의료지리학: 개념적 역사와 역사적 전망 = Medical Geography : Its Conceptual History and Historical Vision

국문 초록 (Abstract)

한국 지리학계에서 보건의료에 대한 지리학적 연구가 증가되고 있는 양상에 비추어 볼 때, 의료지리학이 개념적으로 어떻게 발달해왔는지에 대한 역사적인 인식이 요청된다. 이 글의 목적은 의료지리학의 개념적 역사를 탐구하고 향후 의료지리학의 역사적 전망을 제시하는 데 있다. 근대 의료지리학은 유럽이 열대 식민지를 통치하는 과정에서 필연적으로 직면하게 되었던 열대 질병을 통제하는 과정에서 의료지형학의 이름으로 형성되었다. 영국에서는 환경위생 개혁의 명분으로, 프랑스에서는 문명화 사명의 구호 아래, 독일에서는 지리의학의 개념으로 각각 발달해왔던 의료지리학은 20세기에 크게 질병 생태학과 의료체계의 두 가지 흐름으로 발달되었다. 본 논문은 질병의 지도에 함축된 권력의 의미를 강조하면서, 의료지리학, 보건지리학, 건강지리학의 공통 지점과 서로 다른 지향점을 제시하였다는 데 의의가 있다.

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The objective of my paper is to investigate historical change in concepts of medical geography and to present its historical vision. Modern medical geography was established in the name of medical topography in Europe where it had to control tropical diseases in the course of exploration and voyages for colonial interests. England developed medical geography in the name of sanitary reform, France did so for civilizing mission, and geomedicine prevailed in Germany. The twentieth century witnessed two traditions of medical geography, with focus on disease ecology and medical care system, respectively. In addition, the paper emphasizes the significance of cartography of disease as knowledge as power. As the identity of place becomes increasingly important in relation to health at the around of the twenty-first century, geography of health has emerged as a new promising discipline independently of medical and public health geography.

목차 (Table of Contents)

• 요약
• Abstract
• 1. 문제의식 및 문제의 성격
• 2. 의학에 대한 지리적 사유: 개념적 역사
• 3. 의료지리학의 발달과 분화
• 4. 의료지리학의 이론적 맥락과 역사적 전망
• 5. 맺음말
• 참고문헌

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 和吐哲郞, "풍토와 인간" 장승 1993

2 정선태, "지도의 상상력" 산처럼 2006

3 Jer-emy Black, "지도, 권력의 얼굴" 심산 2006

4 김현주, "장소와 장소상실" 논형 2005

5 Friedrich Nietzsche, "인간적인 너무나 인간적인 II" 책세상 2002

6 이종찬, "의학의 세계사" 몸과마음 2009

7 박경돈, "의료이용의 지역적 불균형에 대한 연구: 공간종속성을 중심으로" 한국정책학회 21 (21): 387-414, 2012

8 이희연, "응급의료기관의 공간분포와 응급의료 서비스 수급의 공간적 격차" 한국지역지리학회 10 (10): 606-623, 2004

9 Susan Sontag, "은유로서의 질병" 이후 2002

10 이종찬, "열대와 서구 - 에덴에서 제국으로" 새물결 2009

11 Jean Bau-drillard, "시뮬라시옹" 민음사 2001

12 신호성, "시공간 분석을 이용한 외래 의료이용의 지역적 차이 분석" 한국지리정보학회 15 (15): 138-150, 2012

13 Fernand Braudel, "생물학적 인간에 관한 지리학이 존재하는가, 역사학 논고" 민음사 1990

14 Jorge Luis Borges, "불한당들의 세계사" 민음사 1997

15 남광우, "부산시 응급의료서비스의 시공간적 분포특성" 한국지리정보학회 10 (10): 113-123, 2007

16 박선엽, "벡터매개 질병(vector-borne diseases) 공간역학을 중심으로 한 보건지리학의 최근 연구" 대한지리학회 47 (47): 677-699, 2012

17 이건학, "방문보건서비스의 효율적 운영을 위한 방문경로 최적화 연구" 한국도시지리학회 13 (13): 1-16, 2010

18 이종찬, "동아시아 의학의 전통과 근대" 문학과지성사 2004

19 김감영, "농촌지역 노년인구를 위한 방문 의료서비스 구역 설정 모델 및 알고리즘" 대한지리학회 44 (44): 813-831, 2009

20 조대헌, "농촌지역 공공 보건서비스에 대한 공간적 접근성 분석" 한국지역지리학회 16 (16): 137-153, 2010

21 부혜진, "네팔 보건의료 정책의 현황과 과제－전문 의료 인력의 지리적 분포와 의료서비스 접근성의 관점에서 －" 한국지역지리학회 18 (18): 203-216, 2012

