중소기업의 노동법규제적용제외에 관한 비교연구 = A Comparative Study on the Small-Business Exemption under the Labor Law

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This study has been begun based on the critical mind that the exemption to below a certain scale enterprises or businesses might be necessary to pushfully accept to increase the practicality of the application of labor law. First of all, by making a hypothesis that the exemption need to be accepted by the character of restriction target and difference of hired restrict method the study has been verified by foreign law before starting full-fledged study. And we verified what kind of rationale of justification is suggested in exemptions of each country.
In short about this study's conclusions, examples that implement flexible management of regulations or exemption under the labor law is much more than other countries(especially Germany) in American law, but the main rationale is the theory of business burden. Besides in America, it is required to consider impact on small businesses from the law that will be enacted at enactment step by Small Business Regulatory Fairness Enforcement Act etc. Also we can get a sense of that the theory of business burden has a important meaning in America through this point.
As we know from German examples, if the law determine exemption based on enterprise scale․business scale, point that it violates the principle of equality or not occurs unavoidably about happening differences for legal protections between workers that work at different scale enterprises or businesses. Thinking that show up German precedent could be a reference when our country institutes exemption.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 24 (24): 2002-, 2003

2 大內伸哉, "勞働安全衛生に關する勞働者代表(上)" (235) : 1995

3 하경효, "해고보호제도의 유연성과 실효성 제고방안" 2006

4 중소기업은행조정연구부, "중소기업 규제개혁과 경쟁력 강화방안" 2004

5 "독일연방헌법재판소홈페이지"

6 김희성, "노동사회의 변화와 노동법" 한국학술정보(주) 2007

7 임종률, "노동법" 박영사 2009

8 김형배, "노동법" 박영사 2011

9 국제노동법연구원, "근로기준법 적용의 합리화 방안 연구" 노동부 2007

10 한국노동법학회, "근로기준법 적용범위의 합리화 방안 연구" 노동부 2006

11 水町勇一郞, "集團の更生-アメリカ勞働法規制の歷史と理論" 有斐閣 2005

12 藤本茂, "米國雇用平等法の理念と法理" かもがわ出版 2007

13 西谷敏訳, "獨逸解雇制限法の現狀" 193 : 2000

14 大谷康夫, "平等への道-アフリカ系アメリカ人と最高裁" 彩流社 1993

15 大內伸哉, "中小企業に對する勞働法規制の適用除外に關する共同比較法硏究" (223) : 2008

16 大內伸哉, "中小企業に對する勞働法規制の適用除外 -イタリア" (226) : 2009

17 寺罔寬, "アメリカ中小企業論" 信山社 1997

18 寺罔寬, "アメリカの中小企業政策" 信山社 1990

19 Wolfgang Clement, "Zusammenfassung und Bewertung der Vorschläge der Kommission Moderne Dienstleistungen Am Arbeitsmarkt" 2002

20 B. Simpson, "Trade Union Recognition and the Law, a New Approach"

21 Marc Linder, "The Small-Business Exemption under the Fair Labor Standards Act: The "Original" Accumulation of Capital and the Inversion of Industrial Policy" 6 : 1998

22 Jeffrey A, "The Procedural Posture of Minimum Employee Thresholds in Federal Antidiscrimination Statutes" 2005

23 Esther Endres, "Schwellenwertregelungen im Arbeitsrecht"

24 European Commission, "Models to Reduce the Disproportionate Regulatory Burden on SMEs"

25 Lex K. Larson, "Larson's Workers' Compensation Law" Matthew Bender & Company 2008

26 Douglas L. Leslie, "Labor law in a Nutshell" West Group 2000

27 Weiss, "Labor law and industrial relations in the Federal Republic of Germany" Kluwer 1987

28 Bauer, "Kündigungsrecht"

29 Busemann, "Kündigung und Kündigungsschutz im Arbeitsverhältnis" Erich Schmidt Verlag 2006

30 Wolfgang Clement, "Hartz Ⅳ Menschen in Arbeit bringen" Bundes ministerium für Wirtschaft und Arbeit 2004

31 Lex K. Larson, "Employment Discrimination" Matthew Bender & Company 2008

32 B. Doyle, "Disability Discrimination,In The New Law" Jordan Publishing Bristol 1996

33 Klaus Adomeit, "Die Agenda 2010 und das Arbeitsrecht Eine Reform im Kampf gegen Widerstände"

34 GünterSchaub, "Arbeitsrechts Handbuch" 2007

35 Hanau, "Arbeitsrecht, Dreizehnte" Luchterhand 2005

36 Junker, "Arbeitsrecht zwischen Markt und gesellschaftspolitischen Herausforderungen,In Differenzierung nach Unternehmengröße? familiengerechte Strukturen" 2004

37 Henssler, "Arbeitsrecht Kommentar" Verlag Dr.Otto Schmidt Köln 2004

38 Brox, "Arbeitsrecht" Kohlhammer 2002

39 Christine Jolls, "Antidiscrimination and Accommodation" 115 : 642-, 2001

40 Press and Information Office of the Federal Government, "Agenda" 2004

41 Deutscher Gewerkschaftsbund, "Abteilung Arbeitsmarktpolitik und internationale Sozialpolitik"