KOSPI200 주가지수선물과 옵션의 헤지효과 = Hedging Effectiveness of KOSPI200 Index Futures and Options

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The purpose of this study is to investigate hedging effectiveness of KOSPI200 index futures and options using three measures proposed by Fishburn (1977), Ederington (1979), and Howard and D`Antonio (1987). The comparison of hedging effectiveness is conducted based on the market prices of KOSPI200 index futures and options traded in Korea Exchange (KRX) between January of 2001 and January of 2011, during which bootstrapping method is utilized to make a dataset of 100,000 random samples with holding period of 1, 3, 6, and 12 months, respectively. We examine the hedging performance of hedge portfolios made of short futures, protective puts and covered calls respectively based on three hedging effectiveness measures. One of our finding is that short futures hedging is better than options in minimizing total volatility risk as well as down-side risk, which is consistent to the previous researches. Also futures hedging is more effective in reducing the VaR than the others. Secondly, the optimal hedge ratios of futures in minimizing total risk and down-side risk are turned out to be 0.97～0.98 and 0.94～0.95 respectively. Third, OTM short call hedge is the best hedging instrument when hedgers would like to maximize the Sharpe ratio. Finally, protective put hedging strategy is in general inferior to the short futures and covered call hedge based on three hedging effectiveness measures.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 권택호, "파생상품 이용이 국내기업의 위험 및 가치에 미치는 영향과 그 결정요인" 한국파생상품학회 19 (19): 335-362, 2011

2 홍정효, "코스피 200 주가지수선물을 이용한 교차헤지(cross-hedge)" 한국재무관리학회 23 (23): 243-266, 2006

3 이준행, "연기금의 포트폴리오 보험 전략 활용에 관한 연구-CPPI와 TIPP 전략을 중심으로" 4 (4): 97-119, 2005

4 남상구, "분수 공적분을 이용한 최적 헤지비율 추정" 18 (18): 23-41, 2001

5 박영규, "다양한 포트폴리오 보험전략의 성과비교연구" 28 (28): 333-378, 2001

6 윤원철, "국내 통화선물계약의 상대적 헤징효과 분석" 한국파생상품학회 15 (15): 41-72, 2007

7 Merton, R., "The Returns and Risk of Alternative Call Option Portfolio Investment Strategies" 51 (51): 183-242, 1978

8 Ederington, L., "The Hedging Performance of the New Futures Markets" 34 (34): 157-170, 1979

9 Ahmadi, H., "The Effectiveness of Futures and Options in Hedging Currency Risk" Part B : 171-191, 1986

10 Adam, M., "Risk Value Analysis of Covered Short Call and Protective Put Portfolio Strategies" 13 (13): 431-449, 1999

11 Markowitz, H. M., "Portfolio Selection" 7 : 77-91, 1952

12 De Jong, A., "Out-of-Sample Hedging Effectiveness of Currency Futures for Alternative Models and Hedging Strategies" 17 (17): 817-837, 1997

13 Whaley, R., "On the Return and Risk of the CBOE BuyWrite Monthly Index" 10 (10): 35-42, 2002

14 Fishburn, P., "Mean-Risk Analysis with Risk Associated with Below-Target Return" 67 (67): 116-126, 1977

15 정한규, "KOSPI200 현․선물간 최적헤지비율의 추정" 16 (16): 223-243, 1999

16 한덕희, "KOSPI200 옵션을 이용한 포트폴리오보험 성과" 한국산업경제학회 20 (20): 2417-2436, 2007

17 이재하, "KOSPI200 선물을 이용한 헤지전략" 28 (28): 379-421, 2001

18 이재하, "KOSPI200 선물을 이용한 포트폴리오 보험전략" 16 (16): 309-335, 1999

19 박영규, "KOSPI200 변동성 추정과 동태적 헤징 전략" 25 (25): 189-227, 1999

20 정진호, "KOSPI 200, S&P 500 주가지수 선물시장간 헤지모형의 성과비교에 관한 연구" 대한경영학회 16 (16): 15-319, 2003

21 최병욱, "KIKO 통화옵션의 헤지효과 분석" 한국파생상품학회 21 (21): 1-47, 2013

22 Brown, G., "How Firms Should Hedge" 15 (15): 1283-1324, 2002

23 Chang, J., "Hedging Effectiveness of Currency Options and Currency Futures" 6 (6): 289-305, 1986

24 Chen, S., "Futures Hedge Ratios : a Review" 43 : 433-465, 2003

25 Hill, J., "Finding Alpha via Covered Index Writing" 62 (62): 29-46, 2006

26 Black, F., "Fact and Fantasy in the Use of Options" 31 (31): 36-72, 1975

27 Figleman, I., "Expected Return and Risk of Covered Call Strategies" (Summer) : 81-95, 2008

28 Figlewski, S., "Evaluating the Performance of the Protective Put Strategy" 46-56, 1993

29 Naidu, N., "Effectiveness of Currency Futures Market in Hedging Foreign Exchange Risk" 21 : 5-16, 1981

30 Shimko, D., "Bounds of Probability" 5 : 33-37, 1993

31 Davidson, A., "Bootstrap Methods and their Application" Cambridge University Press 1997

32 Howard, C., "A Risk-Return Measure of Hedging Effectiveness : A Reply" 22 (22): 377-381, 1987

33 Tian, Y., "A Reexamination of Portfolio Insurance: The Use of Index Put Options" 16 (16): 163-188, 1996

34 Hsin, C., "A New Measure to Compare the Hedging Effectiveness of Foreign Currency Futures versus Options" 14 (14): 685-707, 1994