주주총회결의를 다투는 소송의 소송물에 관한 고찰 = A Study on the Subject-Matter in the Litigations Regarding the Resolution of a General Shareholder’s Meeting

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

In investigating the subject-matter in the litigations regarding the resolution of a general shareholder’s meeting under the current Commercial Act, we should grasp the contents of the matter of the lawsuits based on the relevant provisions of the Act in view of the interest of the person who is entitled to institute an action and the securing of a legal stabilization. In the case of the litigation for revocation of a resolution, restrictions are placed on the person has the authority to file a lawsuit and the period of instituting an action, etc. It needs to comprehend in respect to the contents of the claim of it that the litigation for confirmation of the nullity or non-existence of a resolution is a kind of lawsuits for confirmation. It is not desirable to understand that the subject-matter in the lawsuits about a resolution of general meeting of stockholders is single on the ground of diffuse boundaries of the causes of revocation, nullity and non-existence because it brings about unreasonable consequence which hurts the legal stabilization.
When a plaintiff demands the ruling of revocation/confirmation of nullity or non-existence because his/her alleged facts constitute the grounds of revocation/nullity/non-existence, the courts of a lawsuit treat it as the litigation for revocation/confirmation of nullity or non-existence of a resolution and shall proceed a trial. If it has been proved that plaintiff’s facts correspond to the defects in a resolution of a different action types by the result of deliberation of the courts, they have to exercise the right to request elucidation and then provide the opportunity that the plaintiff shall alter his/her claims into the right kind of an action. That will make possible to prevent that plaintiffs have a disadvantage because of the obscurity of the flaws in resolutions.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 김병재, "회사법상의 제문제[상]" 법원행정처 1987

2 이철송, "회사법강의" 박영사 2014

3 서정갑, "회사법" 경진사 1989

4 오세욱, "형성소송의 소송물과 변론주의" 판례월보사 (263) : 1992

5 김교창, "주주총회의 운영" 육법사 2010

6 황성호, "주주총회결의하자에 관한 소에 대한 고찰" 법원도서관 24 : 1997

7 김상근, "주주총회결의하자 소송에 관한 실무적 고찰" 한국사법행정학회 12 : 2003

8 정동윤, "주석 상법[회사(Ⅲ)]" 한국사법행정학회 2014

9 김주수, "주석 민법[상속(1)]" 한국사법행정학회 2010

10 최기원, "신회사법론" 박영사 2012

11 이시윤, "신민사소송법" 박영사 2015

12 정찬형, "상법강의(상)" 박영사 2014

13 정동윤, "상법강의(상)" 법문사 2012

14 손주찬, "상법(상)" 박영사 2003

15 강현중, "민사소송법강의" 박영사 2013

16 정동윤･유병현, "민사소송법" 법문사 2014

17 김홍규, "민사소송법" 삼영사 2014

18 김용진, "다시본 민사소송법" 청목출판사 2012

19 小山 昇, "訴訟物の硏究[小山昇著作集 第1卷]" 信山社 1994

20 前田 庸, "實務民事訴訟法講座5 會社訴訟･特許訴訟" 日本評論社 1969

21 谷口安平, "多数當事者訴訟･会社訴訟[民事水続法論集第2巻]" 信山社 2013