Chunchuopae' means five supreme rulers in Chunchu era. The visual angles which count five supreme rulers are not in accord in some cases. But generally, they mean the Duke of 'Hwan' in Je country, the Duke of 'Mun' in Jin country, the Duke of 'Yang' i...
Chunchuopae' means five supreme rulers in Chunchu era. The visual angles which count five supreme rulers are not in accord in some cases. But generally, they mean the Duke of 'Hwan' in Je country, the Duke of 'Mun' in Jin country, the Duke of 'Yang' in Song country, the Duke of 'Mok' in Jin country, and the Duke of 'Jang' in Cho country.
At the above Duke, the Duke of 'Hwan' in Je country and the Duke of 'Mun' in Jin country were evaluated contrary by Confucius. As the feudal lords of Je country and jin country, they were the supreme rulers at this time. But they were not the Emperor of an empire. So, they had the obligation to respect against the Emperor and an empire. Therefore, we have to examine whether they respect Ju country or not, whether they rule their people with force or not, and whether they rule their people with the principles of royalty or not. After that, we have to distinguish whether they were the royal ruler or they were the supreme ruler. This paper states frankly essay on actions which do duties faithfully at own position with these ways. This paper has meaning to make clear the reasons which Confucius evaluates the Duke of 'Hwan' in Je country as the honest and undeceivable man and the Duke of 'Mun' in Jin country as the deceivable and unfair man. And this paper has meaning to make clear the origin with the articles in『Chunchu』and『Chunchujwajeon』.
Confucius' evaluations against actions which do duties faithfully at their position of the Duke of 'Hwan' in Je country and the Duke of 'Mun' in Jin country, the feudal lords of Chunchu era were contrary to the logic of the power. On counting strong degrees, the Duke of 'Mun' in Jin country ruled better than the Duke of 'Hwan' in Je country and the strength of Jin country was continued long. Confucius, however, didn't evaluate the Feudal Lords in placing the focus on the strong power.
It was proved that the Duke of 'Hwan' in Je country was the man who possess a capacious mind in putting 'Gwan-jung', the minister of the enemy into an important position. It was high evaluation that the Duke of 'Hwan' in Je country achieved the harmony of the upper position and the low position showing the politics which loves the small country and the politics which respects the Emperor through 'Gwan-jung'. While, even though the Duke of 'Mun' in Jin country was troubled with his stepmother and displayed his political capacity with living in exile, he killed his nephew and assumed authority in the process of being the Feudal Lord. So, even the merits which the Duke of 'Mun' promote the strong power in Jin country, Confucius judged that it doesn't conform with actions which do Duties faithfully at his position.
Confucius only emphasized justice and injustice about two feudal lords. But we don't matter to look on actions which two feudal lords do duties faithfully at their position as impartiality because the seat which is called the feudal lord was placed on the fifth 'Yin'(the negative) and the second 'Yang'(the positive) in the middle of 'Yukhyo'( symbols are made up six signs ) in 『the Book of Changes』in relation to the Emperor and was placed on the fifth 'Yang'(the positive) and the second 'Yin'(the negative) in relation to the ministers or the small countries. The undeceivable actions and unfair actions don't speak for justice and deceit. If we compared with two feudal lords, the Duke of 'Hwan' in Je country could verge on impartiality more than the Duke of 'Mun' in Jin country.
Confucius' evaluations on the Duke of 'Hwan' in Je country and the Duke of 'Mun' in Jin country are full of suggestions educationally the moderns who are interested with gaining power unconditionally in the tendency which takes a serious view of results.