학교수학적 지식의 성장: 고등학교 영재 학생들의 위키(Wiki) 기반 협력 문제해결 활동을 중심으로 = The growth of school mathematics: Korean secondary gifted students' collaborative problem solving using the Wiki

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

In this study, I strive to design a collaborative learning model of Wikis, which can embed ESMCE(Educational Setting for Mathematical Creation and Errors) in collective metal space where secondary gifted students are able to work collaboratively on math problems beyond a classroom. By applying the design, this study aims to identify students' collaborative patterns in MKB(mathematical knowledge building) process and design factors of the Wiki, which facilitate educational situation to operate for collaborative mathematics problem solving in the Wiki system, and to increase understanding of the secondary gifted students' collaborative mathematics problem solving in virtual environment.
In designing this experiment, I draw on dynamics of errors as ``an organizing power of reality'' (Thom, 1992). To gradually induce students' collaboration on mathematical problem solving based on finding-error activities, I used 3 types of problems; the 1st type of ECS(Explicitly Contradictory Situation), the 2nd type of ECS, ICS(Implicitly Contradictory Situation) Participants were 14 Korean secondary gifted students, who enrolled in calculus II courses in one of gifted institutions in Korea, and their math teacher.
The findings of this study suggest that Wikis are applicable to building online Mathematical Community of Inquiry beyond classrooms for Korean secondary gifted students. The patterns emergent in students’ collaborative mathematical knowledge building process are identified as scattered form and double helix form. The double helix form consists of an axis of refutation(RFT)-agreement(AGMT) and an axis of fix(FIX)-supplement(SUPPL). I conclude that the mechanism of growing SM is solutions and refutations following the double helix form, which is very similar to the pattern of “Conjectures and Refutations”(Lakatos, 1976).
Despite that most participants had difficulty in using LaTeX for mathematical expressions, this study shows that Wikis are valuable tools for providing Korean secondary students opportunities to learn social virtue such as “humility and courage”(Lampert, 1990), which have been neglected in Korean educational environment but emphasized as precious for doing mathematics in the field of mathematics education.

국문 초록 (Abstract)

본 연구는 수학 수업에서 온라인 탐구 커뮤니티의 건설을 시도함으로써 개별화된 경쟁에 치우쳐 있는 우리나라 수학교육 환경에서도 고등학교 영재 학생들에게 수학 발전의 사회적 과정을 경험할 수 있는 기회를 제공하는 것을 목표로 하였다. 2012년 B과학고등학교에서 개설된 두 개의 미적분학 II 강좌를 수강하였던 14명의 학생들이 약 70일간 위키를 협력 문제해결 도구로 사용하여 지정된 위키 사이트에 접속하여 10개의 문제를 풀었다. 위키는 학생들의 흩어져 있는 사고과정을 공유되는 세계 내에 효과적으로 집적함으로써 상호학습이 이루어지는 것을 가능하게 하였다. 또한 학생들의 협력 문제해결의 패턴은 Lakatos(1976)의 증명과 반박과 비슷하게 ‘풀이와 반박’으로 특징지어졌는데 학생들은 이 과정을 통해 학교수학적 지식의 성장을 경험할 수 있었다. 실험 종료 후 실시된 인터뷰와 설문조사에서 담당교사와 학생들은 협력 문제해결 도구로서의 위키의 사용 경험에 대해 매우 긍정적인 반응을 보였다. 따라서 본 연구에서 위키는 수학적 지식의 사회적 측면을 경험하게 할 수 있는 가치 있는 수학교육 도구라고 평가되었다.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 이승우, "학교수학이란 무엇인가?" 대한수학교육학회 25 (25): 381-405, 2015

2 Cobb, P., "Where Is the mind? constructivist and sociocultural perspectives on mathematical development" 23 (23): 13-20, 1994

3 Lampert, M., "When the problem is not the question and the solution is not the answer:Mathematical knowing and teaching" 27 (27): 29-63, 1990

4 Ben-Zvi, D., "Using wiki to promote collaborative learning in statistics education" 1 (1): 1-18, 2007

5 Peterson, E., "Using a wiki to enhance cooperative learning in a real analysis course" 19 (19): 18-28, 2009

6 Clinkenbeard, P. R., "Unfair expectations: A pilot study of middle school students'comparisons of gifted and regular classes" 15 (15): 56-63, 1991

