Patients’ perceptions on non‐specific effects of acupuncture: Qualitative comparison between responders and non‐responders

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Background: Non-specific effect of acupuncture constitutes part of the overall effect generated via clinical encounter beyond needle insertion and stimulation. It is unclear how responders and non-responders of acupuncture experience non-specific effects differently. We aimed to compare their experiences in a nested qualitative study embedded in an acupuncture randomized trial on functional dyspepsia.




Methods: Purposive sampling was used to capture experience of responders (n=15) and non-responders (n=15) to acupuncture via individual in-depth interviews. Design and analysis followed a framework analysis approach, with reference to an existing model on acupuncture non-specific effects. Themes emerging outside of this model were purposefully explored.




Results: Responders had a more trusting relationship with acupuncturist in response to their expression of empathy. In turn they were more actively engaged in lifestyle modifications and dietary advice offered by acupuncturists. Non-responders were not satisfied with the level of reassurance regarding acupuncture safety. They were also expecting more peer support from fellow participants, regarded that as an empowerment process for initiating and sustaining lifestyle changes.




Conclusions: Our results highlighted key differences in acupuncture non-specific effect components experienced by responders and non-responders. Positive non-specific effects contributing to overall benefits could be enhanced by emphasizing on empathy expression from acupuncturists, trust-building, offering appropriate explanations on safety, and organizing patient support groups. Further research on the relative importance of each component is warranted.

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Background: Non-specific effect of acupuncture constitutes part of the overall effect generated via clinical encounter beyond needle insertion and stimulation. It is unclear how responders and non-responders of acupuncture experience non-specific effects differently. We aimed to compare their experiences in a nested qualitative study embedded in an acupuncture randomized trial on functional dyspepsia.


Methods: Purposive sampling was used to capture experience of responders (n=15) and non-responders (n=15) to acupuncture via individual in-depth interviews. Design and analysis followed a framework analysis approach, with reference to an existing model on acupuncture non-specific effects. Themes emerging outside of this model were purposefully explored.


Results: Responders had a more trusting relationship with acupuncturist in response to their expression of empathy. In turn they were more actively engaged in lifestyle modifications and dietary advice offered by acupuncturists. Non-responders were not satisfied with the level of reassurance regarding acupuncture safety. They were also expecting more peer support from fellow participants, regarded that as an empowerment process for initiating and sustaining lifestyle changes.


Conclusions: Our results highlighted key differences in acupuncture non-specific effect components experienced by responders and non-responders. Positive non-specific effects contributing to overall benefits could be enhanced by emphasizing on empathy expression from acupuncturists, trust-building, offering appropriate explanations on safety, and organizing patient support groups. Further research on the relative importance of each component is warranted.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Asprey A, "‘all in the Same Boat— : A Qualitative Study of Patients’ Attitudes and Experiences in Group Acupuncture Clinics" 30 (30): 163-169, 2012

2 Vickers AJ, "Why use placebos in clinical trials? A narrative review of the methodological literature" 53 (53): 157-161, 2000

3 Hibbard JH, "What the evidence shows about patient activation : better health outcomes and care experiences; fewer data on costs" 32 (32): 207-214, 2013

4 Francis JJ, "What is an adequate sample size? Operationalising data saturation for theory-based interview studies" 25 (25): 1229-1245, 2010

5 Chung VC, "Views on traditional C hinese medicine amongst C hinese population : a systematic review of qualitative and quantitative studies" 17 (17): 622-636, 2014

6 Gale NK, "Using the framework method for the analysis of qualitative data in multi-disciplinary health research" 13 (13): 1-8, 2013

7 Jiang SM, "Unhealthy dietary behavior in refractory functional dyspepsia : A multicenter prospective investigation in C hina" 15 (15): 654-659, 2014

8 Kaptchuk TJ, "The placebo effect in alternative medicine: can the performance of a healing ritual have clinical significance?" 136 (136): 817-825, 2002

9 Grünbaum A, "The placebo concept in medicine and psychiatry1" 16 (16): 19-38, 1986

10 Grünbaum A, "The placebo concept in medicine and psychiatry1" 16 (16): 19-38, 1986

11 Chavarria V, "The placebo and nocebo phenomena : their clinical management and impact on treatment outcomes" 39 (39): 477-486, 2017

12 Data-Franco J, "The nocebo effect : a clinicians guide" 47 (47): 617-623, 2013

13 Yang JW, "The holistic effects of acupuncture treatment" 2014 : 2014

14 Hopton A, "The acceptability of acupuncture for low back pain: a qualitative study of patient’s experiences nested within a randomised controlled trial" 8 (8): e56806-, 2013

15 Birch S, "Testing the clinical specificity of needle sites in controlled clinical trials of acupuncture" 29 : 274-294, 1995

