라틴아메리카 대통령제에 대한 재평가 -브라질 대통령제를 중심으로- = The Revaluation for Presidentialism in Latin America -Focusing on the Brazilian Presidentilism-

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Latin American countries chose the Presidentialism in the course of modernization. These countries experienced unstable constitutional system for years and also had a difficulty in solidifying democracy. On the contrary European countries of Parliamentarism had built a stable constitutional system. It is true the argument that the Presidentialism is inferior to the parliamentarism has been supported by this fact. In recent days, however, the constitutional government system of Latin American countries is quite well operated with a rapid progress of democracy. Brazil could be a typical example. Braizil is making a remarkable growth of the market economy, mature democracy and regime change between ruling and opposition parties. Therefore the argument for the Parliamentarism based on the historical experience of Latin America is more likely to lose a ground. In the Presidentialism of multiparty country, to discuss how to secure the stability of political situation, how to evaluate the combination of Presidentialism and Proportional representation and how to manage the political situation when the president doesn`t get enough support of dominant assembly will be more constructive than to simply compare the Presidentialism to the Parliamentarism. And this productive discussion will draw wisdom from the historical experience of Latin America who had been through the political upheaval.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 강경희, "현재 브라질 대통령제의 특징에 관한 고찰 : ‘강화된’‘연합형’대통령제" 22 (22): 2007

2 鄭宗燮, "헌법학원론 제7판" 박영사 2012

3 김정현, "이원정부제" 금붕어 2009

4 이원삼, "이슬람법이론 및 금융법제" 한국법제연구원 2009

5 양동훈, "신민주체제의 경제개혁과 민주주의: 브라질과 아르헨티나의 사례" 한국라틴아메리카학회 19 (19): 37-68, 2006

6 신명순, "비교정치" 나남 2003

7 양동훈, "브라질의 신민주체제와 정치부패의 문제:정치체제 접근" 한국라틴아메리카학회 16 (16): 263-313, 2003

8 오삼교, "브라질의 새로운 좌파 정치：룰라의 당선과 노동자당의 변화" 한국인문사회과학회 27 (27): 118-142, 2003

9 최대원, "브라질의 경제민주화 헌법과 경제선순환 예산법제 소개" (9) : 2012

10 최대원, "브라질의 경제민주화 관련 법제 및 정책" 2012

11 장성훈, "브라질 헌정체제와 불안정한 민주주의" 한국정당학회 6 (6): 133-164, 2007

12 정진영, "브라질 대통령제와 정치적 불안정, In 한국의권력구조 논쟁Ⅱ: 권력구조의 운영과 변화" 풀빛 2000

13 조돈문, "브라질 노동자당의 집권과 계급적 기초" 한국사회과학연구회 (72) : 287-325, 2008

14 김정현, "분점정부에 관한 헌법적 연구" 서울대학교 대학원 2011

15 양동훈, "민주화와 권위주의체제 유산의 청산문제: 브라질과 아르헨티나의 비교" 9 : 1996

16 이성형, "룰라정부의 브라질: BRICs의 밝은 미래는 있는가?" 역사문제연구소 (76) : 270-306, 2006

17 강원택, "대통령제, 내각제와 이원정부제: 통치형태의 특성과 운영의 원리" 인간사랑 2006

18 김정현, "대통령 결선투표제에 관한 고찰" 법학연구원 (40) : 159-186, 2012

19 양동훈, "남미의 인권유산 정리정책과 민주주의: 비교정치의 시각에서" 한국라틴아메리카학회 20 (20): 5-39, 2007

20 양동훈, "군부와 민주화 : 브라질과 아르헨티나 비교분석" 3 : 1990

21 정종섭, "韓國에서의 大統領制政府와 持續可能性 - 憲法政策論的 接近 -" 법학연구소 53 (53): 447-496, 2012

22 許營, "韓國憲法論" 博英社 2012

23 金浩鎭, "軍部支配 국가의 脫군부화 모형－브라질과 한국－" 20 (20): 1986

24 張錫權, "獨逸議院內閣制의 特徵" 단국대학교 법학연구소 20 : 1995

25 鄭宗燮, "憲法과 政治制度" 博英社 2010

26 金哲洙, "憲法學槪論" 博英社 2003

27 權寧星, "憲法學原論" 法文社 2005

28 성낙인, "憲法學" 法文社 2010

29 陰善滭, "大統領制와 比例代表選擧制에 관한 연구 序說-라틴 아메리카의 立法例를 중심으로-, In 憲法規範과 憲法現實-權寧星敎授停年紀念論文集-" 법문사 1999