7 Ruth, A., "The wiki way of learning" 25 (25): 135-152, 2009

8 Lee, S., "The growth of school mathematics:Korean secondary gifted students' collaborative problem solving using the Wiki" University of Missouri- Columbia 2014

9 Kennedy, D. A., "The effect of group composition on gifted and non-gifted elemenary students in cooperative learning groups" National Research Center on the Gifted and Talented, University of Connecticut 1995

10 Eisner, E. W., "The educational imagination:On the design and evaluation of school program" Macmillan 2001

11 Diezmann, C. M., "The collaboration of mathematically gifted students on challenging tasks" 25 (25): 7-31, 2001

12 Sheehy, G., "The Wiki as knowledge repository: Using a Wiki in a community of practice to strengthen K-12 education" 52 (52): 55-60, 2008

13 Reich, J., "The State of Wiki Usage in U. S. K–12 Schools" 41 (41): 7-15, 2012

14 Williams, K. S., "The Red Book of Mathematical Problems" Dover Publications 1988

15 Krutetskii, V. A., "The Psychology of Mathematical Abilities in Schoolchildren" University of Chicago Press 1976

16 Stahl, G., "Supporting group cognition in an online math community: A cognitive tool for small-group referencing in text chat" 35 (35): 103-122, 2006

17 Zemel, A., "Studying Virtual Math Teams Vol. 11" Springer 421-450, 2009

18 Stahl, G., "Studying Virtual Math Teams" Springer Science + Business Media 505-527, 2009

19 Wee, J. D., "Studying Virtual Math Teams" Springer Science + Business Media 475-497, 2009

20 Stahl, G., "Studying Virtual Math Teams" Springer Science + Business Media 7-16, 2009

21 Stahl, G., "Studying Virtual Math Teams" Springer Science + Business Media 3-6, 2009

22 Sarmiento-Klapper, J. W., "Studying Virtual Math Teams" Springer Science + Business Media 83-98, 2009

23 Fuks, H., "Studying Virtual Math Teams" Springer Science + Business Media 373-398, 2009

24 Hurme, T., "Students’ activity in computer-supported collaborative problem solving in mathematics" 10 (10): 49-73, 2005

25 Litz, I. R., "Student adoption of a Computer-Supported Collaborative Learning (CSCL)mathematical problem solving environment: The case of The Math Forum's Virtual Math Team (VMT) chat service" Nova Southeastern University 2007

26 Lave, J., "Situated learning:Legitimate peripheral participation (Learning in doing: Social, cognitive and computational perspectives)" Cambridge University Press 1991

27 Bruffee, K. A., "Sharing our toys - Cooperative learning versus collaborative learning" 12-18, 1995

28 Robinson, A., "Response to Slavin : Cooperation, consistency, and challenge for academically talented youth" 14 (14): 31-36, 1990

29 Slavin, R. E., "Response to Robinson:Cooperative learning and the gifted: Who benefits?" 14 (14): 28-30, 1990

30 Garrison, D. R., "Researching the community of inquiry framework : Review, issues, and future directions" 10 (10): 157-172, 2007

31 Patrick, H., "Reconsidering the issue of cooperative learning with gifted students" 29 (29): 90-108, 2005

32 Lakatos, I., "Proofs and refutations: The logic of mathematical discovery" Cambridge University Press 1976

33 NCTM, "Professional standards for teaching mathematics" The National Council of Teachers of Mathematics 1991

34 Nason, R., "Online Collborative Learning: Theory and Practice" Information Science Publishing 103-131, 2004

35 Nason, R., "New ways of learning mathematics: Are we ready for it?" 2002

36 Boaler, J., "Multiple perspectives on mathematics teaching and learning" Alblex Publishing 171-200, 2000

37 Lerman, S., "Multiple perspectives on mathematics teaching and learning" Alblex Publishing 19-44, 2000

38 Matthews, M., "Meaningful cooperative learning is key" 50 (50): 64-, 1993

39 Wee, J. D., "Mathematical knowledge construction through the use of guided collaborative critique in a quasi-synchronous chat environment" 2007

