에지워스의 교환 이론은 왜 잊혔나? = Why Was Edgeworth`s Theory of Exchange Disregarded

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

An ingenious theory of exchange was developed in Edgeworth`s work titled Mathematical Psychics published in 1881. The theory, however, failed to be accepted. Its core concepts such as ‘recontract’ and ‘final settlement’ had been disregarded and forgotten until Shubik (1959) appreciated them. The failure is partly ascribable to Edgeworth himself. He should have critically assorted and evaluated other theories of exchange in comparison with his. He should have fully explicated and elaborated his concepts in comparison with comparable ones. Mathematical Psychics was deficient in putting forward the author`s extraordinary concepts and theory.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Jevons, W. S., 6 (6): 581-583, 1881

2 김진방, "제번스의 교환이론: 모색과 혼란" 한국경제학회 59 (59): 175-203, 2011

3 김진방, "공급과 수요 그리고 윌리엄 손톤" 한국사회경제학회 (36) : 75-120, 2011

4 김진방, "경제의 교양을 읽는다: 현대편" 더난출판 2014

5 Walras, L, "Éléments d'Économie Politique Pure, ou Théorie de la Richesse Sociale" L. Corbaz & cie 1874

6 Walker, D. A., "Walras’s Market Model" Cambridge University Press 1996

7 Walker, D. A., "Walrasian Economics" Cambridge University Press 2006

8 Mill, J. S., "Thornton on Labour and Its Claims, Part I" 29 : 505-518, 1869

9 Jevons, W, "Theory of Political Economy" Macmillan & co 1871

10 Jevons, W. S, "Theory of Political Economy" Macmillan & co 1879

11 von Neumann, J, "Theory of Games and Economic Behavior" Princeton University Press 1944

12 Edgeworth, F. Y., "The Theory of International Values: Parts I, II and III" 4 (4): 35-50, 1894

13 Hurwicz, L., "The Theory of Economic Behavior" 35 (35): 909-925, 1945

14 Green, J. R., "The Stability of Edgeworth’s Recontracting Process" 42 (42): 21-34, 1974

15 Edgeworth, F. Y., "The Rationale of Exchange" 47 (47): 165-166, 1884

16 Edgeworth, F. Y., "The Pure Theory of Taxation: Parts I, II and III" 7 (7): 46-70, 1897

17 Marshall, "The Pure Theory of Foreign Trade" 1879

18 Bowley, A, "The Mathematical Groundwork of Economics" Clarendon Press 1924

19 Edgeworth, F. Y., "The Hedonical Calculus" 4 (4): 391-408, 1978

20 Edgeworth, F. Y., "Some New Methods of Measuring Variation in General Price" 51 : 346-368, 1888

21 Cournot, A, "Récherches sur les Principes Mathématiques de la Théorie des Richesses" Chez L. Hachette 1838

22 Marshall, A., "Review of F. Y. Edgeworth’s Mathematical Psychics" 457-, 1881

23 Feldman, A. M., "Recontracting Stability" 42 (42): 35-44, 1974

24 Jenkin, F., "Recess Studies" Edmonston and Douglas 1870

25 Mill, J. S, "Principles of Political Economy" J. Parker 1852

26 Mill, J, "Principles of Political Economy" J. Parker 1848

27 Stigler, G., "Perfect Competition, Historically Contemplated" 65 (65): 1-17, 1957

28 Edgeworth, F, "Papers Relating to Political Economy" Macmillan 1925

29 Edgeworth, F. Y., "Osservazioni Sulla Teoria Matematica dell'Economia Politica con Riguardo Speciale ai Principi di Economia Politica di Alfredo Marshall" 2 (2): 233-245, 1891

30 Thornton, W, "On Labour: Its Wrongful Claims and Rightful Dues, Its Actual Present and Possible Future" Macmillan 1870

31 Thornton, W, "On Labour: Its Wrongful Claims and Rightful Dues, Its Actual Present and Possible Future" Macmillan 1869

32 Carlyle, T., "Occasional Discourse on the Negro Question" 40 (40): 670-679, 1989

33 Edgeworth, F, "New and Old Methods of Ethics: Or ‘Physical Ethics’ and ‘Methods of Ethics’" J. Parker & Co 1877

34 Marschak, J., "Neumann’s and Morgenstern’s New Approach to Static Economics" 54 (54): 97-115, 1946

35 Edgeworth, F, "Mathematical Psyhics: An Essay on the Application of Mathematics to the Moral Sciences" C. Kegan Paul & co 1881

36 Whewell, W., "Mathematical Exposition of Some Doctrines of Political Economy-second Memoir" 9 (9): 128-149, 1850

37 Pareto, V, "Manuale di Economia Politica con una Introduzione alla Scienza" Societa Editrice Libraria 1906

38 Fawcett, H, "Manual of Political Economy" Macmillan 1863

39 Edgeworth, F. Y., "La Teoria Pura del Monopolio" 40 : 13-31, 1897

40 Schumpeter, J. A., "History of Economic Analysis" Oxford University Press 1954

41 Hildenbrand, W., "Francis Ysidro Edgeworth: Perfect Competition and the Core" 37 (37): 477-490, 1993

42 Newman, P., "F. Y. Edgeworth: Mathematical Psychics and Further Essays on Political Economy" Oxford University Press 2003

43 Keynes, J, "Essays in Biography" Macmillan & co 1933

44 Marshall, A, "Economics of Industry" Macmillan & co 1879

45 Shubik, M., "Annals of Mathematical Studies" Princeton University Press 40-, 1959