지역사회의 폭력남편과 가정폭력범죄 행위자들의 특성 비교

국문 초록 (Abstract)

본 연구는 사회에 노출되지 않은 지역사회의 폭력남편들과 사법부의 처벌을 받은 아내폭력 가해남성들의 중요한 특성이 무엇이며, 서로 어떻게 다른지 밝히고자 하였다. 이를 위해 152명 비폭력 남성들과 사법체계의 사회기관과 접촉이 없는 82명 폭력남편들, 그리고 가정폭력범죄 처벌을 받은 336명 행위자들을 세 집단으로 분류해서 비교하였다. 다항로지스틱 회귀분석의 결과를 요약하면 다음과 같다. 비폭력 또는 지역사회 폭력집단을 예측하는 요인들은 자녀폭력, 부부평등결정권, 소득으로 나타났다. 법원의 처벌을 받은 행위자들은 아내폭력을 허용하는 태도, 학력, 자녀폭력, 질투심에서 비폭력 남편들과 구별되고 있었다. 사법체계에 노출되지 않은 지역사회의 폭력남편들은 노출된 집단보다 학력이 높고, 결혼기간이 길며, 스트레스 수준이 월등하게 높았다. 반면 가정폭력범죄 행위자들은 지역사회 폭력남편들에 비해 알코올 문제와 폭력을 허용하는 태도를 더 많이 가지고 있었다. 본 연구는 총 333명을 대상으로 MCMI-III 척도에서 제시하는 성격을 유형별로 살펴보았다. 지역사회 폭력남편들은 다른 두 집단에 비해 수동공격적인 성향이 강하고, 사법체계 행위자들보다 자기애성이 강한 것으로 나타났다. 사법체계 폭력집단에서는 상대집단들과 비교할 때 외상 후 스트레스장애만이 고유한 특성으로 발견되었다. 이러한 결과들을 기초로 이론적 논의와 실천적 방안이 제시되었다.

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The present study explored and compared the risk factors of two subtypes of maritally violent men with those of a nonviolent comparison group. One type of batterers consisted of a community sample, and the other was sought from the criminal justice system. The identities of the male community batterers were not exposed to the society since their victims did not contact any of the social service agents related to domestic violence.
To identify the different characteristics associated with two subtypes of woman abusers, a total of 152 nonviolent men, 82 male community batterers, and 336 offenders in a criminal justice system were considered. The results of the descriptive analysis showed that the level of physical violence of the community batterers was two times lower than that of the batterers who received legal punishments. The results of the multinominal logistic regression were as follows:(1) The variables that distinguished the male community batterers from the nonviolent men were the use of physical violence towards children, marital decision power, and income. (2) Four factors had been found to distinguish batterers in the criminal justice system from nonbatterers, namely: attitudes towards woman battering, education, violence towards children, and level of jealousy. (3) The community batterers showed a higher level of education and of stress as well as a longer period of marital relationship compared to the batterers in the criminal justice system. On the other hand, the batterers who received legal punishments had more severe alcohol problems and had an accepting attitude towards the use of violence.
This study also investigated psychopathology among batterers using MCMI-Ⅲ, based on 333 subjects. In terms of the mean scores, there were no subscales associated with personality pathology in all the male groups. Based on the logit model, the community batterers showed a stronger tendency towards having a passive-aggressive personality than did their counterparts, and they recorded a higher level of narcissism compared to the court-referred battering men. Post-traumatic stress was the only symptom that distinguished the batterers who received legal punishments from the other groups. The theoretical and practical implications of these results were pointed out and discussed in the paper.

목차 (Table of Contents)

• 요약
• 1. 서론
• 2. 폭력남편 특성에 관한 선행연구 검토
• 3. 연구방법
• 4. 연구결과
• 5. 요약 및 논의
• 참고문헌

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 김재엽, "한국가정폭력의 실태와 사회복지 개입의 필요성" 1-37, 1998

2 장희숙, "아내폭력가정 자녀의 적응에 영향을 미치는 요인들: 쉼터 거주 아동을 중심으로" 한국사회복지학회 55 : 255-281, 2003

3 김병수, "개인 및 가정환경 변인에 따른 아내학대의 인식과 경험" 1999

4 정숙영, "가정폭력에 영향을 미치는 요인에 관한 연구" 1997

5 장희숙, "가정폭력 행위자의 유형" 56 (56): 303-325, 2004

6 "“부부갈등이 부부폭력과 자녀학대에 미치는 영향”" 1991

7 "“기혼남성의 스트레스와 폭력과의 인과관계”" 1994

8 Bowlby, "“Violence in the Family as a Disorder of the Attachment and Caregiving System American Journal of Psychoanalysis 44" 9-27, 1984

9 A, "“Typologies of Male Batterers Three Subtypes and the Differences among Them" 476-497, 1994

10 Kantor, "“The drunken bum theory of wife beating 203-224 in Physical Violence in American Families edited by M" 1990

11 White, "“The Social Psychology of Romantic Jealousy" 5449-, 1977

12 Hart, "“The Prevalence of Personality Disorders Among Wife Assaulters Journal of Personality Disorder 7" Dutton 329-341, 1993

13 Saunders, "“The Inventory of Beliefs about Wife Beating The Construction and Initial Validation of a Measure of Beliefs and Attitudes" 39-57, 1987

14 "“The Index of Clinical Stress A Brief Measure of Subjective Stress for Practice and Research" 12-15, 1991

15 Dibble, "“Some Social Structure Determinants of Inconsistency Between Attitudes and Behavior Journal of Marriage and the Family 42" 71-80, 1980