16 Birch S, "Testing the claims of traditionally based acupuncture" 5 (5): 147-151, 1997

17 Pach D, "Standardized versus individualized acupuncture for chronic low back pain: a randomized controlled trial" 2013 : 2013

18 Vase L, "Specifying the nonspecific components of acupuncture analgesia" 154 (154): 1659-1667, 2013

19 Denzen N, "Sociological methods: A sourcebook" 1978

20 Bishop FL, "Scientific tools, fake treatments, or triggers for psychological healing : how clinical trial participants conceptualise placebos" 74 (74): 767-774, 2012

21 Chan MW, "Safety of acupuncture : overview of systematic reviews" 7 (7): 1-11, 2017

22 Chinese Medicine Council of Hong Kong, "Regulation of Chinese Medicines Practitioners"

23 Cutcliffe JR, "Reconsidering reflexivity : introducing the case for intellectual entrepreneurship" 13 (13): 136-148, 2003

24 Ritchie J, "Qualitative research practice: A guide for social science students and researchers" sage 2013

25 Pope C, "Qualitative research in health care : Analysing qualitative data" 320 (320): 114-, 2000

26 Spiegel B, "Psychometric evaluation of patient-reported outcomes in irritable bowel syndrome randomized controlled trials : a Rome Foundation report" 137 (137): 1944-1953, 2009

27 Centre for Health Protection, Department of Health, "Proposed Guidelines on Infection Control related to Acupuncture"

28 Camilleri M, "Primary endpoints for irritable bowel syndrome trials : a review of performance of endpoints" 5 (5): 534-540, 2007

29 Kaptchuk TJ, "Placebo effects in medicine" 373 (373): 8-9, 2015

30 Elsenbruch S, "Placebo effects and their determinants in gastrointestinal disorders" 12 (12): 472-, 2015

31 Benedetti F, "Placebo and the new physiology of the doctor-patient relationship" 93 (93): 1207-1246, 2013

32 Liu T, "Placebo analgesia, acupuncture and sham surgery" 2011 : 65-, 2010

33 Pearson SD, "Patients’ trust in physicians : many theories, few measures, and little data" 15 (15): 509-513, 2000

34 Barr K, "Participation in a randomised controlled trial of acupuncture as an adjunct to in vitro fertilisation : the views of study patients and acupuncturists" 8 (8): 48-54, 2016

35 Bradbury K, "Non-specific mechanisms in orthodox and CAM management of low back pain (MOCAM): theoretical framework and protocol for a prospective cohort study" 6 (6): e012209-, 2016

36 Ho RS, "Non-specific effects of acupuncture and sham acupuncture in clinical trials from the patient’s perspective: a systematic review of qualitative evidence" 2020

37 Schedlowski M, "Neuro-bio-behavioral mechanisms of placebo and nocebo responses : implications for clinical trials and clinical practice" 67 (67): 697-730, 2015

38 Immordino-Yang MH, "Neural correlates of admiration and compassion" 106 (106): 8021-8026, 2009

39 Armour M, "More than needles: the importance of explanations and self-care advice in treating primary dysmenorrhea with acupuncture" 2016 : 2016

40 Shuldiner SR, "Methodological challenges in mapping chinese medicine syndrome with conventional diagnosis : implications for multi-centre trials in integrative medicine" 7 (7): 358-364, 2015

41 Manheimer E, "Meta-analysis : acupuncture for osteoarthritis of the knee" 146 (146): 868-877, 2007

42 Ahmed DAA, "Issues of gender, reflexivity and positionality in the field of disability : researching visual impairment in an Arab society" 10 (10): 467-484, 2011

43 Chung VC, "Incorporating traditional Chinese medicine syndrome differentiation in randomized trials : methodological issues" 8 (8): 898-904, 2016

44 Khorsan R, "How to assess the external validity and model validity of therapeutic trials : a conceptual approach to systematic review methodology" 2014 : 694804-, 2014

45 Linde K, "How large are the nonspecific effects of acupuncture? A meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials" 8 (8): 1-14, 2010

46 Street, "How does communication heal? Pathways linking clinician–patient communication to health outcomes" 74 (74): 295-301, 2009

47 Shapiro AK, "Handbook of Psychotherapy and Behavior change. The placebo effect in medical and psychological therapies" 1978

48 Haake M, "German acupuncture trials(GERAC)for chronic low back pain : randomized, multicenter, blinded, parallel–group trial with 3 groups" 167 (167): 1892-1898, 2007

49 Enck P, "Functional dyspepsia" 3 (3): 1-20, 2017

50 Talley NJ, "Functional Dyspepsia Treatment Trial(FDTT) : a double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled trial of antidepressants in functional dyspepsia, evaluating symptoms, psychopathology, pathophysiology and pharmacogenetics" 33 (33): 523-533, 2012