22 Tuan, Yi-Fu, "공간과 장소" 대윤 2007

23 裵秉哲, "今釋 黃帝內經 - 靈植" 成輔社 1994

24 裵秉哲, "今釋 黃帝內經 - 素問" 成輔社 1994

25 Barrett, Frank A., "‘Scurvy’ Lind’s Medical Geography" 33 : 347-353, 1991

26 Jarcho, Saul, "Yellow Fever, Cholera, and the Beginnings of Medical Cartography" 25 : 131-142, 1970

27 Wilkinson, Richard G., "Unhealthy Societies: The Af fliction of Inequality" Routledge 1996

28 Livingstone, David N., "Tropical Climate and Moral Hygiene: The Anatomy of a Victorian Debate" 32 : 93-110, 1999

29 Cosgrove, Denis, "Tropic and Tropicality, In Tropical Visions in an Age of Empire" The University of Chicago Press 197-216, 2005

30 Gesler, Wilbert M., "Therapeutic Landscapes: Medical Issues in Light of the New Cultural Geography" 34 : 735-746, 1992

31 Williams, Allison, "Therapeutic Landscapes" Ashgate Pub. Co 2008

32 Pettenkoffer, Max, "The Value of Health to a City: Two Lectures Delivered In 1873(1873)" Literary Licensing, LLC 2011

33 Montesquieu, "The Spirits of the Laws" Cambridge University Press 1989

34 Duffy, John, "The Sanitarians: A History of Public Health" University of Illinois Press 1990

35 Barrett, Frank A., "The Role of French-language Contributors to the Development of Medical Geography (1872-1993)" 55 : 155-165, 2002

36 Agnew, John A, "The Power of Place: Bringing Together Geographical and Sociological Imaginations" Unwin Hyman 1989

37 Wood, Denis, "The Power of Maps" The Guilford Press 1992

38 Mayer, Jonathan, D., "The Political Ecology of Disease as One New Focus for Medical Geography" 20 : 441-456, 1996

39 Petersen, Alan, "The New Public Health: Health and Self in the Age of Risk" SAGE 1996

40 Harley, John Brian, "The New Nature of Maps: Essays in the History of Cartography" The Johns Hopkins University Press 2001

41 Hudson, Brian, "The New Geography and the New Imperialism, 1870-1918" 9 (9): 140-153, 1972

42 Livingstone, David N., "The Moral Discourse of Climate: Historical Considerations of Race, Place and Virtue" 17 : 413-434, 1991

43 Johnson, James, "The Influence Of Tropical Climates On European Constitutions(1813)" 1818

44 Porter, Dorothy, "The History of Public Health and the Modern State" 1994

45 Knox, Paul L., "The Geography of Medical Care Delivery: An Historical Perspective" 13 : 245-250, 1982

46 Clemow, Frank G., "The Geography of Disease" Cambridge University Press 1903

47 Osborne, Michael A., "The Geographical Imperative in Nineteenth-Century French Medicine, In Medical Geography in Historical Perspective" Wellcome Trust Centre for the History of Medicine 31-50, 2000

48 May, Jacques, M., "The Ecology of Human Disease" MD Publications, Inc 1958

49 Wateson, George, "The Cures of the Diseased, in Remote Regions: Preventing Mortalitie, Incident in Forraine Attempts, of the English Nation(1598)" Clarendon Press 1915

50 Kiple, Kenneth F., "The Cambridge World History of Human Disease" Cambridge University Press 1993

51 Kearns, Robin, "Space in Its Place: Developing the Link in Medical Geography" 37 : 711-717, 1993

52 McClellan III, James E., "Science, Medicine and French Colonialism in Old-Regime Haiti, In Science, Medicine and Cultural Materialism" St. Martin’s Press 4-35,

53 Bewell, Alan, "Romanticism and Colonial Disease" The Johns Hopkins University Press 1999

54 Harrison, Mark, "Representations of India in British Medical Topography, 1820-c.1870, In Medical Geography in Historical Perspective" Wellcome Trust Centre for the History of Medicine 51-69, 2000

55 Chadwick, Edwin, "Report on The Sanitary Condition of the Labouring Population of Great Britain(1842)" Edinburgh University Press 1965

56 박선엽, "Remote Sensing Applications for Malaria Research : Emerging Agenda of Medical Geography" 한국지역지리학회 18 (18): 473-493, 2012

57 Mayer, Jonathan, D., "Relations between Two Traditions of Medical Geography" 6 : 216-230, 1982

58 Livingstone, David N., "Race, Space and Moral Climatology" 28 : 159-180, 2002

59 Kearns, Robin, "Putting Health into Place: Landscape, Identity & Wellbeing" Syracuse University Press 1998

60 Hamlin, Christopher, "Public Health and Social Justice in the Age of Chadwick, Britain, 1800-1854" Cambridge University Press 1998

