Childcare policies and services in Hong Kong after the handover: Beyond a feminist critique

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This article reviews the development of childcare policies and services in Hong Kong after the handover, gauging it with two standards: promoting the equal development of children and gender equality in our society. Statistics derived from data taken from multiple sources show that the government has been sticking to a “positive non-in-tervention approach” to welfare development and that the male breadwinner/female carer model prevalent in this region was shaped and strengthened by current child-care policies and services. The current provision of childcare services is insufficient to guarantee the equal use of childcare among children of different socioeconomic backgrounds, or to ease the tension between the needs of childcare and job require-ments in a family, or to emancipate married women from the domestic sphere. A “generative welfare approach” that collects fiscal resources and redistributes them strategically with a systemic mind-set has been suggested for social policy and ser-vice planning, including spending the money in the right place, launching smart and practical policies that can achieve both pragmatic effects and ideological improve-ment in the area of gender equality, providing financial support or subsidies to a company for the provision of parental leave, and increasing the provision of quality childcare services.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 CSD, "Women and men in Hong Kong: Key statistics"

2 HKSPC, "The opinion on the establishment of Child Welfare Committee [CB(4)717/17‐18(01)]"

3 Choi, H.‐W., "The dearth of childcare services: The government’s role"

4 HKSPC (Hong Kong Society for the Protection of Children), "The comparison between Hong Kong and other developed countries on the support for dual‐worker families"

5 Jill E. Yavorsky, "The Production of Inequality: The Gender Division of Labor Across the Transition to Parenthood" Wiley 77 (77): 662-679, 2015

6 European Union, "Sweden: Successful reconciliation of work and family life"

7 HKCSS, "Study on childcare services for low income families in Hong Kong"

8 Donna Kam Pun Wong, "Struggling in the Mainstream: The case of Hong Kong" Informa UK Limited 49 (49): 79-94, 2010

9 Legislative Council, "Statistics pre‐primary education"

10 Legislative Council, "Statistics on minimal wage"

11 World Bank, "Statistics of Hong Kong SAR, China"

12 HKCSS (The Hong Kong Council of Social Service), "Special report of social development: Profile of Hong Kong children"

13 European Commission, "Social protection and social inclusion: country profile—Sweden: Successful reconciliation of work and family life"

14 Elizabeth Adamson, "Social Investment or Private Profit? Diverging Notions of ‘Investment’ in Early Childhood Education and Care" Springer Science and Business Media LLC 46 (46): 47-61, 2014

15 Legislative Council, "Review on childcare policy[CB(4)484/17‐18(07)]"

16 Crompton, R., "Restructuring gender relations and employment: The decline of the male breadwinner" Oxford University Press 1999

17 HKCSS, "Reports on the future development of childcare care services"

18 CSD, "Report on annual earnings and hours survey"

19 Craig, J., "Replacement level fertility and future population growth" 78 : 20-22, 1994

20 Social Welfare Department, "Public services"

21 Social Indicators of Hong Kong, "Public expenditures on social welfare services as percentages of gross domestic production"

22 Ana Marija Sikirić, "Public Spending on Childcare as an Indicator of Gender Sensitivity of Budget" Faculty of Administration, University of Ljubljana 14 (14): 95-119, 2016

23 Education Bureau, "Profiles of kindergartens and kindergarten‐cum‐child care centres 2018/19 school year"

24 HKIAS (Hong Kong Institute of Asian‐pacific Studies), "Pre‐primary education and family care in Hong Kong"

25 Ma, J. L., "Post-1997 Hong Kong" Hong Kong Institute of Asia-Pacific Studies, CUHK 413-444, 2017

26 CSD, "Population estimates: Vital events"

27 Legislative Council, "Policy on standard working hours [CB(2)1615/16‐17(05)]"

28 Legislative Council, "Pilot scheme on on‐site pre‐school rehabilitation services [CB(2)812/17‐18(03)]"

29 Legislative Council, "Opinions on paid leave of working parents [LC Paper No. CB(2)1518/15‐16(01)]"

30 SoCO (Society for Community Organization), "Opinion paper on the “Free quality kindergarten education committee report” (Legislative Council)"

31 Labour Department, "Maternity protection"

32 Katia Begall, "L’impact sur les intentions de fécondité de la perception subjective de contrôle sur le travail, du stress lié au travail et du conflit travail-famille: une comparaison européenne" Springer Science and Business Media LLC 27 (27): 433-456, 2011

33 Basten, S., "Low and lower fertility: Variations across developed countries" Springer International Publishing 63-86, 2015

34 Yuk-King Lau, "Labor Force Participation of Married Women in Hong Kong: A Feminist Perspective" University of Toronto Press Inc. (UTPress) 37 (37): 93-112, 2006

35 Legislative Council, "Kindergarten tuition and miscellaneous investigation report" and "opinions on the free education committee report[CB(4)1161/14‐15(01)]"

36 Ministry of Labor, Taiwan, "International labour statistics 2017: (Table 1–4) population and labour"

37 CSD, "Hong Kong poverty situation report 2017"

38 Oxfam Hong Kong, "Hong Kong poverty report (2011–2015)"

39 Lai Ching Leung, "Gender mainstreaming childcare policy: barriers in a Confucian welfare society" Cambridge University Press (CUP) 30 (30): 41-52, 2014

40 Judith Treas, "Gender inequality in housework across 20 European nations: Lessons from gender stratification theories" Springer Science and Business Media LLC 74 (74): 495-511, 2016

41 Jennifer L. Hook, "Gender Inequality in the Welfare State: Sex Segregation in Housework, 1965–2003" University of Chicago Press 115 (115): 1480-1523, 2010

42 Education Bureau, "Free quality kindergarten education scheme: Guidance notes on subsidy disbursement (2017/18 school year)"

43 Tranby, E., "Family policies or labor forces? Women’s employment inequality in 14 welfare states. from 1960 to 2008" The University of Minnesota 2010

44 Wim Van Lancker, "Explaining patterns of inequality in childcare service use across 31 developed economies: A welfare state perspective" SAGE Publications 57 (57): 310-337, 2016

45 CSD (Census and Statistics Department), "Demographic trends in Hong Kong 1986–2016"

46 Yip, S. F., "Consultancy study on the long‐term development of child care services"

47 Trine Rogg Korsvik, "Childcare policy since the 1970s in the ‘most gender equal country in the world’: A field of controversy and grassroots activism" SAGE Publications 18 (18): 135-153, 2011

48 Mak, K. Y., "Child Care Policy and Services in Hong Kong" Hong Kong Society for the Protection of Children & Department of Social Work, Hong Kong Baptist University 2016

49 Financial Secretary, "Budget estimate: Volume 1 General Revenue Account (Head 170: social welfare department)"

50 Steiber, N., "Advances in explaining women's employment patterns" 10 (10): 343-367, 2012

51 Equal Opportunities Commission, "A study on family status discrimination in the workplace in Hong Kong"