현대인권론과 공리주의 ― 인권의 정당화 ― = Contemporary Theory of Human rights and Utilitarianism ― Justification on Human rights ―

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

One of the traditional debate on the objective existence of substantial
justice and its possibility of knowledge is whether the criteria which apply
to judge base of moral rights should be distributive and equalitarian one or
aggregative and utilitarian one. The former stands on the utilitarianism
which takes preference of community value, the latter lies at the root of
comtemporary theory of human rights which emphasizes on indispensible
individual human rights.
Present-days theory of human rights has criticized utilitarian theory of
human rights through cognizing human rights as a moral rights and
developed new alternative theory which could take place of value relativism
and utilitarinism which has prevailed throughout the field of ethics
generation after generation.
By challenging contemporary theory of human rights and utilitarianism,
I will seek the methodology for ensuring objective justification of human
rights and establish basis of human rights as a moral rights on the
philosophy of law.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 프랑케나, "위의 책" 70-74,

2 김도균, "권리담론의 세 차원: 개념분석, 정당화, 제도화" 한국법철학회 7 (7): 181-210, 2004

3 M. Cranston, "What are human Rights?" London 6-69, 1973

4 J. S. Mill, "Utilitarianism in Collected Works of J. S. Mill vol.X: Essays on Ethics, Religion and Society" 73-75, 1969

5 H. L. A. Hart, "Utilitarianism and Natural Rights" 53 (53): 675-678, 1979

6 J. Rawls, "Two Concepts of Rules" Duke Univ. Press 3-32, 1955

7 H. G. Blocker, "Theory of Social Justice: An Introduction" Ohio Univ. Press 1980

8 R. B. Friedman, "The Basis of Human Rights: A Criticism of Gewirth’s Theory" in Nomos 148-157, 1981

9 R. M. Dworkin, "Taking Rights Seriously" Havard Univ. Press 234-277, 1977

10 J. Feinberg, "Social Philosophy" Prentice Hall, Inc 84-85, 1973

11 J. R. Pennock, "Rights, Natural Rights, and Human Rights: A General view" New York Univ. Press 3-, 1981

12 A. Gewirth, "Reason and Morality" Univ. of Chicago Press 42-47, 1978

13 J. Bentham, "Pannomial Fragment in Bentham’s Works" 3 : 181-, 1843

14 J. S. Mill, "On liberty in Collected Works of J. S. Mill vol.ⅩⅧ: Essays on Politics and Society Part I" Univ. of Toronto Press 228-, 1969

15 R. M. Hare, "Moral Thinking, Its Levels, Method and point" Clarendon Press 156-, 1981

16 F. A. Hayek, "Law, Legislation and Liberty" I : 55-71, 1973

17 Ph. Petit, "Judging Justice" Routridge & Kegan Paul 118-128, 1980

18 A. Gewirth, "Human Rights: Essays on Justification and Applications" Univ. of Chicago Press 41-, 1982

19 D. Lyons, "Human Rights and the General Welfare in Philosophy and Public Affairs, no.6" Blackwell Publishing 121-, 1977

20 H. L. A, "Hart, Rawls on Liberty and its Priority" Univ. of Chicago Law Review 534-555, 1973

21 J. C. Harsanyi, "Essays on Ethics, Social Behavior, and Scientific Method" D. Reidel Publishing Co 1-85, 1976

22 H. L. A. Hart, "Between Utility and Rights" 79 (79): 829-831, 1979

23 H. L. A. Hart, "Bentham on Legal Rights in Oxford Essays in Jurisprudence" Oxford 1973

24 R. Nozick, "Anarchy, State, and Utopia" Basic Books 28-33, 1974

25 J. Bentham, "An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation" Kessinger Publishing 266-, 2005

26 J. Rawls, "A Theory of Justice" Harvard Univ. Press 1971

27 A. A. Morris, "A Differential of Human Rights" in Nomos 158-, 1981