16 in Forensic Psychology, "“Social Stress and Marital Violence in a National Sample of American Families edited by F New York Academy of Sciences 213-234 in The Dark Side of Families edited by D “Social Stress and Marital Violence in a National Sample of American Families 181-202 in Physical Violence in American Families edited by M" ------1980

17 Osmond, "“Sex and Sexism a Comparison of Male and Female Sex-Role Attitudes Journal of Marriage and the Family" 1975

18 "“Procedures for Removing Social Desirability Bias from Self-Reports of Violence Journal of Interpersonal Violence 6 “A Typology of Men Who Batter Women Three Types Derived from Cluster Analysis Journal of Orthopsychiatry 62" 337 264-345 275, ------1991------1992

19 Hamberger, "“Personality Correlates of Men Who Abuse Their Partners “Personality Correlates of Men who Batter and Nonviolent Men Journal of Family Violence 6" 323 131-341 147, 1986

20 Hastings, "“Personality Characteristics of Spouse Abusers" 31-48, 1988

21 An Introduction, "“Feminist Perspectives on Wife Abuse 11-26 in Feminist Perspectives on Wife Abuse edited by M" 1988

22 Murphy, "“Family Origin Violence and MCMI-II Psychopathology Among Partner Assaultive Men" 165-176, 1993

23 and A, "“Borderline Personality in Perpetrators of Psychological and Physical Abuse" Dutton 327-337, 1993

24 Neidig, "“Attitudinal Characteristics of Males Who Have Engaged in Spouse Abuse Journal of Family Violence 1" 223-233, 1986

25 Hotaling, "“An Analysis of Risk Markers in Husband to Wife Violence" 101-124, 1986

26 Gelles, "“Alcohol and Other Drugs are Associated with Violence in Current Controversies on Family Violence edited by R" ------1993b182-196

27 Leonard, "“Alcohol and Marital Aggression in a National Sample of Young Men Journal of Interpersonal Violence 7" 199219-30

28 Tolman, "“A Review of Quantitative Research on Men Who Batter Journal of Interpersonal Violence 5" 87-118, 1990

29 Barnett, "“A Hostility-guilt Assessment of Counseled and Uncounseled Batters Paper presented at the Responses to Family Violence Research Conference" Purdue University 1989

30 A, "in Current Controversies on Family Violence edited by R" 47-62, 1993

31 Gelles, "in Current Controversies on Family Violence edited by R" 31-46, 1993a

32 Coleman, "and Violence in an Nationally Representative Sample of American Couples in Physical Violence in American Families edited by M" 1990182-202

33 O'Leary, "and Levels of Violence 7-30 in Current Controversies on Family Violence edited by R" 1993

34 Cahn, "and Depression in Domestically Violent versus Generally Assaultive Men and Nonviolent Control Subjects Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 56" vitalia : 17-23, 1988

35 MacEwen, "Violence in the Family of Origin Journal of Family Violence 3" 73-88, 1988

36 Steinmetz, "Violence in the Family" 1974

37 Katz, L. F.,, "Vagal Tone Protects Children from Marital Conflict" 7 : 83-92, 1995

38 van der Kolk, "Trauma in Men Effects on Family Life in Abuse and Victimization Across the Life Span edited by M" Johns Hopkins University Press 170-185, 1988

39 Dutton, D. G, "Through a Psychological Lens" Sage 5-18, 2005

40 Selzer, "The Quest for a New Diagnostic Instrument American Journal of Psychiatry 127" 1653-1658, 1971

41 Dutton, D. G, "The Domestic Assaults of Women2nd ed" University of British Columbia Press 1995

42 Anger Control, "The Development and Evaluation of An Experimental Treatment" Lexington (vaco) : 1975

43 "The Abusive Personality" Guilford 1998

44 Cunradi, C. B, "Socioeconomic Predictors of Intimate Partner Violence Among White Black and Hispanic Couples in the United States" 17 (17): 377-389, 2002

45 Straus, M. A, "Revised Conflict Tactics Scales(CTS2) : Development and Preliminary Psychometric Data" 17 (17): 283-316, 1996

46 Quigley, B. M, "Resistance of Husband Aggression in the Early Years of Marriage" 11 : 355-370, 1996

47 Briere, "Predicting self-reported likelihood of battering Research in Personality 21" 61-69, 1987

48 Beasley, "Personality Characteristics of Male Spouse Abusers" 310-23 317, 1992

49 "MCMI-III Results for Batterer Program Participants in Four Cities : Less Pathological Than Expected" 14 (14): 1-17, 1999

50 Straus, "Journal of Marriage and the Family Feburary" 75-88, 1979

51 Rosenbaum, "Journal of Family Violence 1" 121-130, 1986

52 Barling, "Journal of Applied Psychology 71" 346-348, 1986

53 Barnett, O. W, "Jealousy and Anxious Romantic Attachment in Maritally Violent and Nonviolent Males" 10 : 473-486, 1995

54 Straus, "Estimates from the National Family Violence Resurvey and Other Studies in Physical Violence in American Families edited by M" 95-112, 1990

55 Martin, "Counseling for Family Violence and Abuse Resource for Christian Counseling Series" 1986

56 Rosenbaum, "Characteristics of Abusive Couples Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 49" 663-671, 1981

57 Morrison, K. M, "A Survey of Massachusetts Batterer Intervention Programs Predicting Treatment Completion" Antioch New England Graduate School 1997

58 Pokorny, "A Shortened Version of the Michigan Alcoholism Screening Test American Journal of Psychiatry 129" 342-345, 1972