61 Ptolemy, "Ptolemy’s Geography: An An-notated Transla -tion of the Theoretical Chapters" Princeton University Press 2000

62 Foucault, Michel, "Power/ Knowledge: Selected Interviews & Other Writings, 1972-1977" Pantheon Books 1980

63 Stepan, Nancy Leys, "Picturing Tropical Nature" Reaktion Books 2001

64 McLeod, Karis S., "Our Sense of Snow: The Myth of John Snow in Medical Geography" 50 : 923-935,

65 Snow, John, "On the Mode of Communication(1855)" Google e-book 2009

66 Finke, Leonhard Ludwig, "On the Different Practices Used by People with Respect to the Sick, the Dying, and the Died: Two Countries on the History of Mankind and Medicine. With a Plan of a Work to be Published on Folkmedicine of Different Peoples of the Earth, In Foreign Primary Sources for Medical Geography and Geographical Medicine, Geographical Monographs" York University-Atkinson College 37-42, 1789

67 Canizares-Esguerra, Jorge, "Nature, Empire, andNa-tion: Explorations of the History of Science in the Iberian World" Stanford University Press 2006

68 La Berge, Ann F., "Mission and Method: The Early Nineteenth- Century French Public Health Movement" Cambridge University Press 1992

69 Martin, James Ranald, "Medical Topography of Calcutta" G. H. Huttmann 1837

70 Jones, Kelvyn, "Medical Geography: Taking Space Seriously" 17 : 515-524, 1993

71 May, Jacques, M., "Medical Geography: Its Methods and Objective" 40 : 9-41, 1950

72 Akhtar, Rais, "Medical Geography: Has J.M. May Borrowed M. Sorre’s 1933 Concept of Pathogenic Complexes?" 236 : 2003

73 Parr, Hester, "Medical Geography: Critical Medical and Health Geography?" 28 : 246-257, 2004

74 Meade, Melinda S., "Medical Geography(1988; 2000)" The Guilford Press 2010

75 Short, John Rennie, "Making Space: Revisioning the World, 1475-1600" Syracuse University Press 2004

76 Rosenberg, M.W., "Linking the Geographical, the Medical and the Political in Analyzing Health Care Delivery Systems" 26 : 179-186, 1988

77 Nuernberger, Andrea, "Leonhard Ludwig Finke: Medical Geography" Center for Spatially Integrated Social Science

78 Rosen, George, "Leonhard Ludwig Finke, On the Different Kinds of Geographies, but Chiefly on Medical Topographies, and How to Compose Them, Translated from the German with an Introduction" 20 : 527-538, 1946

79 Arnold, David, "Introduction: Tropical Medicine before Manson, in idem, ed., Warm Diseases and Western Medicine: The Emergence of Tropical Medicine, 1500-1900" 30 : 1-19, 1996

80 Ackerknect, Erwin H., "History and Geography of the Most Important Diseases" Hafner Publishing Company 1965

81 Hippocrates, "Hippocrates I" Harvard University Press 1923

82 Kearns, Robin, "Health Geography, In A Companion to Health and Medical Geography" Blackwell Publishing, Ltd 15-32, 2010

83 Hirsch, August, "Handbook of Geographical and Historical Pathology, 2 Vols" The New Sydenham Society 1883

84 Foucault, Michel, "Governmentality, In The Foucault Effect: Studies in Governmentality" The University of Chicago Press 87-104, 1991

85 Simmons, James Stevens, "Global Epidemiology: A Geography of Disease and Sanitation" J. B. Lip-pincott Company 1944

86 Garrison, Fielding H., "Geomedicine: A Science in Gestation" 1 : 1-9, 1933

87 Barkhuus, Arne, "Geomedicine and Geopolitics" 6 : 2017-2020, 1945

88 Gatrell, Anthony, C., "Geographies of Health: An Introduction" Blackwell Publishing Ltd 2009

89 박수경, "Geographical Characteristics and Patients’ Determinants of Online Referrals : A Case Study of Choongbook, Korea" 한국지역지리학회 17 (17): 617-637, 2011

90 Kearns, Robin, "From Medical to Health Geography: Novelty, Place and Theory after a Decade of Change" 26 : 605-625, 2002

91 Osborne, Michael A., "French Military Epidemiology and the Limits of the Laboratory: The Case of Louis-Felixe-Achille Kelsch, In The Laboratory Revolution in Medicine" Cambridge University Press 189-208, 1992

92 Marcovich, Anne, "French Colonial Medicine and Colonial Rule: Algeria and Indochina, In Disease, Medicine, and Empire: Perspectives on Western Medicine and the Experience of European Expansion" Routledge 103-117,

