上海시기 玉觀彬 밀정설에 대한 비판적 검토 = Critical Review of the Ok Guan-bin Secret Spy Suspicion in the Shanghai Era of Independence Movement

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Due to young patriot Ok Guan-bin, famous for the 105-personnel incident, took asylum in Shanghai, where he was made to be implicated in a secret spy suspicion and was finally killed by an Independence Movement group. The suspicion over Ok Guan-bin secret agent traces back to around 1915 when he was released after serving a four-year term in prison due to involvement in the 105 Personnel Incident in Korea. The secret agent suspicion arose from the fact that while imprisoned, he was orchestrated by the Imperial Japanese to declare ideological transfer together with Yun Chi-ho, An Tae-guk and Yang Gi-tak, and that after released from the prison, he worked with a Japanese company.
After March 1, 1919Independence Movement incident, Ok Guan-bin arrived in Shangahi, he was suspected as a secret spy of the Japanese Government of Korea. It would not be denied that such suspicion was raised due to the excessive political struggle and regionalism of independence activists operating in Shanghai. Many independence activists gathered in Shanghai, and they had to get involved in conflicts due to different regions from which they came, and different political lines. They suspected people from different regions or with different political lines as secret agents. Also, Ok Guan-bin with outstanding competence and strong showmanship created many enemies. This led Ok Guan-bin to be attacked as a secret spy for Japanese by his opponents. Although Ok Guan-bin was engrossed in businesses and religious activities, distancing himself from Independence Movements, except for the early period of Provisional Government of the Republic of Korea in Shaghai, there is no evidence to prove that he had reason or motivation to be a secret spy.
A Korean Anarchist group, after Ok Guan-bin died, disclosed his crime, but no direct evidences for such insistence can be found. Ok Guan-bin refused their request to provide funds for their Independence Movements, and openly criticized their excessive revolutionary line, thereby probably leading them to falsely brand him as a secret agent. The process of Ok Guan-bin being suspected as a secret agent and made as such shows the stark reality of the political struggle and regionalism within the Shanghai Independence Movement camp. Also, he was probably falsely branded as a secret agent as he refused to provide Independence Movement fund to Independence Movement groups, amid conflicts surrounding independence activities, leading them to condemn him. The secret spy suspicion surrounding Ok Guan-bin and his assassination reveal the complicatedness of the Shanghai Korean Society and Independence Movement camp.

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Due to young patriot Ok Guan-bin, famous for the 105-personnel incident, took asylum in Shanghai, where he was made to be implicated in a secret spy suspicion and was finally killed by an Independence Movement group. The suspicion over Ok Guan-bin secret agent traces back to around 1915 when he was released after serving a four-year term in prison due to involvement in the 105 Personnel Incident in Korea. The secret agent suspicion arose from the fact that while imprisoned, he was orchestrated by the Imperial Japanese to declare ideological transfer together with Yun Chi-ho, An Tae-guk and Yang Gi-tak, and that after released from the prison, he worked with a Japanese company.
After March 1, 1919Independence Movement incident, Ok Guan-bin arrived in Shangahi, he was suspected as a secret spy of the Japanese Government of Korea. It would not be denied that such suspicion was raised due to the excessive political struggle and regionalism of independence activists operating in Shanghai. Many independence activists gathered in Shanghai, and they had to get involved in conflicts due to different regions from which they came, and different political lines. They suspected people from different regions or with different political lines as secret agents. Also, Ok Guan-bin with outstanding competence and strong showmanship created many enemies. This led Ok Guan-bin to be attacked as a secret spy for Japanese by his opponents. Although Ok Guan-bin was engrossed in businesses and religious activities, distancing himself from Independence Movements, except for the early period of Provisional Government of the Republic of Korea in Shaghai, there is no evidence to prove that he had reason or motivation to be a secret spy.
A Korean Anarchist group, after Ok Guan-bin died, disclosed his crime, but no direct evidences for such insistence can be found. Ok Guan-bin refused their request to provide funds for their Independence Movements, and openly criticized their excessive revolutionary line, thereby probably leading them to falsely brand him as a secret agent. The process of Ok Guan-bin being suspected as a secret agent and made as such shows the stark reality of the political struggle and regionalism within the Shanghai Independence Movement camp. Also, he was probably falsely branded as a secret agent as he refused to provide Independence Movement fund to Independence Movement groups, amid conflicts surrounding independence activities, leading them to condemn him. The secret spy suspicion surrounding Ok Guan-bin and his assassination reveal the complicatedness of the Shanghai Korean Society and Independence Movement camp.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 柳永益, "李承晩 東文 書翰集 下" 연세대출판부 2009

2 李庭植, "혁명가들의 항일회상" 민음사 1988

3 박찬승, "한국근대정치사상사연구 : 민족주의 우파의 실력양성운동론" 역사비평사 1992

4 조영록, "일제 강점기 杭州 高麗寺의 재발견과 重建籌備會" 한국근현대사학회 (53) : 40-72, 2010

5 국사편찬위원회, "일본외무성외교사료관 소장 한국관계사료목록"

6 김상태, "윤치호 일기 : 한 지식인의 내면세계를 통해 본 식민지시기" 역사비평사 2001

7 鄭華岩, "어느 아나키스트의 몸으로 쓴 근세사" 자유문고 1992

8 이호룡, "아나키스트들의 민족해방운동" 한국독립운동사연구소 2008

9 오영섭, "상해 임정내 이승만 통신원들의 활동" 한국민족운동사학회 (52) : 143-202, 2007

10 "삼천리"

11 김도형, "대한민국임시정부의 친일파 처단과 의열투쟁, In 大韓民國臨時政府 樹立80周年 紀念論文集 (下)" 國家報勳處 1999

12 禹昇圭, "나절로漫筆" 探求堂 1978

13 국사편찬위원회, "韓民族獨立運動史資料集 2, In 105人事件公判始末書 2" 1986

14 國會圖書館, "韓國民族運動史料(中國篇)" 1976

15 金昌淑, "躄翁七十三年回想記, In 心山遺稿 卷五" 國史編纂委員會 1973

16 "申報"

17 김광재, "玉觀彬의 상해 망명과 활동" 한국근현대사학회 (59) : 46-78, 2011

18 "獨立新聞"

19 "海潮音"

20 黃夏年, "民國佛敎期刊文獻集成" 全國圖書館文獻縮微複製中心 2006

21 "東亞日報"

22 金正明, "朝鮮獨立運動 2" 東京 : 原書房 1967

23 "朝鮮日報"

24 "新韓民報"

25 도산안창호선생전집편찬위원회, "島山安昌浩全集 제4권 일기" 2000

26 "不逞團關係雜件"

27 柳基石, "三十年 放浪記 : 유기석 회고록" 국가보훈처 2010

28 김광재, "2012년 7월 22일 서울 익선동 자택"

29 윤경로, "105인 사건 피의자들의 사건 이후 행적에 관한 소고 - 친일로 경도된 9인을 대상으로-" 한국기독교역사학회 36 (36): 91-156, 2012

30 윤경로, "105人事件과 新民會 硏究" 일지사 1990