종합부동산세와 재산세 간 이중과세조정의 쟁점과 평가 = Research on the Double Taxation Adjustment in Comprehensive Real Estate Holding Tax and Property Tax

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This study aims to summarize changes and issues in the double taxation adjustment between comprehensive real estate holding tax and property tax, and to evaluate its appropriateness. Specifically, an evaluation model for the current system is designed and a simulation is attempted. The results are as follows. First, the property tax deduction method under the current comprehensive real estate holding tax law is subject to excessive deduction as the actual deduction rate slightly exceeds the alternative level based on the individual deduction method if the number of real estates is large given the total price of them. Second, the degree of excessive deduction changes from an increase to a decrease around a certain total price even if the number of real estates is the same. Third, when the total price of real estates is the same, the higher the number of them, the smaller the price per real estate, so the proportion of the tax base subject to the lower tax rate increases, and the effective property tax rate tends to decrease to a certain point of the total price. These results show that the current double taxation adjustment between comprehensive real estate holding tax and property tax exhibits different patterns in the deduction rate and effective property tax rate depending on the total price of real estates or the number of them, thus undermining the equity of taxpayers' tax burden. The main reason is that the current double taxation adjustment between comprehensive real estate holding tax and property tax is designed based on the total price of real estates owned by the same taxpayer under the comprehensive real estate holding tax system. Therefore, considering the purpose of introducing each tax item, it will be necessary to redesign the current double taxation adjustment based on the price of each real estate rather than the total price of real estates.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 박훈, "현행 종합부동산세의 내용과 그 문제점" 한국세법학회 12 (12): 35-72, 2006

2 김승대, "헌법학강론" 법문사 2017

3 마정화, "최근 종합부동산세 환급 논란과 시사점" 15-23, 2019

4 김태호, "지방세법상 취득세의 취득개념과 과세물건에 관한 연구" 한국세무학회 25 (25): 67-100, 2008

5 관계부처합동, "주택시장 안정대책"

6 관계부처합동, "주택시장 안정 보완대책"

7 김민수, "종합부동산세와 재산세의 이중과세조정제도" 한국세무사회 부설 한국조세연구소 9 (9): 233-281, 2020

8 오문성, "종합부동산세와 재산세의 이중과세조정에 관한 소고(小考) - 대법원 2015.6.23. 선고 2012두2986판결을 중심으로 -" 한국세무학회 33 (33): 167-199, 2016

9 서보국, "종합부동산세와 재산세의 이중과세 문제" 법학연구소 28 (28): 37-68, 2017

10 이동식, "종합부동산세법의 헌법합치성에 관한 소고" 한국세법학회 13 (13): 414-440, 2007

11 김영우, "종합부동산세법의 입법적 문제점 및 개선방안" 한국세무학회 23 (23): 155-188, 2006

12 관계부처합동, "실수요 보호와 단기 투요 억제를 통한 주택시장 안정화 방안"

13 "대한민국법원 종합법률정보"

14 "국가법령정보센터"