93 Nordenskiold, Adolf Erik, "Facsimile-Atlas to the Early History of Cartography with Reproductions of the Most Important Maps Printed in the XV and XVI Centuries(1889)" Dover 1973

94 Pagden, Anthony, "European Encounters with the New World" Yale University Press 1993

95 Boudin, Jean Chrisitian, "Essai de geographie medicate" Germer-Bailliere 1843

96 Brundage, Anthony, "England’s “Prussian Minister”: Edwin Chadwick and the Politics of Government Growth, 1832-1854" The Pennsylvania State University Press 1988

97 Hardt, Michael, "Empire" Harvard University Press 2000

98 Garrison, Fielding H., "Editorial: Medical Geography and Geographic Medicine" 7 : 593-612, 1932

99 Dorn, Michael L, "Doubting Dualisms, In A Companion to Health and Medical Geography" Blackwell Publishing, Ltd 55-78, 2010

100 Delaporte, Francois, "Disease and Civilization: The Cholera in Paris, 1832(1986)" The MIT Press 1986

101 Coleman, William, "Disease Is a Social Disease: Public Health and Political Economy in Early Industrial France" The University of Wisconsin Press 1982

102 Barrett, Frank A., "Disease & Geography. The History of an Idea. Geographical Monographs" York University-Atkinson College 2000

103 Thomas, Nicolas, "Colonialism’s Culture: Anthropology, Travel and Government" Princeton University Press 1994

104 McKay, Donald Vernon, "Colonialism in the French Geographical Movement, 1871-1881" 33 : 214-232, 1943

105 Virchow, Rudolf, "Collected Essays on Public Health and Epidemiology, 2 Vols" Science History Publications 1985

106 Hoy, Suellen, "Chasing Dirt: The American Pursuit of Cleanliness" Oxford University Press 1995

107 Riley, James C., "Chapter 2. Medical Geography and Medical Climatology, The Eighteenth-Century Campaign to Avoid Disease" Macmillan 31-53, 1987

108 Koch, Tom, "Cartographies of Disease: Maps, Mapping, and Medicine" ESRI Press 2005

109 Rosen, George, "Cameralism and the Concept of Medical Police, From Medical Police to Social Medicine: Essays on the History of Health Care" Science History Publications 120-141, 1974

110 McGrane, Bernard, "Beyond Anthropology: Society and the Other" Columbia University Press 1989

111 Stoler, Ann Laura, "Between Metropole and Colony: Rethinking a Research Agenda, In Tensions of Empire: Colonial Cultures in a Bourgeois World" University of California Press 1-56, 1997

112 Barrett, Frank A., "August Hirsch: As Critic of, and Contributor to, Geographical Medicine and Medical Geography" 20 : 98-117, 2000

113 Paul, Bimal Kanti, "Approaches to Medical Geography: An Historial Perspective" 20 : 399-409, 1985

114 Ackerknect, Erwin H., "Anticontagionism between 1821 and 1867" 22 : 562-593, 1948

115 Lind, James, "An Essay on the Diseases Incidental to Europeans in Hot Climates with the Method of Preventing Their Fatal Consequences" Gale ECCO 1768

116 Finke, Leonhard Ludwig, "An Attempt at a Universal Medical-Practical Geography, in which the historical section on folk and public medicine is presented, In Foreign Primary Sources for Medical Geography and Geographical Medicine, Geographical Monographs" York University-Atkinson College 51-54, 1792

117 Jackson, Robert, "A Treatise on the Fevers of Jamaica, with Some Observations on the Intermitting Fever of America, and an Appendix, Containing Some Hints on the Means of Preserving the Health of Soldiers in Hot Climates" J. Murray 1791

118 Moseley, Benjamin, "A Treatise on Tropical Diseases, on Military Operations; and on the Climate of the West Indies (1787)" T. N. Longman and O. Rees 1804

119 Frank, Johann Peter, "A System of CompletedMedi-cal Police" The Johns Hopkins University Press 1976

120 Conklin, Alice, L., "A Mission to Civilize: The Republican Idea of Empire in France and West Africa, 1895-1930" Stanford University Press 1997

121 Barrett, Frank A., "A Medical Geographical Anniversary" 37 : 701-710, 1993

122 Rosen, George, "A History of Public Health(1958)" The Johns Hopkins University Press 1993

123 Sigerist, Henry E., "A History of Medicine: Primitive and Archaic Medicine. Vol. I" Oxford University Press 1951

124 최병두, "2000년대 한국 사회지리학의 경향과 논제들-(2) 경험적 연구들-" 대한지리학회 47 (47): 735-754, 2012

125 Moon, Graham, "(Re)Placing Research on Health and Health Care" 1 : 1-4, 1995