30 Linz, Juan J, "The Virtues of Parliamentarism, In The global Resurgence of Democracy" Johns Hopkins University Press 1993

31 Pereira, Carlos, "The Surprising Success of Multiparty Presidentialism" 23 (23): 2012

32 Linz, Juan J, "The Perils of Presidentialism, In The global Resurgence of Democracy" Johns Hopkins University Press 1993

33 Linz, Juan J., "The Failure of Presidential Democracy: The case of Latin America" The Johns Hopkins University Press 1994

34 Linz, Juan J, "The Failure of Presidential Democracy: Comparative Perspectives" The Johns Hopkins University Press 1994

35 Martin., "The Centrality of political Culture, In The global Resurgence of Democracy" Johns Hopkins University Press 1993

36 Shugart, Matthew Soberg, "Presidents and assemblies : constitutional design and electoral dynamics" Cambridge University Press 1992

37 Mainwaring, Scott, "Presidentialism, Mutipartisl, and Democracy : The Difficult Combination" 26 (26): 1993

38 Lamounier, Bolivar, "Presidentialism and Parliamentarism in Brazil, In Parliamentary versus Presidential Government" Oxford University Press 1992

39 Mettenheim, Kurt von, "Presidential institutions and democratic politics: comparing regional and national contexts" The Johns Hopkins University Press 1997

40 Sola, Lourdes, "Politics, Markets, and Society in Brazil, In Latin America’s struggle for democracy" The Johns Hopkins University Press 2008

41 Lopes, Juarez B, "Obstacles to Economic Reform in Brazil, In Institutional Design in New Democracies: Eastern Europe and Latin America" Westview Press 1996

42 Mainwaring, Scott, "Multipartism, Robust Federalism, and Presidentialism in Brazil, In Presidentialism and democracy in Latin America" Cambridge University Press 1997

43 Mainwaring, Scott, "Latin America : Eight Lessons for Governance" 19 (19): 2009

44 Mainwaring, Scott, "Juan Linz, Presidentialism, and Democracy : A Critical Appraisal" 29 (29): 1997

45 Barczak, Monica, "Executive and Legislatures in Ecuador, In Divided Government in Comparative Perspective" Oxford University Press 2001

46 Blondel, Jean, "Dual Leadership in the Contemporary World, In Parliamentary versus Presidential Government" Oxford University Press 1992

47 Klesner, Joseph L., "Divided Government in Mexico’s Presidentialist Regime: The 1997-2000 Experience, In Divided Government in Comparative Perspective" Oxford University Press 2001

48 Lijphart, A, "Constitutional Choices for New Democracies" 2 (2): 1991

49 Horowitz, Donald, "Comparing Democratic System, In The global Resurgence of Democracy" Johns Hopkins University Press 1993

50 Sartori, Giovanni, "Comparative Constitutional Engineering : an Inquiry into Structures, Incentives, and Outcomes" New York University Press 1997

51 Mettenheim, Kurt Von, "Brazlian Presidentialism: Shifting Comparative Perspectives from Erope to the Americas, In Presidential institutions and democratic politics: comparing regional and national contexts" The Johns Hopkins University Press 1997

52 Power, Timothy J., "Brazilian Democracy as a late bloomer: Reevaluating the Regime in the Cardoso-Lula Era" 2010

53 Mainwaring, Scott, "Brazil: Weak Parties, Fekless Democracy, In Building democratic institutions: party systems in Latin America" Stanford University Press 1995

54 Lamounier, Bolivar, "Brazil: Toward Parliamentarism, In The Failure of Presidential Democracy: The Case of Latin America" The Johns Hopkins University Press 1994