gi, "Maesanjip 梅山集(The Collected Works of Maesan Jeong, Jung-gi)"

13 Lee, Ae-hi, "Joseon yuhak-ui hakpadeul(Schools of Joseon Confucianism)" Yemun 1996

14 Hong, Jung Geun, "Horak nonjaeng-ui bonjil-gwa Im Seong-ju-ui cheolhak sasang(The Essence of the Horak Debates and Im Seong Ju’s Philosophical Thought)" Academia Koreana 2007

15 Moon, Suk-yoon, "Horak nonjaeng hyeongseong-gwa jeongae(The Formation and Development of the Horak Debate)" Dong-gwa Seo 2006

16 Boehm, Christopher, "Hierarchy in the Forest: The Evolution of Egalitarian Behavior" Harvard University Press 2001

17 Bae, Jong-Ho, "Hanguk yuhak-ui cheolhakjeok jeongae(The Philosophical Unfolding of Korean Confucianism). Vol. 2" Yonsei University Press 1985

18 Yoo, Myung-Jong, "Hanguk yuhak yeongu(A Study of Korean Confucianism)" Imun Chulpansa 1998

19 Choi, Young-Jin, "Hanguk cheolhaksa (The History of Korean Philosophy)" Saemunsa 2009

20 Han, Won-jin, "Gyeongui gimunnok 經義記聞錄(Review of Neo-Confucianism)" 1741

21 Kim, Song Han, "Gongnijuui-wa dongmul-ui dodeok-jeok jiwi(Utilitarianism and Moral Status of Animals), In Dongmul-ui gamgak, dongmul-ui uisik, geurigo dongmul-ui dodeokjeok jiwi(Animals’ Sense, Animals’ Consciousness, and Animals’ Moral Status)" Chung-Ang University, Chung-Ang Institute of Philosophy 2010

22 Eo, Yu-bong, "Giwonjip 杞園集(The Collected Works of Giwon Eo Yubong)"

23 "Dongmul-ui gamgak, dongmul-ui uisik(Animals’ Senses and Consciousness), In Dongmul-ui gamgak, dongmul-ui uisik, geurigo dongmul-ui dodeokjeok jiwi(Animals’ Sense, Animals’ Consciousness, and Animals’ Moral Status)" Chung-Ang University, Chung-Ang Institute of Philosophy 2010

24 Yi, Jae, "Doamjip 陶庵集(The Collected Works of Doam Yi Jae)" 1816

25 De Waal, Frans, "Chimpanzee Politics: Power and Sex among Apes. Revised edition" The Johns Hopkins University Press 2000

26 Yun, Bong-gu, "Byeonggyejip 屛溪集(The Collected Works of Byeonggye Yun Bong-gu)"

27 Chae, Ji-hong, "Bongamjip 鳳巖集(The Collected Works of Bongam Chae, Ji-hong)"

28 Cho, Sung-san, "18 segi horak nonjaeng-gwa noron sasanggye-ui bunhwa(A Study of the Horak Debates and the Division of Noron in the 18th Century)" 8 : 75-112, 1997