Objective: The purpose of this study is to find methods on how to properly utilize Clinical Practice Guidelines (CPGs) of traditional medicine through reviewing the current state of Korean medicine CPGs and Japanese traditional medicine (Kampo) CPGs.
...
Objective: The purpose of this study is to find methods on how to properly utilize Clinical Practice Guidelines (CPGs) of traditional medicine through reviewing the current state of Korean medicine CPGs and Japanese traditional medicine (Kampo) CPGs.
Methods: This study compares CPGs from Korea and Japan. Sources include Korean medicine CPGs, Kampo CPGs, and CPGs regarding Complementary and Alternative Medicine (CAM) published in books, reports, and journals.
Results: Research showed that there were 10 CPGs in Korean medicine and 28 in Kampo medicine, which had strength of evidence and recommendation. Strength of Recommendation ranking is as follows: Grade A: 30, Grade B: 38, Grade C+ and C: 31, Grade D: 1 in Korean medicine CPGs. Respectively, ranking in Kampo medicine is: Grade A: 2, Grade B: 18, Grade C+ and C1: 51, Grade C: 15, and Grade C2: 14. Korean medicine CPGs have clinical questions describing the synergistic effect of multi-treatments such as acupuncture with chuna. In Kampo CPGs, there were clinical questions verifying that the use of a Kampo product as a single treatment can also be effective. Furthermore, according to the organ system classifications, there are five (5) guidelines regarding the muscular/skeletal system in Korean medicine, and seven (7) guidelines on the integumentary system in Kampo medicine.
Conclusion: CPGs only present options and not regulations on how to do treatments in the field of traditional medicine. However, making a system of CPGs could be a step towards better shared making decisions between the doctors and patients during treatment.