40 Thom, R., "Mathematical Research Today and Tomorrow:Viewpoints of Seven Fields Medalists" Springer-Verlag 1-12, 1992

41 Barbeau, E. J., "Mathematical Fallcies, Flaws, and Flimflam" The Mathematical Association of America 2000

42 Reed, C. F., "Math education for gifted students" Prufrock Press 17-31, 2005

43 Carter, J. F., "Lines of communication : Using a wiki in a mathematics course" 19 (19): 1-17, 2009

44 Scardamalia, M., "Liberal Education in a Knowledge Society" Carus Publishing Company 67-98, 2002

45 Goos, M., "Learning mathematics in a classroom community of inquiry" 35 (35): 258-291, 2004

46 Moss, J., "Knowledge building in mathematics : Supporting collaborative learning in pattern problems" 1 (1): 441-465, 2006

47 Narasimhan, R., "Incorporating current research, wikis, and discussion lists in a mathematics capstone course" 19 (19): 29-38, 2009

48 Schoenfeld, A. H., "In fostering community of inquiry, must it matter that teacher knows“the answer”?" 16 (16): 11-16, 1996

49 Ormrod, J. E., "Human learning" Pearson Prentice Hall 2009

50 Kulik, J. A., "Handbook of gifted education" Allyn and Bacon 268-281, 2003

51 Webb, N. M., "Handbook of educational psychology" Macmillan 841-873, 1996

52 Robinson, A., "Handbook of Gifted Education" Allyn 282-292, 2003

53 Stahl, G., "Group Cognition: Computer Support for Building Collaborative Knowledge" MIT Press 2006

54 Li, A. K. F., "Gifted secondary students' preferred learning style: Cooperative, competitive, or individualistic?" 16 (16): 46-54, 1992

55 Nason, R., "Fostering authentic, sustained, and progressive mathematical knowledge-building activity in computer collaborative learning(CSCL)communities" 22 (22): 345-363, 2003

56 Kramarski, B., "Enhancing mathematical reasoning in the classroom : The effects of cooperative learning and metacognitive training" 40 (40): 281-310, 2003

57 Goos, M., "Do it this way!Metacognitive strategies in collaborative mathematical problem solving" 30 (30): 229-260, 1996

58 Garrison, D. R., "Critical thinking, cognitive presence, and computer conferencing in distance education" 15 (15): 7-23, 2001

59 Oxford, R. L., "Cooperative learning, collaborative learning, and interaction : Three communicative strands in the language classroom" 81 (81): 443-456, 1997

60 Neber, H., "Cooperative learning with gifted and highachieving students : A review and meta-analyses of 12 studies" 12 (12): 199-214, 2001

61 Olsen, R. E. W. B., "Cooperative language learning: A teacher's resource book" Prentice Hall 1-30, 1992

62 Slavin, R. E., "Cooperative Learning" 50 (50): 315-342, 1980

63 Robinson, A., "Cooperation or exploitation? The argument against cooperative learning for talented students" 14 (14): 9-27, 1990

64 Popper, K., "Conjectures and refutations: The growth of scientific knowledge" Routledge Classics 2002

65 Brett, C., "Communities of inquiry among pre-service teachers investigating mathematics" 3 (3): 39-62, 2002

66 Swan, M., "Collaborative learning in mathematics: A challenge to our beliefs and practices" Redlin 2002

67 Brandon, D. P., "Collaborative learning and computer-supported groups" 48 (48): 109-126, 1999

68 Scardamalia, M., "Cambridge handbook of the learning sciences" Cambridge University Press 97-118, 2006

69 Koschmann, T., "CSCL: Theory and practice of an emerging paradigm" Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Publishers 1-23, 1996

70 Davidson, N., "An overview of research on cooperative learning related to mathematics" 22 (22): 362-365, 1991

71 Johnson, D. W., "Active learning : Cooperation in the college classroom. Edina" Interaction book company 1991

72 Slavin, R. E., "Ability grouping, cooperative learning and the gifted" 14 (14): 3-8, 1990

73 Reynolds, B. E., "A practical guide to cooperative learning in collegiate mathematics (Vol. 37)" The Mathematical Association of America 1995