51 Parkinson S, "Framework analysis : a worked example of a study exploring young people’s experiences of depression" 13 (13): 109-129, 2016

52 Shi GX, "Factors contributing to therapeutic effects evaluated in acupuncture clinical trials" 13 (13): 1-5, 2012

53 Leonard TF Ho ; Vincent C.H. Chung ; Charlene H.L. Wong ; Irene XY Wu ; Kun Chan Lan ; Darong Wu ; Jerry WF Yeung ; Nevin L Zhang ; Ting Hung Leung ; Justin C Y Wu, "Evaluating traditional Chinese medicine diagnostic instruments for functional dyspepsia: systematic review on measurement properties" 한국한의학연구원 10 (10): 1-10, 2021

54 Guillemin M, "Ethics, reflexivity, and"ethically important moments"in research" 10 (10): 261-280, 2004

55 Patton MQ, "Enhancing the quality and credibility of qualitative analysis" 34 (34): 1189-, 1999

56 Bradbury-Jones C, "Enhancing rigour in qualitative health research : exploring subjectivity through Peshkin’s I’s" 59 (59): 290-298, 2007

57 Patton, M. Q., "Encyclopedia of statistics in behavioral science" 2005

58 Chung VC, "Electroacupuncture plus standard of care for managing refractory functional dyspepsia: protocol of a pragmatic trial with economic evaluation" 8 (8): 2018

59 Chung VC, "Electroacupuncture plus on-demand gastrocaine for refractory functional dyspepsia : Pragmatic randomized trial" 34 (34): 2077-2085, 2019

60 Yuan J, "Effectiveness of acupuncture for low back pain: a systematic review" 33 (33): E887-E900, 2008

61 Witt CM, "Effectiveness guidance document(EGD)for Chinese medicine trials : a consensus document" 15 (15): 1-11, 2014

62 Petrie KJ, "Effect of providing information about normal test results on patients’ reassurance : randomised controlled trial" 334 (334): 352-, 2007

63 Younger J, "Development of the Stanford Expectations of Treatment Scale(SETS) : a tool for measuring patient outcome expectancy in clinical trials" 9 (9): 767-776, 2012

64 Cresswell JW, "Designing and conducting mixed method research" Sage 201-, 2011

65 Irvine EJ, "Design of treatment trials for functional gastrointestinal disorders" 130 (130): 1538-1551, 2006

66 Kaptchuk TJ, "Components of placebo effect : randomised controlled trial in patients with irritable bowel syndrome" 336 (336): 999-1003, 2008

67 Hannibal KE, "Chronic stress, cortisol dysfunction, and pain : a psychoneuroendocrine rationale for stress management in pain rehabilitation" 94 (94): 1816-1825, 2014

68 Kaptchuk TJ, "Chinese Medicine: The Web That Has No Weaver" Random House 2000

69 Paterson C, "Characteristic and incidental(placebo)effects in complex interventions such as acupuncture" 330 (330): 1202-1205, 2005

70 Xiang Y, "Appropriateness of sham or placebo acupuncture for randomized controlled trials of acupuncture for nonspecific low back pain : a systematic review and meta-analysis" 11 : 83-, 2018

71 Chung VC, "Age, chronic non-communicable disease and choice of traditional Chinese and western medicine outpatient services in a Chinese population" 9 (9): 1-8, 2009

72 Madsen MV, "Acupuncture treatment for pain:systematic review of randomised clinical trials with acupuncture, placebo acupuncture, and no acupuncture groups" 338 : 2009

73 Lao L, "Acupuncture techniques and devices" 2 (2): 23-25, 1996

74 MacPherson H, "Acupuncture research:strategies for establishing an evidence base" Elsevier Health Sciences 2007

75 Linde, K., "Acupuncture for tension-type headache" (1) : CD007587-, 2009

76 Linde K, "Acupuncture for migraine prophylaxis" (1) : CD001218-, 2009

77 Vickers AJ, "Acupuncture for chronic pain : update of an individual patient data meta-analysis" 19 (19): 455-474, 2018

78 Scharf HP, "Acupuncture and knee osteoarthritis : a three-armed randomized trial" 145 (145): 12-20, 2006

79 Smith C, "Acupuncture and acupressure and massage health outcomes for patients with anorexia nervosa : findings from a pilot randomized controlled trial and patient interviews" 20 (20): 103-112, 2014

80 Cherkin DC, "A randomized trial comparing acupuncture, simulated acupuncture, and usual care for chronic low back pain" 169 (169): 858-866, 2009

81 Kaptchuk TJ, ""Maybe I made up the whole thing" : placebos and patients’ experiences in a randomized controlled trial" 33 (33): 382-411, 2009