국제법학방법으로서의 ‘국제법에 대한 제3세계의 접근' = TWAIL as a Method of International Law

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

As a keynote speech an Academic Conference held under the subject of "Three World and International Law", this essay tries to make an expository description of the TWAIL(Third World Approaches to International Law) postulating it as a method of international law. The first matter to be made clear for such a description is "what the third world is". The words "third world" are used in different meaning in different contexts. However, for the TWAIL as a method of international law, what is important is not the "existence of unproblematic monolithic category" but the "existence of a
group of states and populations" which deem themselves as third world, as professor Okafor emphasizes.
According to the time when it appeared, TWAIL is classified as TWAIL I and TWAIL II. TWAIL I appeared in the circumstances of decolonization. In that sense, the Bandung Conference in 1955 is called as the birth place of the TWAIL I. TWAIL II is said to have originated from meeting of graduate students at the Harvard Law School in 1996. Therefore, TWAIL II is 40 years later than TWAIL I. At that time, European colonialism seem to have disappeared from international society. Nonetheless, as a matter of fact, it maintained its life as neo-colonialism. The TWAIL II wanted to
expose and criticize this (neo-)colonialism deeply rooted in international law.
In the next part of the expository description, main assertions of the TWAIL I and TWAIL II are introduced. TWAIL's relation with other methods of international law and methods of law is reviewed also. It is explained that among many methods of international law TWAIL especially criticizes and objects to the 19th century legal positivism and its successors. The fact that the TWAIL borrows much from methods of law such as history of law, Marxist theory of law, and economic analysis of law is mentioned. The influence of structuralism and post modernism on the TWAIL and the commonality among the TWAIL and Critical Legal Studies, New Approaches to International Law, Critical Race Theory and LatCrit(Latina and Latino Critical Legal Theory) are also pointed out.

목차 (Table of Contents)

• Ⅰ. 머리말
• Ⅱ. ʻ제3세계ʼ의 개념
• Ⅲ. 제3세계 국제법론의 등장시기와 상황
• Ⅳ. 제3세계 국제법론의 국제법관
• Ⅴ. 제3세계 국제법론의 방법적
• Ⅵ. 국제법과 국제법학의 목적과 임무
• Ⅶ. 맺음말

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 이중범, "제3세계와 국제법의 발전" 단국대학교 법학연구소 12 (12): 73-82, 1982

2 김성원, "이스트팔리아 질서(Eastphalian Order)의 출현 가능성에 관한 연구" 대한국제법학회 56 (56): 63-85, 2011

3 한인섭, "미국법을 지배하는 지적 흐름:비판법학" 20 : 93-, 1997

4 양건, "미국 법사상에서의 급진주의적 흐름 －1920,30년대의 법현실주의운동과 1970년대후반 이래의 비판법학운동－" 8 : 7-, 1985

5 오시진, "근대 국제법상 문명론에 대한 비판적고찰" 고려대학교 2014

6 박배근, "국제법학방법의 서설적 고찰" 국제법평론회 (40) : 1-21, 2014

7 Antony Anghie, "mperialism,Sovereignty and the Making of International Law" Cambridge University Press 52-53, 2005

8 Makau Mutua, "Whatis TWAIL?" 94 : 35-, 2000

9 Chimi, "Towards a Third World Approach to Non-Intervention: Through the Labyrinth of Western Doctrine" 20 : 1980

10 Frederick E. Snyder, "Third World Attitudes TowardInternational Law" Martinus Nijhoff Publishers 1987

11 R.P. Anand, "Third World Attitudes Toward International Law" Martinus Nijhoff Publishers 7-, 1987

12 B.S. Chimni, "Third World Approaches to International Law:A Manifesto" 8 (8): 4-7, 2006

13 Anthony Anghie, "Third World Approaches to International Law and Individual Responsibility in Internal Conflict" Williams S. Hein& Co.,Inc. 185-, 2006

14 Antony Anghie, "Third World Approaches to International Law and Individual Responsibility in Internal Conflict" 36 : 189-, 2004

15 B.S. Chimni, "The World of TWAIL: Introduction to the Special Issue" 3 (3): 18-19, 2011

16 David Kennedy, "The TWAIL Conference: Keynote Address-Albany,New York-April 2007" 9 : 336-337, 2007

17 WangTieya, "The Structure and process of international law: essays in legalphilosophy doctrine and theory" Nijhoff 956-, 1983

18 L. Oppenheim, "The Science of International Law: Its Task and Method" 2 (2): 314-, 1908

19 Steven R. Ratner, "The Methods of International Law" Williams S. Hein & Co.,Inc. 185-210, 2006

20 G. Schwarzenberger, "The Inductive Approach to International Law" 60 (60): 539-, 1947

21 J. T. Gathii, "TWAIL: A Brief History of its Origins,its Decentralized Network and a Tentative Bibliography" 3 (3): 28-, 2011

22 "Symposium on Method in International Law" 93 (93): 291-423, 1999

23 Karin Mickelson, "Rhetoric and Rage:Third World Voices in International Legal Discourse" 16 : 358-, 1998

24 James H. Mittelman, "Out From Underdevelopment Revisited: Changing Global Structures and the Remaking of the Third World" 23-, 1997

25 Obiora Chinedu Okafor, "Newness,Imperialism,and International Legal Reform in Our Time: A Twail Perspective" 43 (43): 174-, 2005

26 Balakrishnan Rajagopal, "Locating the Third World in Cultural Geography" 1-2, 1999

27 Antony Anghie, "Lat Crit and Twail" 42 : 311-320, 2012

28 Pae Keun Park, "Korea and TWAIL: Does She Fitinto the Picture?" 1 (1): 51-, 2013

29 B.S. Chimni, "International Law and World Order: A Critique of Contemporary Approaches" Sage Publications 21-, 1993

30 "Declaration on the Establishment of a New International Economic Order"

31 Obiora Chinedu Okafor, "Critical Third World Approaches to International Law(TWAIL):Theory,Methodology,or Both" 10 (10): 371-378, 2008

32 "Correspondence" 94 (94): 99-100, 2000

33 "Charter of Economic Rights and Duties of States"

34 B.S. Chimni, "Capitalism,Imperialism,and International Law in the Twenty-First Century" 14 (14): 17-46, 2012

35 Luis Eslava, "Between Resistance and Reform: TWAIL and the Universality of International Law" 3 (3): 104-, 2011