정관복원술에 대한 건강보험 적용의 영향 분석 = Effects of Health Insurance Coverage for Vasovasostomy

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Purpose: In early 1980s, vasectomy was performed in more than 10 thousand men of reproductive age annually without cost as a South Korean government policy of birth control, but because the policy has been converted to encouraging childbirth since July 2004, vasovasostomy is now covered by national health insurance. We investigated the effect of national health insurance coverage of vasovasostomy.
Materials and Methods: From August 1997 to June 2009, a total of 117 patients who underwent vasovasostomy were enrolled in this study. We divided the patients into two groups. The 63 patients undergoing the procedure before national health insurance coverage were included in group A, and the other 54 patients, who underwent the procedure after insurance coverage began, were classified into group B. The two groups were compared according to age, spouse's age, time since vasectomy, number of children at the time of vasectomy, occupation, educational attainment, religion, and the reason for vasovasostomy.
Results: The average number of cases of vasovasostomy was almost 3 times higher after insurance coverage was introduced, at 2.3 cases per month. The average spouse's age was significantly higher in group B than group A (35.2±4.8 vs. 32.2±3.5, p=0.012). Time since vasectomy was shorter in group B than group A (5.7±4.7 years vs. 8.9±5.0 years, p=0.001). Number of children at the time of vasectomy showed no significant difference between group A and group B, at 1.7±0.7 and 1.6±0.8 respectively. Cross tabulation analysis of occupation, educational status, religion, and the reason for vasovasostomy showed no significant difference. The patency rate was significantly higher in group A than group B (87.3% vs. 90.7%, p=0.012), but there was no significant difference in pregnancy rate.
Conclusions: A significant increase was seen in patency rate, but not in pregnancy rate, after insurance coverage. However, further follow up will show us that a rise in the patency rate promises positive effects on the rise of pregnancy rate. We suggest that insurance coverage for vasovasostomy has encouraged an increase in births.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 이경미, "정관절제술 후 10년 이상 경과한 153례에서 정관복원술의 수술 성적" 대한비뇨기과학회 44 (44): 109-114, 2003

2 김준석, "정관복원술 환자의 특성과 출산결과" 대한남성과학회 27 (27): 36-41, 2009

3 Fuchs EF, "Vasectomy reversal performed 15 years or more after vasectomy: correlation of pregnancy outcome with partner age and with pregnancy results of in vitro fertilization with intracytoplasmic sperm injection" 77 : 516-519, 2002

4 Weiske WH, "Vasectomy" 33 : 125-134, 2001

5 Paick JS, "Two-layer vasovasostomy" 9 : 41-44, 1991

6 Deck AJ, "Should vasectomy reversal be performed in men with older female partners?" 163 : 105-106, 2000

7 Belker AM, "Shalip ID. Results of 1,469 microsurgical vasectomy reversals by the Vasovasostomy Study Group" 145 : 505-511, 1991

8 Schwingl PJ, "Safety and effectiveness of vasectomy" 73 : 923-936, 2000

9 Park DW, "Outcome of vasovasostomies on 15 years of more after vasectomy" 43 (43): 79-, 2002

10 Kabalin JN, "Microscopic vasovasostomy re-examined" 38 : 135-138, 1991

11 Silber SJ, "Microscopic vasovasostomy and spermatogenesis" 117 : 299-302, 1977

12 Chaset N, "Male sterilization" 87 : 512-517, 1962

13 Robb P, "Cost-effectiveness of vasectomy reversal" 36 : 391-396, 2009

14 Lee SB, "Comparative evaluation about factors influencing the success rate of microscopic vasovasostomy" 33 : 363-366, 1992

15 Ahn HS, "Clinical study on the vasectomy reversal" 9 : 95-98, 1991

16 Lee HY, "A 20-year experience with vasovasostomy" 136 : 413-415, 1986